Online version of TerraViva, the independent daily journal of the
World Social Forum

Versión online de TerraViva, el diario independiente del Foro Social Mundial

Inter Press Service - Home Page

World Social Forum - Porto Alegre , January 28, 2003



24/01/2003


25/01/2003


26/01/2003


27/01/2003


28/01/2003

Background


Terra Viva is an independent publication of IPS - Inter Press Service.

The opinions expressed in Terra Viva do not necessarily reflect the editorial views of IPS nor the official position of any of its sponsors.

IPS gratefully acknowledges the financial support received for this publication from: Novib Oxfam Netherlands and the Charles Stewart Mott Foundation.

The Commonwealth Foundation generously funded the participation of the following journalists:

Debra Anthony
Zarina Geloo
Marwaan Macan-Markar
Sanjay Suri
Kalinga Seneviratne


 

 


 

RIGHTING GLOBAL WRONGS
Complacency is No Virtue

By Aye Aye Win*

A sigh of relief as this year’s pilgrimage comes to an end. Full of inspiration and hope many hail the WSF process as a "victory of the people". But complacency is no virtue.

Contradictions are apparent and there are no clear answers.

The big brain behind the WSF is the International Organising Committee who some complemented for building the movement to "startling maturity".

Among some comrades, however, there were still some questions. Who are these IC people and how did they get there? Election, selection or free participation? Do you get in if you can pay your travel costs or if you are buddies with the big boys of the WSF? Transparency please, cynics demand. Look who’s talking. The question of democracy is something we all should address. Which of the world’s people elected an NGO to represent them here or anywhere else for that matter. NGOs just sprouted like weeds in a fallow field and proceeded to take over the land.

Another dilemma. When do you jettison the heroes of the movement and bring in new blood? At an informal dinner, Carol Barton a US delegate from the Women's International Coalition for Economic Justice complained "...even in the TerraViva you have enough space for the gurus, but not for us."

George, Bello, Khor, are your days done? And who should replace you? Maybe some eloquent visionary from the youth camp?

And why is it even an issue? Why should we feed on our own, when there may be room for everyone?

Appreciation is in order for the local organisers. But even these martyrs did not escape criticism. It's a "forum of equals" some say, so why then do your badges display your status? In the pecking order the "delegates" and "participants" were at the bottom of the pile, below the big shot "organisers" from the IOC/LOC and the superstar "conferistas". I noticed a few delegates sniff as they bumped into men in black wearing "VIP Service" badges. What do you mean by V.I.Ps? Isn’t that us, the masses?

* Aye Aye Win, Burma, is the Coordinator of Dignity International and a member of the IPS Board of Directors.


Published Stories