Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

RIGHTS: Alarm Over Human Rights Threats in Egypt, Tunisia

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, May 30 1999 (IPS) - Government moves in Egypt and Tunisia during the past week has set off alarm bells among human rights organisations in the United States and Europe.

In joint statements, the groups denounced the approval by the Egyptian parliament of a strict new law governing non-governmental organisations (NGOs). They also condemned recent harassment of human rights activists in Tunisia.

The human rights watchdogs included Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch (HRW), the Lawyers Committee for Human Rights (LCHR), the International Federation of Leagues of Human Rights (FIDH) and the World Organisation Against Torture.

They declared the developments in Egypt and Tunisia marked potentially serious setbacks to human rights and the growth of civil society in a region where more than 50 human-rights groups have emerged and struggled to survive over the past 15 years.

With few exceptions, the mainly authoritarian governments in the Arab Middle East and North Africa have opposed the growth of independent NGOs.

“What you’re seeing are increasing efforts by governments to put civil society organisations – especially human rights activists – out of business or make them completely compliant with government views,” said HRW Mideast analyst Joe Stork.

Egypt’s new Law on Civil Associations and Institutions, which still must be signed by President Hosni Mubarak, drew protests from the US State Department Friday. Spokesman James Rubin said Washington was “deeply disappointed” with the bill, because it appeared to “increase the amount of government control of non- governmental organisations.”

“This is the wrong direction to go if Egypt wants to energise civil society and promote development,” said Rubin, who added that Washington would express its concerns about the law “with senior levels of the Egyptian government.”

The law, which has been under debate in Egypt for several years, imposed a wide range of restrictions on the management, operation, and financing of NGOs. It would require them to register with the government, which can deny them legal status if it believes their work may “threaten national unity” or “violate public order or moral codes.”

The law also requires NGOs to seek prior government approval for conducting board elections, affiliating with other NGOs outside Egypt, and seeking or receiving funding from abroad.

Violations of these regulations could result in the dissolution of the NGO itself and the criminal prosecution of its members with possible prison sentences of up to one year.

“This draft law is a blueprint for massive state interference in every aspect of the operation of NGOs,” said HRW Mideast director Hanny Megally. “Provisions such as these can cripple the autonomy of NGOs and put them under the thumb of the government.”

Megally told IPS that the government likely would be selective in its implementation of the law. Foreign funding may be approved for NGOs engaged in charitable projects but denied , or held up, for rights groups in Egypt that were investigating or publicising government abuses.

Last December, the government arrested the secretary-general of the Egyptian Organisation for Human Rights (EOHR), Hafez Abu Seda, after he was accused in a newspaper of treason.

The newspaper alleged Abu Seda had received 25,000 dollars from the British government to publish a report on police torture during a murder investigation of Christian residents in a southern village. The British embassy in Cairo, however, said the money was used to support a legal-aid project.

Megally said the government’s regulation of foreign funding could prove devastating to the more than dozen rights groups which have mushroomed in Egypt in recent years.

“These groups are very, very dependent on funding from abroad,” which, he said, probably accounts for 90-95 percent of their total budgets.

Megally noted that Egypt may be trying to emulate Tunisia, the first in the region to enact a similar law of association governing the activities and operations of NGOs.

That law, combined with a campaign of harassment, including the sentencing to three years imprisonment of one its leaders, has largely succeeded in rendering the Tunisian Human Rights League (LTDH), largely ineffective.

In the last few months, however, a new organisation, the National Council for Liberties in Tunisia (CNLT), consisting of many LTDH activists, emerged to challenge the human rights record of the government headed by President Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali.

Its appearance converged with a “general upturn in activity by more independent groups, especially among workers and students,” according to Eric Goldstein, a Tunisia expert at HRW. “There are more people willing to speak out at the moment.”

The result has been a “disturbing escalation of harassment and intimidation” against the CNLT and other independent groups, according to a joint statement by the five human rights organisations, and the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ).

Last week, Taoufik Ben Brik, a prominent journalist and member of the CNLT, was attacked outside his home by three individuals armed with chains. “Such a physical attack is something very new,” said Megally. “In the past, attacks have been directed more against property.”

Ben Brik, who had published a number of articles in French and Swiss newspapers about the deterioration in the human rights situation in Tunisia earlier this year, was arrested last Monday and detained several hours for interrogation. In previous weeks, he had been prevented from leaving the country, and his passport was confiscated.

On May 11, the CNLT issued an appeal condemning the arrest of ten independent trade unionists. The following day the its secretary-general, Omar Mestiri, was arrested at his home and held for one day. A week later, Mohamed Tahar Chaieb, another trade unionist and university lecturer, was arrested at the Tunis Airport after returning from Paris and held for two days.

These events took place in the run-up to the trial of prominent human rights lawyer Radhia Nasraoui and 20 co-defendants, who are accused of unauthorised association. The court abruptly cancelled a hearing in the case May 15 after some 20 foreign lawyers, several foreign diplomats, and 120 defence lawyers showed up.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags