Thursday, November 19, 2026
Commentary Mario Osava
- International efforts to liberalise trade have led to a renewed look at the agricultural sector, which for decades has played second to industry, even ideologically.
Industrialisation is not the only way to change the unfavourable terms of trade that seem to deepen the problems of developing countries. In fact, tearing down agricultural trade barriers and eliminating subsidies can alleviate imbalances between poor and rich nations, say experts.
This conviction is spreading throughout the South as the possibility of a new round of multilateral trade negotations surfaces. The debate, already referred to as the Millennium Round, is expected to be launched by the World Trade Organisation’s (WTO) Third Ministerial Conference, to run Nov 30 through Dec 3 in the U.S. city of Seattle, Washington.
Agricultural exporting nations have joined forces to fight protectionism in the sector, practiced mainly by the European Union (EU), the United States and Japan.
The Group of Cairns, created 1986 by 14 nations to fight agricultural subsidies, is gaining support for its position. Its members are mostly Latin American and Asian countries, but some industrialised nations are included as well, including Canada, Australia and New Zealand.
Agriculture, a key issue for a growing number of countries, is seen as a threat to the Millennium Round’s success. The WTO made an unsuccessful informal attempt in late October to overcome discrepancies that could frustrate trade talks.
Numerous countries are refusing to discuss other trade issues without a prior agreement that would guide agricultural negotiations, reported Brazil’s ambassador to the WTO, former foreign minister Celso Amorim.
Latin America has lost more than 215 billion dollars in exports since 1970 as a result of agricultural subsidies in wealthy countries, reported Jorge Campbell, Argentina’s secretary of International Economic Relations for the foreign affairs ministry.
Such subsidies reached a yearly combined total of 362 billion dollars for the member-countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), a group of the 29 wealthiest nations, said Campbell, adding that the sum is more than Argentina’s gross domestic product (GDP).
Brazil could expand its agro-industrial exports by 30 percent if protectionism in the wealthier nations were eliminated, according to the Permanent Forum of International Agricultural Negotiations.
This increase would mean additional income of six billion dollars annually for Brazil, 12 percent of its total exports. Orange juice, soya, meat and sugar are the nation’s products most affected by barriers imposed in the United States and the EU.
The battle for agricultural trade liberalisation comes accompanied by ideological changes.
The belief that industry is “the only road to riches” created attitudes and errors, leading developing countries to undervalue agriculture, lamented Benedito Rosa, president of the National Provisions Company, an agency of Brazil’s Ministry of Agriculture.
Identifying agriculture with lack of development leads to policies that are harmful to the economy and to society. It is the “obsession” with exporting products of high added-value, believed to only include industrial products, Rosa pointed out.
The EU countries, which control 38 percent of the world’s agricultural trade, do not make the same mistake, nor does the United States, whose sales in the sector are greater than Brazil’s exports.
Agriculture currently adds a great deal of value because it involves technology in its chemical inputs and auxiliary equipment, as well as bio-technological support, observed Rosa.
The fight for an agricultural trade that is less distorted by barriers and subsidies has opened the eyes of leaders in many countries of the South who used to think that industry was synonymous with development.