Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

UNITED NATIONS: U.N. Falters in Move to Create New Security Council

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Jun 27 1995 (IPS) - The United Nations is faltering in its attempts to create a new Security Council aimed at better reflecting post-Cold War realities.

“We are nowhere close to an agreement,” Ambassador Francesco Fulci of Italy told IPS Tuesday.

Italy has broken away from the European Union (EU) by opposing the creation of any new permanent members to a revamped Security Council.

The United States, France and Britain — who, along with China and Russia, hold veto-wielding, permanent seats — are rooting for two new permanent members in the Council.

But developing nations are opposing this move. Any restructuring of the Security Council should involve more than the addition of Japan and Germany, they say, adding that poor nations also should take their place among the major powers.

The United Nations is “going round and round” and moving “too far away from anything definite.” observes James Paul of the New York-based Global Policy Forum.

“Nothing will happen because there is quite a lot of opposition to any kind of movement,” he says.

A proposal to add five permanent members — including one each from Asia, Africa and Latin America and the Caribbean — is also in trouble.

Nigeria, Brazil and India would like to become permanent members, and they have campaigned actively for seats. “But their regional rivals are staunchly opposed,” according to Paul.

Egypt and South Africa wonder about Nigeria’s special qualifications as a representative of Africa, while Argentina and Mexico, and Indonesia and Pakistan question the choice of Brazil and India.

“Smaller countries, in turn, are unhappy about any system that will strengthen the powerful at their expense,” says Paul.

A U.N. Working Group, consisting of all 185 member states, is now breaking up into smaller units in a last-ditch attempt to produce a formula acceptable to all.

But the Group, which has been meeting since last year, is now being accused of holding informal consultations among only a select few countries.

Italy, although a member of the select group, has denounced this procedure.

“Of course, we realise that within the framework of the United Nations, there have always been closed meetings, designed to give strong impulse to specific exercises,” the Italian envoy said.

“However, the reform of the Security Council is too vital, too fundamental a question, for all member states of the United Nations, none of whom, I am sure we all agree, should feel excluded,” he said.

“Unfortunately, this system with inclusions, exclusions and replacements of some countries — with apparently no rhyme or reason — can make one feel the proceedings have lost transparency,” he told the Working Group recently.

The Global Policy Forum, which has set up its own NGO Working Group on the Security Council, insists that the discussion should be open to non-governmental organisations (NGOs) as well.

Paul maintains that civil society has an important role in the restructuring of the Security Council.

But U.N. diplomats, who do not share his views, say the restructuring exercise is too complicated already. The involvement of the NGOs will make things even more difficult, they say.

Paul said the prevailing view at the United Nations is the restructuring should be “done quietly. We disagree with this view,” he says.

The only changes so far, says Paul, are mostly procedural. The Council president now holds regular meetings to keep all member states informed about the activities of the Council.

The agenda and resolutions are also circulated as part of new procedures in the Council, he said.

Meanwhile, Italy has been championing the cause of Third World nations by submitting a detailed proposal weighted heavily in favour of developing nations.

“The big brothers have been elbowing out the smaller brothers far too long,” Fulci told IPS early this year.

Any proposed restructuring should make the Council more efficient, more democratic and more representative of the world body because the majority of its members are from developing nations, he said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags