Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, North America

POLITICS-AMERICAS: Mixing Markets With Democracy

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Mar 8 1998 (IPS) - Does moving to a market economy in the present era of globalisation, when capitalism reigns supreme, strengthen or weaken democracy in the Americas?

This question ran through two days of discussions held to celebrate the 50th anniversary here of the Organisation of American States (OAS); and, despite the best efforts of some of the hemisphere’s most prominent political and intellectual personalities, an answer proved elusive.

The “great paradox” in Latin America today, according to Virginia Vargas, president of the Centro de la Mujer Peruana ‘Flora Tristan’ in Lima, is the flourishing of political democracy alongside a social and economic system “which is fragile and unjust.”

Not only is it the strains imposed by globalisation and economic liberalisation that threaten the progress made in the region over the past ten or 15 years in consolidating democracy, according to most speakers. Indeed, former Chilean President Patricio Aylwin insisted that these were “good times for democracy in the hemisphere.”

Aylwin credited the collapse of both Communist totalitarianism and the “national security doctrine,” as well as a growing appreciation for human rights and as the resumption of economic growth. At the same time, however, he cited a number of institutional, cultural and structural obstacles that still threaten democracy’s consolidation.

These include weaknesses in the region’s systems of justice, imbalances of power between branches of government, the “lack of a democratic” tradition and national consensus in some countries. Then there is corruption, monopolostic or oligopolistic ownership of the mass media, apathy, and the lack of participatory mechanisms that encourage broad participation in political affairs!

Among the most important challenges, Aylwin said, are the “alarming rise of inequalities and the defeat of solidarity” in the continent’s societies.

“Poverty and discrimination…undermine the moral sustainability of democracy,” he declared and posed the question: “to what extent is the prevailing economic environment compatible with democracy?”

On the one hand, said Yale University Professor Robert Dahl, modern history established a “very close relation” between a capitalist economy and the development of democratic institutions.

“(No) country with a centralised, planned economic order has been or is democratic,” he insisted.

On the other hand, “free market capitalism automatically generates inequalities in the allocation of political resources,” such as economic power and access to the mass media. In an era of globalisation, when governments are forced to liberalise their economies in order to compete for foreign capital, those inequalities can grow even faster.

In an economically advanced and diversified country with a large and politically powerful middle class, a certain amount of inequality can coexist with democratic institutions, so long as poverty is confined to a relatively small part of the population.

Inequalities are much more threatening to democracy in Latin America because of the pervasive poverty that affects roughly half of the region’s 400 million people, according to a number of speakers at the conference.

“An order of political freedoms cannot sustain itself on the fragile foundations of poverty,” said Carlos Fuentes, the great Mexican novelist and political commentator.

Despite recent years of relatively rapid growth, poverty levels “are higher today than they were before the debt crisis” of the early 1980s, Jose Antonio Ocampo, Executive Secretary of the U.N.’s Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean, told the audience.

While the incidence of poverty has been slightly reduced since the resumption of economic growth in the early 1990s, evidence is growing that the liberalisation measures taken to integrate the region into the global economy may actually be contributing to a worsening in income distribution, Ocampo said.

“The poverty that affects our people threatens democracy,” according to former Honduran President Roberto Reina. “Without addressing it, we’ll go back to those systems which flagrantly violated human rights.”

Other speakers warned that democracy could not be sustained if the poor were given little hope of improving their lives.

“We cannot speak of human rights as if it were an isolated situation,” said Nobel Peace Laureate Adolfo Perez Esquivel of Argentina. “They are also rights to development, to health, to education and work.”

The key, according to Claudette Werleigh, the former foreign minister of Haiti, was to do more to ensure the participation of all sectors of society, particularly of the poor, women, minority groups, and indigenous populations, who went unrepresented at the OAS’ celeberations this week.

“Democracy is not exclusion; it is participation,” said former OAS Secretary-General Joao Baena Soares, of Brazil. He said countries must do far more to encourage participation of their citizens who, in some ways, were better represented in the international sphere.

In his keynote speech, Fuentes also put forward a similar approach, emphasising the importance of culture and traditional sectors in devising ways to overcome the tensions between democracy and the marketplace.

“To avoid Global Darwinism, we must all come back to real people, the to re-knitting of the social tissue in the rural community, in the urban barrio, in the national society,” he said, adding that education should serve as a key to this process.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags