|
WORLD PRESS REVIEW - July 2006
NO ONE SHOULD BE PUT TO DEATH, NOT EVEN
SADDAM - VATICAN
No one should be put to death, not even former
Iraqi President Saddam Hussein, said Cardinal
Paul Poupard, president of the pontifical councils
for Interreligious Dialogue and for Culture. "The
Catechism of the Catholic Church, the church itself
and the pope reaffirm that every person is a creature
of God and that no one but the creator can claim
to be the lord of the life and death of another,"
the cardinal said in an interview with the Italian
news agency ANSA.
"Every creature, even the most wretched,
was created in the image and likeness of God,"
the French cardinal said. "God is the master
of life and death." The cardinal made his
comments after Avvenire, the Italian bishops'
daily newspaper, published an editorial June 20
calling for the life imprisonment and not the
execution of Saddam and his co-defendants, who
are on trial in Iraq.
"Even in the daily slaughterhouse of Iraq
a human life – any human life – always
is sacred," the newspaper said. Revenge,
even resulting from a fair trial, "will not
heal wounds, but rather risks exacerbating them
further," Avvenire said. "Nothing gives
legitimacy to a killing unless it is motivated
by a compelling need for legitimate defense."
INDONESIA REFUSES EU REQUEST ON CANCELLATION OF
DEATH PENALTY
Indonesia has refused the demand of the ambassadors
of the European Union (EU) countries to revoke
the country's death penalty, People's Daily online
said in a Xinhua report July 4. Minister of Justice
and Human Rights Hamid Awaluddin made the statement
after meeting with the Indonesian Vice President
Jusuf Kalla, a counselor delegation of the European
Union and the ambassadors of Finland and Germany
at the vice presidential office.
As "they asked us to delete the death penalty,
Indonesia still had the law, which was inherited
from the Dutch colonial rule and event in the
country's view of criminal law, death penalty
should still exist," the minister said, adding
"the vice president and I explained our position...
and Indonesia's criminal law still has a cause
of it (death penalty)." Awaluddin said that
in the new draft, "the death penalty is still
stipulated, which sparks pro and contra."
Indonesia has executed 71 people up to now and
prepares to conduct the death penalty on tens
of others, including three bombers whom played
leading roles in the Bali bombings in 2002, which
killed 202 people. Indonesian has been imposing
death penalty on the cases of terrorism, drug
trafficking and planned assassination.
DEATH PENALTY WORLDWIDE DIMINISHES, REPORT SAYS
Less countries worldwide are issuing life sentences,
according to the Italian rights group Nessuno
Tocchi Caino (Noone touch Cain) which released
its annual report on the death penalty, AKI reported
on July 21.
Today 90 countries have abolished capital punishment
altogether, while no executions have taken place
in another 52 states in the past few years. However,
there are still 52 countries worldwide where capital
punishment is legal. Overall, 5,494 executions
were carried out in 2005, compared to 5,530 a
year before. Asia is the continent where the highest
number of executions were registered in 2005,
98.7 percent of life sentences worldwide. Among
Asian countries, China ranks first with as many
as 5,000 executions last year, followed by Iran
with 113.
DEATH PENALTY NEEDS FIXING, SAY CRITICS
The death penalty should be changed or abolished
because it is corrupting the U.S. system of justice
at all levels, critics allege. "It corrupts
all of us. It is corrupting our courts, it's corrupting
prosecutors, it's corrupting defense attorneys,
it's corrupting juries, it's corrupting our society,"
said Bryan Stevenson, a defense attorney and professor
of clinical law at New York University's School
of Law. He was among those participating in a
National Press Club discussion on the future of
the death penalty, Cyber Cast New (CSN.COM) reported
July 24.
Stevenson said the system is so corrupt in Alabama
that 80 percent of death row inmates face execution
for committing crimes against white people, while
65 percent of all murder victims are black. "The
people on death row are not terrorists. They are
not Timothy McVeigh. The majority of them are
poor, the mentally ill, the wronged," Stevenson
said.
Sam Millsap, former district attorney for Bexar
County, Texas, said too many innocent people face
the death penalty. "It's better that a hundred
guilty men go free, than one innocent man gets
sentenced to death. It's important that we remember
that." Kenneth Starr, a former U.S. solicitor
general and independent counsel who investigated
the Bill Clinton/Monica Lewinsky scandal, said
that while he favors the death penalty, it needs
to be fixed. "I am not an abolitionist and
never have been," he said. Starr said the
president and governors have the power to grant
pardons and clemency and should do so more frequently.
