Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS: Reservations Impede UN Convention against Discrimination against Women

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Feb 11 2001 (IPS) - Long before the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait in August 1990, a US TV anchorwoman did a critical story on the rigidly male chauvinistic societies in the family-run sheikhdoms in the Gulf.

She discovered that most countries in the region deprived women of some of their basic human rights – and one of them even barred women from driving automobiles.

Perhaps one of the many customs that intrigued the TV anchor was a widely-accepted norm where wives religiously walked several feet behind their husbands outside the confines of their homes.

But 10 years after the Gulf War, the same network was keen on a follow-up story: how the US “liberation” of Kuwait had helped transform some of the affluent sheikhdoms into Western-style democracies – perhaps justifying a war which killed hundreds and thousands in the name of liberty and human rights.

After all, in Qatar, there is a relatively free press now and US- style educational institutions. And since May 1999, women have been permitted to vote and run for political office in municipal elections.

Oman broke new ground in January 1995 when, for the first time, women were included in the State Consultative Council.

The TV anchorwoman was also pleasantly surprised to find the reversal of an old custom – whereby husbands now walked several feet behind their wives apparently giving women social precedence over men.

So she approached a woman in the streets of Kuwait, thrust the mike at her face, and asked her: “Could you tell the free world what led to this dramatic reversal of roles for women?”

“Yes,” said the woman, “landmines.”

The story may be apocryphal, but it illustrates the wide gender gap between the Middle East and rest of the world – despite the fact that most countries in the world have ratified a UN convention barring discrimination against women.

In May 1999, the Kuwaiti cabinet did give women the right to vote and run for parliament. But the all-male state assembly rejected it. Last month, Kuwait’s highest court turned down yet another case filed by women challenging the denial of their right to vote.

Coincidentally, the ruling came at a time when the UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women was meeting in New York to take stock of the progress made in advancing the rights of women worldwide.

The three-week session, which ended last week, reviewed the current status of women’s rights in several countries, and ascertained whether or not they conformed to the UN Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW).

The convention, which was adopted by the General Assembly in 1979, has been endorsed by 166 of the UN’s 189 member states.

But most countries in the Middle East, Asia and Africa which have signed the convention have done so with strong reservations, nullifying the very purpose of the international treaty.

The reservations have come from Algeria, Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Lebanon, Libya and Morocco. Virtually all of them say that they will not implement provisions of the Convention which come in conflict with Islamic law, the Sharia.

The reservations relate mostly to provisions of the convention which deal with equality in laws of marriage, family, divorce, inheritance and choice of spouse, and also on relationships within the family.

Charlotte Abaka of Ghana, chair of the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women, admitted that some of the reservations really impede the implementation of the convention.

“We are always being told that the Sharia is actually not against equality for women. It depends on how it is interpreted,” Abaka told IPS last week. “People and governments would want to interpret it to suit their agenda … that is the problem.”

She said that there are some Islamic countries that have found a way out. She singled out Tunisia as a typical example. “Tunisia has found a way to implement the convention in the spirit and the letter of the law, in spite of religion.”

Meanwhile, Kuwait has expressed reservations regarding some articles of the convention “inasmuch as it conflicts with the provisions of the Islamic Sharia, Islam being the official religion of the State”.

The government of Kuwait has also reserved its right not to implement the provision contained in Article 9, paragraph 2, of the Convention, “inasmuch as it runs counter to the Kuwaiti Nationality Act, which stipulates that a child’s nationality shall be determined by that of his father”.

Saudi Arabia, in what is considered a sweeping reservation, has said that “in case of contradiction between any term of the Convention and the norms of Islamic law, the Kingdom is not under obligation to observe the contradictory terms of the Convention”.

Algeria, on the other hand, has declared that the provisions of Article 16 concerning equal rights for men and women in all matters relating to marriage, both during marriage and its dissolution, should not contradict the provisions of the Algerian Family Code.

There have also been reservations from countries such as Argentina, Australia, France, Germany, India, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and the United Kingdom.

But some of these reservations have subsequently been withdrawn while others are reservations that do not undermine the very basis of the Convention.

Australia, for example, did not accept a provision in the convention which would require a change in its Defence Force policy which excluded women from combat and combat-related duties. But in August last year, it withdrew its reservations.

Spain has said that the ratification of the convention shall not affect its own constitutional provisions concerning succession to the Spanish crown.

Belgium has exercised similar reservations safeguarding its own constitutional rights about the succession to the throne.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags