Thursday, November 19, 2026
Thalif Deen
- The United States and its Western allies are split over a proposal to raise international taxes to supplement shrinking development aid to Third World nations.
“Let’s explore the feasibility of new financial mechanisms,” the 15-member European Union (EU) told delegates here this week. “No Way,” countered Washington, shooting down the proposal even before it could get off the ground.
Speaking on behalf of the EU, Helen Brown of Ireland told U.N. delegates that the United Nations should set up an advisory group of experts to study “new and innovative” funding for globally agreed development priorities.
“The United Nations does not have the authority to impose or collect any form of taxes,” Ambassador Victor Marrero of the U.S. delegation shot back.
A study by a group of North-South experts released Thursday identifies several new sources of funding for development, including taxes on carbon emissions, air transport, and foreign exchange transactions.
“Proposals for international taxes share a general conceptual framework: taxing economic activities that have negative global impacts and using the resultant revenue to finance sustainable development activities,” the study says.
The experts say that although official development assistance (ODA) is an essential ingredient, it is unlikely to contribute more than a fraction of the external financing needs of developing nations.
Brown said the expert group’s report — which had “many ideas for new and innovative funding” — needs to be seriously studied.
But Marrero pointed out that Washington would not support any international tax collection schemes although “his government would have no objection to certain ‘fee for service’ charged by organisations such as the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) and the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO).”
Both organisations are U.N. bodies which already collect revenues for services rendered.
Marrero said if the United Nations decides to set up a study group, its mandate should specifically exclude international taxation.
He also said that it was clear that in the future, the primary source of funding for development would be private sector investment. “The stagnation of ODA and the rise of direct investment were indicators in that direction,” he added.
But Gus Speth, Administrator of the U.N. Development Programme (UNDP), last month challenged the growing Western belief that rising foreign investments mitigate the need for development aid by Third World nations.
“If funds assigned to help poor countries continue to decline, the world will pay dearly with tragic consequences and face a much heavier financial burden,” he said.
Speth said it was a myth that privatisation, a free market, globalisation and foreign direct investment obviate the need for development aid.
ODA is currently at its lowest point since 1970, declining from 59.2 billion dollars in 1994 to 58.8 billion dollars in 1995. Total private investments, on the other hand, have nearly quadrupled since 1990, reaching about 170 billion dollars this year.
Speth argued that increased private investments are going only to a handful of countries, mostly in East Asia, leaving the rest of the poorer nations to fend for themselves.
Ambassador Samuel Insanally of Guyana, a former President of the General Assembly, said that besides environment-related levies and taxes on foreign exchange transactions, there were several other innovative proposals before the United Nations.
There have been calls, he said, for international taxes on low elasticity commodities, on the use of common property resources such as the sea-bed and on the profits of transnational corporations.
Insanally also singled out a recent proposal by Japan which said, in effect, that savings from the reform of the United Nations should be applied to development purposes.
“There is certainly no dearth of imaginative ideas for securing new and additional financing,” he said, “The challenge is to promote their acceptance by the international community as a whole.”
“Bearing in mind the fate which seems to have befallen the much-touted ‘peace dividend’, we must work to ensure that some of these well-intentioned proposals do not fall by the wayside,” he said.
Last year, Secretary-General Boutros Boutros-Ghali also proposed a wide range of international taxes — but mostly to help resolve the cash crisis facing the United Nations.
The proposals advanced by Boutros-Ghali included a fee on speculative international financial transactions, a levy on fossil fuel use (or its resulting pollution), a stamp tax on international travel and a levy on global currency transactions.
The Secretary-General also proposed a diversion to the United Nations of “a small portion of the anticipated decline in world military expenditures” and also “some of the resources released by the elimination of unnecessary subsidies.”