Europe, Headlines, North America

US-EUROPE: U.S. Kicks Off NATO Expansion Campaign

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Oct 7 1997 (IPS) - The administration of U.S. President Bill Clinton Tuesday formally launched its campaign to gain Senate ratification of the eastward expansion of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO).

Speaking before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Secretary of State Madeleine Albright asserted that the United States remains “a European power” and has both a “strategic rationale” and a “moral imperative” for admitting Poland, the Czech Republic, and Hungary into the West’s 48-year-old military alliance.

“We must consider the dangers of Europe’s future; by this, I mean direct threats against the soil of NATO members that our collective defence pact is designed to meet,” she said, citing “the possibility that Russia could return to the patterns of its past.”

At the same time, Albright assured senators that Washington favours a “fair” distribution between Washington and European capitals of the costs of NATO expansion while admitting that there was as yet no consensus among them as to what those costs may be.

The Clinton administration has made ratification of NATO’s enlargement its top foreign-policy priority for 1998, and Tuesday’s hearings were designed to give it a running start before Congress adjourns for 1997, probably later this month.

It hopes to get a vote as early as February, four months before its self-imposed deadline, which may yet be extended, for withdrawing U.S. troops from Bosnia. Officials say they hope the expansion debate will be insulated from more controversial issues, such as U.S. policy in Bosnia and pending arms treaties with Russia.

Eventually, all of parliaments of NATO’s 16 members must ratify expansion before it can become effective. The U.S. Senate, however, is expected to be the first to act.

Most analysts believe that, barring a major crisis involving U.S. troops in Bosnia, the Senate will likely go along with the initiative, particularly as it has at least the provisional support of some key right-wing senators, notably Foreign Relations Committee chairman Jesse Helms.

What makes the battle most interesting, however, is the unlikely alliances that have built up on both sides of the issue. How these play out in the Senate debate remains to be seen.

Favouring expansion are three disparate groups on which the administration will depend to make its case, according to Charles Kupchan, a Georgetown University professor here.

These include a conservative wing led by former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger and Carter’s former national security adviser, Zbigniew Brzezinski, who see enlargement as a strategy for keeping Russia weak and an ethnic faction of voters of Central European extraction who “want their motherlands firmly under American protection.”

A third, liberal wing of the pro-expansion coalition is led by key Clinton aides who see expansion as a strategy for spreading “free-market” democracy across all of Europe, including Russia, according to Kupchan.

Critics are also divided into three major groups, according to Sherle Schwenninger, an analyst and senior fellow of the World Policy Institute in New York.

Defence-minded conservatives are worried about “diluting the coherence and effectiveness of NATO as a military alliance,” he writes in the current issue of The Nation weekly magazine. “Isolationist” Republicans are concerned about expanding U.S. commitments in central Europe, as well as the financial burden of expansion falling disproportionately on Washington.

Finally, many Democrats are worried about the impact of expansion – particularly as it moves beyond the three countries already invited to join NATO at the group’s summit meeting in Madrid last July – on U.S. ties with Russia and the prospects for future arms reduction.

The critics have a lot of support among mainstream policy experts and practitioners. Last June, for example, 40 former U.S. senators, cabinet secretaries and other former policymakers called for Clinton to indefinitely delay NATO’s expansion pending further study.

The group included such heavyweights as President Ronald Reagan’s top arms expert, Paul Nitze; his counterpart under Jimmy Carter, Paul Warnke; former Central Intelligence Agency chief ret. Adm. Stansfield Turner; former Defence Secretary Robert McNamara, and two former U.S. ambassadors to Moscow.

Their concern was mainly Russia’s reaction to NATO’s eastward creep, despite the signing last May by Russian President Boris Yeltsin and NATO leaders of a NATO-Russia Founding Act which established a consultative mechanism between Moscow and NATO on political and military issues.

While those fears have not yet been realised, they were echoed Tuesday by one of the Senate’s most conservative members, Republican Sen. John Ashcroft. “We’ve got to be careful, having won the Cold War against the Russians, not to turn them from Europe and an orientation to the West,” he said, suggesting that it might lead to rapprochement between Russia and China.

But Albright insisted that, so far, Washington has largely overcome this problem through the Founding Act. “I feel very strongly that while we need to maintain NATO as a guard against any potential resurgence (of Russian power),” she said, “at the same time we walked this line very carefully in terms of not isolating a new Russia from a new Europe and a new NATO.”

NATO itself has not yet reached a consensus on how much expansion will cost, but the Pentagon estimated earlier this year that the process could cost as much as 35 billion dollars over the next 12 years. Officially, the Clinton administation has said it will pay only two billion dollars of the total, or 200 million dollars a year, and has suggested that existing European NATO members should pay 16 billion dollars and the new countries another 17 billion dollars.

But in talks in the Netherlands last week, European ministers pointed out that they already bear a disproportionate burden of Western aid to East Europe and Russia.

They also suggested that Washington is putting pressure on the three proposed new NATO members to increase their defence budgets at the behest U.S. arms manufacturers who are expected to capture the bulk of new weapons procurement as part of any modernisation effort.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags