Monday, May 12, 2008   12:38 GMT    
IPS Direct to Your Inbox!
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Africa
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Asia-Pacific
     Afghanistan
     Iran
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Caribbean
      Haiti
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Europe
      Union in Diversity
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Latin America
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Mideast &
   Mediterranean
      Iraq
      Israel/Palestine
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - North America
      Neo-Cons
      Bush at War
Agencia de Noticias Inter Press Service
Agencia de Noticias Inter Press Service
Agencia de Noticias Inter Press Service
Agencia de Noticias Inter Press Service
 - Development
      MDGs
      City Voices
      Corruption
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Civil Society
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Globalisation
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Environment
      Energy Crunch
      Climate Change
      Tierramérica
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Human Rights
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Health
      HIV/AIDS
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Indigenous Peoples
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Economy & Trade
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Labour
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Population
      Reproductive Rights
      Migration&Refugees
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Arts & Entertainment
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Education
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - ExPress Freedom
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Columns
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - In Focus
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Readers' Opinions
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
 - Email News
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
  What is RSS?
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   ENGLISH
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   ESPAÑOL
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   FRANÇAIS
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   ARABIC
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   DEUTSCH
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   ITALIANO
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   JAPANESE
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   NEDERLANDS
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   PORTUGUÊS
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   SUOMI
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   SVENSKA
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   SWAHILI
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
   TÜRKÇE
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
IPS Inter Press Service News Agency
WHAT'S BEHIND SOARING COMMODITY PRICES
By Jose Graziano da Silva*

SANTIAGO, Apr (IPS) The deterioration of terms of trade is one of the historic factors behind underdevelopment, which should be understood not as a stage of development but rather a specific and distorted form in which peripheral economies are inserted into the world capitalist system.

For the majority of these economies, colonial relations built around the export of raw materials were the primary cause of this trait.

Now, in the 21st century, some of these countries have slightly greater control over their economies thanks to the expansion of the evolving industrial base. But these few exceptions only prove the rule: internal patterns of wealth distribution dominate and this expansion is limited for the most part to nuclei of mineral or agricultural exports. Thus income is concentrated in productive systems that remain subject to the ups and downs of global trade in raw materials.

For instance, the economic trajectory of Latin America and the Caribbean is marked by cycles that are both ephemeral and intense: silver, gold, sugar, and coffee, to cite a few examples from the past, and today soy, iron ore, and copper. Neither peripheral area has been able to escape this cyclical trap, which demonstrates the persistence of patterns of trade that transfer control over a country's development abroad.

The recurrent nature of the losses caused by this trade model was first analysed in the 1950s at the dawn of the Economic Commission for Latin America (CEPAL) by Raúl Prebisch of Argentina and later studied by the Brazilian Celso Furtado, who explained in detail the structural limitations generated by this model which have perpetuated economic and political subordination throughout the history of the region.

In the last five years, the explosion of raw material prices began to effect one of the factors that cause underdevelopment, but it was insufficient to break the logic of the pattern identified by Furtado.

Since 2003, according to the Commodity Research Bureau (CRB), the average price of 24 agricultural raw materials on world markets has increased by 50 percent. However, widening the time frame to the period from 1974 to 2004, The Economist magazine found an overall decline of 75 percent in the price of these products. In other words, only a part of this decline has been reversed since 2003.

It is also important to evaluate on a yearly basis the factors behind this recent price increase in order to differentiate structural elements from those related to speculation.

Between 2002 and 2004 there was a rise in the consumption of high-protein foods, primarily meat and milk products, by the poor in developing countries, including China, India, and Brazil. At almost exactly the same time, the United States dramatically increased its consumption of ethanol, which drove up the demand for wheat.

This period of growth in demand was followed by a phase in which there was a scarcity of supply. Between 2004 and 2006 world cereal production dropped significantly as a result of climatic factors, whether droughts in China and Australia or hurricanes in Central America and the Caribbean. This decreased the world cereal reserves at a time that consumption was on the rise.

Then in 2007 speculation emerged as the factor responsible for the sustained increase in prices: in a climate of economic uncertainty, many investors sought shelter in commodity funds, agricultural and non-agricultural.

There are thus two distinct elements driving the current price increases: one is financial; the other is the hitherto unheard of shift in demand: the expansion of consumption in poor countries. The former is transitory, while the latter could result in a structural change of the flux and intensity of the trade in foods and raw materials.

Though these dynamics are still underway, certain lessons can already be drawn. The first regards the risks implicit in dependence on exports of raw materials, as Prebisch and Furtado have warned for decades. The second is the necessity of having a counterweight to economic policy to broaden the range of producers that benefit from cyclical increases in the demand for food. The strengthening of small agricultural producers and farmer cooperatives, for example, would widen the distribution of wealth in a way that would increase the chances of sustainable growth.

A propos, it is worth remembering that hundreds of millions of poor in the countries of the South live in rural areas. For them, the rise in prices is an opportunity to escape poverty, as long as they are guaranteed a market for their goods, in addition to traditional credit and technical assistance policies. This can be accomplished, for example, through government purchasing of their production to form reserves and provide meals in schools.

The current crisis is a clear refutation of the neomalthusian thesis that agroenergy is primarily responsible for increases in commodity prices, which minimised the considerable speculative component, recognised even by the U.S. government, which has proposed joint action by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (which oversees the futures markets for these products) and the Security Exchange Commission (which regulates financial markets). In contrast, agroenergy emerges from the current financial crisis as a safe haven of real consistency and strategic continuity. Even if global demand for commodities declines in the short term, the challenge of remaking the energy network for the 21st century has just begun. Agroenergy can help sustain the expansion of poor countries and usher in a new dynamic of trade independence by industrialising biofuel crop farming and creating bridges between family agriculture and a peak sector of the global economy that is here to stay. (END/COPYRIGHT IPS)

(*Jose Graziano da Silva is the regional representative for Latin America and the Caribbean at the UN Food and Agricultural Organisation.)

IPS News Feeds News Feeds RSS/XML
Make IPS your homepage Make IPS News your homepage!
Free Email Newsletters Free Email Newsletters
IPS Mobile IPS Mobile
Text Only Text Only
Editors interested in acquiring this column, please contact romacol@ips.org specifying the name and address of the publication as well as a proposed rate. Unfortunately, we cannot comply with requests from individuals or organisations that do not represent print media outlets.
News in RSS
THE DEMOCRATIC ILLUSION
  By Johan Galtung
EDUCATION UNDER ATTACK - RECLAIMING SCHOOLS AS ZONES OF PEACE
  By Helene-Marie Gosselin
CURRENT CRISIS HIGHLIGHTS FLAWS IN MARKET ECONOMICS, AND GDP
  By Hazel Henderson
WHAT'S BEHIND SOARING COMMODITY PRICES
  By Jose Graziano da Silva
BHUTANESE HAVE HIGH EXPECTATIONS OF THEIR NEW PARLIAMENT
  By Francoise Pommaret
JAPAN TAKES PROMINENT ROLE IN AFRICAN DEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE
  By Sadako Ogata
SOUTH-SOUTH COOPERATION: THE ASIAN EXPERIENCE
  By Biswajit Nag* - IPS/South Centre
MAKING HIGH COMMODITY PRICES HELP THE POOREST NATIONS
  By Ali Mchumo
NATURE IS NOT MUTE
  By Eduardo Galeano
OLYMPICS MEAN TIGHTER SECURITY AT TIBET-INDIA BORDER
  By Dorjee
MORE >>