Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Mario Osava
- Dependence on foreign capital has become a major obstacle to economic growth in Brazil given the ongoing global financial turbulence.
Never have the country’s foreign currency reserves been as high as this year, covering the equivalent of 15 months of imports. But while authorities point to the reserves as a guarantee of economic solidity, they are unable to conceal their jitters over any sign of capital flight.
This month some seven billion dollars have been withdrawn from Brazil due to the Asian and Russian crises, according to estimates by financial experts, although part of that outflow was due to the expiration of credits forming part of an agriculture financing mechanism.
Still, reserves currently stand “above 69 billion dollars,” only slightly down from 70.2 billion in late July, said Altamir Lopes, the head of the Central Bank’s Economic Department. That phenomenon can be explained by the heavy inflow of direct investment, the result of privatisations and acquisitions of national banks and other firms by foreign economic-financial groups.
Nevertheless, the Central Bank reacted to last week’s “black Friday”, when close to two billion dollars fled the country, by adopting several measures Monday designed to bolster the level of foreign currency reserves.
And although Central Bank president Gustavo Franco has stated that “reserves are to be used,” experience has shown that the country is hostage to its need for increasingly higher levels of reserves, in an apparently vain attempt to cover up weakpoints.
In late 1991 Brazil had a mere 9.4 billion dollars in reserves, but heavy accumulation drove the level above 60 billion dollars by last October.
But that did not prevent the crisis unleashed by Hong Kong from triggering the withdrawal of 10 billion dollars from Brazil and economic stagnation during the first half of 1998, with the consequent rise in unemployment from 4.8 percent in December to the current 7.9 percent.
Today the economy is faltering in a reaction to the crisis in Russia, despite the high level of reserves. Brazil is paying a high cost for its reserves, meanwhile, whose revenues are much lower than the high interest rates the Brazilian government pays on its debt.
Although Brazil’s high internal interest rates impede economic growth higher than the one to 1.5 percent forecast for 1998, they are indispensable for attracting foreign capital.
Only growth of at least 4.5 percent would allow Brazil to begin to reduce poverty and its enormous social disparities, according to the World Bank.
But the international markets crisis, one way to socialise losses at a global level, brings the various objectives of the Brazilian economy into conflict.
To reduce dependence on foreign capital the country must lower its trade deficit, which topped 8.366 billion dollars last year and already stands at nearly three billion this year.
The government of President Fernando Henrique Cardoso aims to double annual exports to 100 billion dollars by the year 2002 by means of an effort that includes an increase in soft loans and incentives for small companies to enter the export market.
But the three percent rise in exports up to July was only achieved at the cost of economic stagnation, and this year’s one percent Gross Domestic Product growth will cause a two percent drop in exports, according to deputy and former finance minister Delfim Netto.
Devaluation has been almost unanimously ruled out as a possible solution, given the current turbulence and the crisis it would trigger in the Southern Common Market – which links Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay and Paraguay in the world’s fourth largest economic bloc – by dealing a severe blow to Argentina, which is facing a proportionally higher trade deficit than Brazil.
Guido Mantega, chief economic adviser to the leftist Workers Party’s presidential candidate Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, suggests clamping a lid on imports through tariff barriers and banning imports of luxury items as a last resort.
But that idea, heavily criticised by a majority of economists, who see it as a retreat from the opening up of the Brazilian market, would be lost anyway with the re-election of Cardoso, slated to win in the coming elections.