Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, North America

POLITICS-US: Bush, Lawmakers at Odds Over UN Retaliation

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, May 10 2001 (IPS) - The US administration told lawmakers Wednesday it opposes any effort to withhold dues or arrears to the United Nations in retaliation for last week’s loss of Washington’s seats on two key UN commissions.

Congressional aides nevertheless told IPS that the Republican- dominated House of Representatives was virtually certain to approve an amendment to a 2002 foreign-aid bill that would withhold 244 million dollars in US arrears until Washington got back its seat on the UN Human Rights Commission.

“I would think we’ll have more than 300 votes,” a spokesman for the House International Relations Committee said. That number would be well over the 218 needed to achieve a majority and could be seen as a sharp rebuff to Bush’s efforts to prevent Congress from retaliating against the world body.

Such a move, if approved by the Senate, could also set back several years of efforts to clear US arrears to the United Nations, a final agreement on which was hammered out last year between the Congress and the administration of President Bill Clinton.

“The United Nations will be the loser, and, over the long run, (the United States) will be,” said retired Ambassador William Luers, head of the UNA-USA organisation, a membership group advocating closer ties between Washington and the UN.

US officials were stunned last week when the UN’s 54-member Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC), voted for the first time against seating a US representative on the human rights commission since it was founded in 1946. Out of the regional slate in which Washington was running, delegates chose Sweden, Austria, and France instead.

On the same day, ECOSOC also voted against re-electing Washington to a seat on the International Narcotics Control Board, where it had served over the last nine years.

While the vote on the narcotics body has attracted little attention, the human rights commission defeat evoked outrage here, particularly because some countries which were elected to the Commission, including Sudan, have been tagged by Washington as among the world’s worst human-rights abusers.

“It is absurd that rogue states and chronic human rights abusers such as Libya, Sudan and Cuba remain on the commission and sit in judgment on the human rights practices of others while the United States now stands on the sidelines,” declared California Democrat Tom Lantos, who is co-sponsoring the amendment to withhold arrears with the chairman of the House International Relations Committee, Henry Hyde.

That amendment, which was submitted Tuesday, provides that 244 million dollars, out of a total package of more than 900 million dollars which Washington is paying in accumulated arrears to the UN, will now be withheld until the US regains a seat on the Commission.

The amount to be withheld under the amendment was actually a compromise between more right-wing Republicans who wanted to withhold more than 500 million dollars in arrears and others who urged a less-radical approach.

It was only last year that the Republican-led Congress, particularly Senate Foreign Relations Chairman Jesse Helms, agreed to begin paying the arrears, a process which is now threatened by this latest turn of events.

On Wednesday, the Bush administration came out strongly against the amendment. “While the United States is disappointed with the results of the Human Rights Commission election, the president feels strongly this issue should not be linked to the payment of our arrears to the UN and other international organisations,” White House spokesman Ari Fleisher said.

State Department spokesman Richard Boucher echoed that view. “We don’t think that linking our obligations and payments to the United Nations to the outcome of that particular vote is a good idea,” he said. “We think that would be extremely damaging to our ability to cooperate in multilateral organisations.”

The administration also received support from some key right- wingers, including Ronald Reagan’s former UN ambassador Jeane Kirkpatrick, who denounced the withholding of arrears as “a very inappropriate statement of opposition or outrage.”

“It is not the United Nations who vote; it is member-states who vote,” she said.

But whether such statements will be enough to stem the tide against the UN in the House is doubtful, as House aides insisted that there remained a strong majority in favour of the Hyde-Lantos amendment.

If approved, the amendment would still have to be considered by the Senate, which is unlikely to take up the foreign-aid bill until the summer at the earliest. Some aides said they believed that the outrage was likely to cool by then, and the Senate may not approve a similar provision.

The two bills would then have to be reconciled in a conference committee which could decide to drop the amendment, particularly if by then the administration works out some arrangement with the European Union (EU), which will now have three members on the Commission, that will ensure Washington’s return.

Assuming the House passes the amendment, Helms will likely play a key role in determining its fate in the Senate and in negotiations with the House. ” Sen. Helms in general is not in favour of changes (to the arrears package),” said one aide, “but he’s also very concerned about the legitimacy of the Human Rights Commission.”

The reasons for Washington’s defeat on the Commission vote have become the subject of much debate here with explanations ranging from poor diplomacy to a backlash by developing countries, the EU, and others to the Washington’s tardiness in paying its arrears and the unilateralist course the Bush administration has taken on the global environment, human rights, and arms control.

Luers, whose offices are based opposite UN headquarters in New York, said he believed all three factors were at work, but most important was the lack of a US ambassador on-site with clout to mobilise diplomacy behind the election. John Negroponte, Bush’s choice as ambassador, has not been formally nominated yet.

Cuba, Sudan and China – all of which have been the target of US- sponsored resolutions at the UNHRC – have also been assailed as the ringleaders behind the effort to exclude Washington, but a number of right-wingers have complained that it was the EU which made it possible.

Indeed, a backlash against the EU may be one result of the incident. “If the EU is so focused on solidarity (in its voting),” noted the Helms aide, “maybe it’s time for the EU to have one permanent seat on the Security Council (instead of Britain and France), and give the other one to Japan.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags