Search           Contacts          Headlines

news in

      Homepage
      Global affairs
      Africa
      Asia-Pacific
      Caribbean
      Europe
      Latin America
      Middle East
      North America
 
      Environment
      Development
      Human Rights
      Population
      Health
      Arts &
      Entertainment

      Columns
 
      News in RSS
 
      Subscriptions
      Readers' Opinions
      About IPS

 

 

RIGHTS-SOUTH AFRICA: Black Migrants Face the Worst Xenophobia

By Farah Khan

Back to index

JOHANNESBURG, Aug 6 (IPS) - For its history of discrimination, one would have expected post-apartheid South Africa to have been a society more tolerant of migrants. Instead, it has become one of Africa's more xenophobic countries where attacks on foreigners have become so commonplace that they barely afford a mention on the media.

Yet this contemporary history of South African discrimination is unlikely to receive much attention when the UN World Conference on Racism gets underway in South Africa, Aug 31-Sep 7.

Analysts say the government is focusing on racism and the lingering legacy of apartheid in the country. It should receive more attention at the conference, believes Jenny Parsley of the Human Rights Commission. "You cannot have an African Renaissance when you don't like Africans," she says, in reference to the African Renaissance philosophy which South Africa's president Thabo Mbeki has made a foundation stone of his Presidency.

As apartheid borders came down, the numbers of African migrants in South Africa increased notably in its major cities. Immigration has always been common -- from the sixties, South Africa's white government encouraged immigration from Britain and Europe. Almost one in ten-white citizens was not born here, while one in four South Africans has a British passport.

Immigrants from the rest of the continent are recent, but common visitors. Ironically, black migrants face the worst xenophobia.

By the time of the 1996 census, statistics showed that there were almost 530,000 Southern African Development Community (SADC) residents living in South Africa, with another 20,000 from the rest of the continent. More than half are migrant workers employed in the mines -- an historical workforce.

The rest arrived more recently and work as professionals or are largely self-employed. Instead of viewing foreigners as a job-creating resource (surveys show immigrant populations are highly skilled and entrepreneurial) they have been met with hostility.

Since the early nineties, there have been ongoing accounts of local hawkers undertaking running battles with street salesperson from Taiwan, India, Pakistan and Bangladesh.

The hostility is not confined to the private sector - while there is no statistical evidence, incidents of police harassment of illegal immigrants is common. At the Johannesburg Central police station, a special immigrant patrol unit goes out every afternoon to find the ''illegal'' or ''makwerekwere'' as migrants are pejoratively referred to.

When analysts try to understand why xenophobia has spread like wildfire, it becomes clear that South Africans believe foreigners ''steal'' their jobs and sap up state services.

The economy has lost a net number of 1.1 million jobs in the past six years, leading to an unemployment rate of over 35 percent and a constantly poverty level of half of all households, according to official statistics.

''There's a perception that 'We've waited so long that we won't share the limited scraps being thrown at us','' says Parsley.

She adds that countries that are internally divided inevitably display higher levels of xenophobia. On top of that, South Africa's racial reconciliation process has stalled, resulting in what she calls ''hierarchies of otherness''.

But David McDonald of the South Africa Migration Project (SAMP) says that often the fears that fuel xenophobia have no basis in reality. Most migrants enter the country legally and do not plan to stay forever; they find the quality of life better in their own countries; and instead of being a drain on the economy, many in fact lend to the economy by doing their retailing locally.

''Cross border migration from the region is already a very legal and regularised process and lends itself to the building of a more humane, management-oriented approach to immigration policy,'' he says, adding that the South African government needs to do a lot more to expand human rights protection to migrants.

It also needs to develop a more sophisticated migration framework that takes account of the economic and social linkages in the Southern African region. On the ground, there is a need for public education.

The Human Rights Commission (HRC) has run a two-year long ''Roll Back Xenophobia'' campaign that includes media education. Research by the SAMP last year found that the media was disseminating many of the myths about migrants. Parsley says that while it is difficult to measure attitude change, the public debate on migrants is changing.

In addition to the media campaign, the HRC also runs face-to-face meetings where local communities get to interact with representatives of refugee and immigrant communities. ''When you get to meet someone personally, they often do not conform to the stereotypes,'' she says.(END/IPS/AF/HD/FK/MN/01)