It is a power that Starr said has not been used
in California since Ronald Reagan was governor.
POLISH LEADER WANTS EU TO RETURN TO DEATH PENALTY
Poland's conservative President Lech Kaczynski
vowed on Friday to campaign for a return of the
death penalty in the European Union, Washington
Post said in a Reuters report July 28. He said
the EU, which has effectively banned capital punishment,
would to come to see it was justified for murder.
"Countries who give up this penalty award
an unimaginable advantage to the criminal over
his victim, the advantage of life over death,"
Kaczynski told public radio. Kaczynski and his
twin brother Jaroslaw, Poland's prime minister,
won power last year promising a tough stance against
corruption and crime in the biggest ex-communist
EU member. Their traditionalist and nationalist
rhetoric has alarmed Warsaw's EU partners, raising
concerns they will drive Poland away from the
European mainstream.
The Kaczynskis dismiss the criticism as unfair
and argue their views on the death penalty should
be debated. "We need to discuss this in Europe.
I think that with time Europe will change its
view in this regard," Kaczynski said. All
15 of the EU's older member states abandoned capital
punishment in the late 1960s. The new members
who joined in 2004 have had to abandon it as a
condition of membership.
UGANDA GOVT NOT READY TO ABOLISH DEATH
PENALTY
Uganda is not ready to abolish the death penalty
the Speaker of Parliament, Edward Kiwanuka Ssekandi,
has said. Ssekandi, on Wednesday, July 26, told
officials from the African Commission on Human
and People's Rights that abolishing the death
penalty "could cause anarchy" in society,
The New Times (Kigali) said in a report from Kampala.
He said "in our society it requires patience
and sensitization" to contain crime but not
abolishing the death penalty. "I personally
would not say we abolish the death penalty. We
should leave it intact after all, it is rarely
carried out. Once we abolish the death penalty,
it could cause anarchy in our society," Ssekandi
told Mumba Malila and Reine Alapini-Gansou, both
commissioners at the African Commission on Human
and Peoples' Rights.
The two officials, during a courtesy call, had
asked the Speaker to explain why Uganda was reluctant
to abolish the death penalty, "a human rights
abuse that is hindering development in Africa".
"From what you have said, it is true Uganda
will do better. As parliament, you should explain
why you have not abolished the death penalty.
Nobody should take the life of another. That is
how Africa will develop," Alapini-Gansou,
the Commissioner of the Defense of the defenders
of human rights, said.
But Ssekandi insisted: "Maybe some years
to come. We still need to sensitise. The death
penalty in Uganda is for capital offences, which
are very few. Even in America, there are capital
offences. And there is no evidence that many people
have suffered because of the death penalty."
The Speaker had earlier said that the abolition
of the death penalty was first debated upon during
the Constituent Assembly and majority of the members
maintained that it stays.
FORMER CHINESE POLICEMAN LIFTS LID ON
ORGAN HARVESTING
Chinese body parts are in hot demand, with Western
patients sick of long waiting queues and in need
of a transplant. Customers, including dozens of
Australians, are prepared to pay up to $US170,000
($255,700) for a major organ such as a lung or
heart, Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC)
reported July 25.
The report quoted former Beijing policeman Sun
Liyong saying he knows the methods used by Chinese
authorities to harvest body parts from prisoners.
Mr Sun now lives in Australia, but during the
1980s he says he was well aware of what was happening
to executed prisoners. "Before the prisoners
were executed the Public Security Bureau would
go to the detention centre and test their blood,"
he said. "As far as I know during the period
I was a policeman all the organs were harvested
by the Friendship Hospital in Beijing."
Records show the Friendship Hospital boasts of
an excellent reputation in transplant operations.
"The Beijing Public Security Bureau would
notify the Friendship Hospital before they carried
out the execution of prisoners," Mr Sun said.
"The Friendship Hospital would then send
an ambulance, and as soon as the prisoners were
executed, the police on the spot would put them
in a plastic bag and throw them into the van."
Mr Sun says the date and time of the executions
were determined by patient demand. He says once
prison authorities had carried out the execution,
hospital staff were ready to act. "And the
staff from the hospital would already have everything
prepared for the organ harvesting," he said.
Mr Sun left the police force in 1987, but afterwards
he became involved in China's democracy movement.
|