Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Environment, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights, Indigenous Rights

ENVIRONMENT: Bio-Pirates to Lose Patent Plank, States Pledge

Stephen Leahy

BROOKLIN, Canada, Feb 21 2004 (IPS) - Patent protection of bio-piracy might be ending after states at a global meeting agreed to work toward an international regime that will spell out who can access and benefit from the world’s biodiversity.

The thrust of the future deal is that when a country or local or indigenous community grant an international company or other body access to its resources, such as plants that can be used to produce new drugs or fragrances, it would receive a fair share of the profits or other benefits in return.

“An effective international regime on access and benefit-sharing would need to protect the interests of indigenous and local communities, commercial firms, consumers and all other key stakeholders,” said Hamdallah Zedan, executive secretary of the United Nations Convention on Biodiversity (CBD), at the end of the seventh meeting of the state parties to the treaty, in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

“By giving biodiversity-rich countries a greater stake in protecting their valuable biological resources, this future regime could make an enormous contribution to the goals of the Convention on Biological Diversity,” he added in a statement Friday.

The announcement lacked detail and did not speak to the hotly contested issue of whether a new access and benefit-sharing regime would be legally binding.

Now, traditional uses of plants cannot be protected under existing international intellectual property rights without placing them in the public domain.


Patent officials require free access to indigenous knowledge to decide whether an application for patent protection for a particular use of a resource is novel or based on traditional practice, says a report released Feb. 19 by the Tokyo-based United Nations University Institute of Advanced Studies.

Obliging indigenous people to permit public documentation of traditional knowledge for patent protection purposes is insensitive to centuries-old cultural practices in many places and might lead to injustice, adds the report.

But because thousands of patents related to medicinal and other commercially valuable plants already exist, many countries are beginning to compile traditional knowledge databases or registries, says report co-author Alphonse Kambu.

Peru made the first comprehensive effort by a developing country to set up a unique regime to protect rights to traditional ecological knowledge, in July 2002.

“Local people in the small island states are very concerned about bio-piracy, because they know they can’t protect their traditional knowledge,” Kambu, who is from Papua New Guinea, told IPS.

They have good reason to worry, according to a group of NGOs that annually “awards” the most egregious efforts to patent the world’s biodiversity.

Prince Hans Adams II of Liechtenstein won in 2000 for a patent on Basmati rice, and the U.S. University of Toledo in Ohio State received the “Captain Hook Award for Bio piracy” in 2002 for a patent on Ethiopia’s endod plant.

Agri-business giant Monsanto took the 2003 prize for its European patent on a soft-milling, low-gluten wheat derived from a traditional Indian wheat variety. Its patent even covers any bakery goods made using the wheat, says Beth Burrows of the Edmonds Institute, a U.S. non-governmental organisation (NGO).

Burrows worries that a new access and benefit-sharing regime might simply increase the number of life forms being patented, yet put little benefits into the pockets of local people.

In particular she is concerned about national parks auctioning off to commercial interests the very biodiversity they are supposed to protect.

In 1997, U.S. Yellowstone National Park – the world’s first national park -¡ licensed the micro organisms found in its famous hot springs.

The resulting patents – for processes ranging from paper and beer making to meat tenderising and drug creation – has earned hundreds of millions of dollars for the companies holding the patents, with little returning to the park or the U.S. government.

The deal was done in secret and the details are still protected by confidentiality agreements, Burrows told IPS.

“It was a violation of the public trust, and theft from the national commons.”

While the CBD encourages the protection of such resources, access to them is given equal weight, says Pat Mooney of the ETC group, a Canadian NGO.

“But even if local groups can benefit, it often sets communities one against the other in a bidding war over shared knowledge,” Mooney added in an interview.

Rather than this “beggar thy neighbour” approach with its secret, bilateral agreements, the CBD should move to an open unilateral system, he suggests.

A global conservation trust should be established where, in return for sharing traditional knowledge, indigenous communities would receive compensation. Under such a system, patenting would not be needed, Mooney argues.

The International Seed Treaty (International Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture) is a very good model for this, he adds.

The treaty aims to conserve and promote the sustainable use of the genetic resources of all the world’s food crops by encouraging national and international collections of seeds and plants; protecting the rights of farmers to these resources, and promoting the transfer of financial and technical resources to the developing South.

Administered by the U.N. Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO), the Seed Treaty is expected to be in force in July.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags