Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

ALGERIA: Violence Persists as West Dithers and Differs in Policy

Barbara Borst and Cherif Cordahi

PARIS, Jun 1 1995 (IPS) - Political violence in Algeria has left more than 60 foreigners dead, but to date Americans have not been targeted — a significant fact, analysts say, reflective of Washington’s “open-minded” approach toward militant groups.

But while the U.S. approach may be saving its citizens resident in Algeria from violent attacks, analysts say Western governments have failed to adopt a single, coherent policy aimed at bringing peace to the North African country

Not surprisingly, mainly Europeans have been targetted in a civil war, and this say analysts, is not only as a result of traditional colonial ties, but because of France’s contradictory stances on Algeria.

For while the United States remains tolerant to the Islamic forces involved in a bitter battle to win power from the military- led government, some French government ministers have on the one hand adopted a hardline stance toward the militants, while others have said they would try to seek a negotiated settlement.

Political violence has claimed more than 30,000 lives in Algeria since the military canceled parliamentary elections in January 1992, that the main Islamic party — the Islamic Salvation Front (FIS) was poised to win.

Though the West, including the United States, condemned the government’s move lightly, little pressure was immediately brought to bear on the regime to force it to change its mind.

And since the ensuing violence and the apparent stalemate, the United States has quietly sought through a carrot-and-stick approach to convince the government to reach a negotiated solution, much to the annoyance of some quarters in France, the former colonial power in Algeria.

“The Americans are playing this very cool,” says Hussein Amin, former Egyptian Ambassador to Algeria. “They are determined not to get caught with their pants down as they did in Iran.”

But analysts say that in the end, the policies of France — because of its own traditional ties as well as a result of its weight in the European Union (EU) — will have to play the deciding role in any final peace agreement in the dispute.

They also say that international lending institutions have a role to play in bringing pressure to bear on the Algerian authorities to seek a negotiated settlement and in this regard thee United States and the West as a whole have been criticised for not putting conditions on aid to the government.

Last month, the U.S. was instrumental in securing Algeria commercial debt relief worth 3.2 billion dollars.

The rescheduling, achieved after seven months of hard negotiations in London, is likely to secure Algeria further loans from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) worth one billion dollars to prop up its ailing economy.

Though the rescheduling covers commercial loans only, the deal will help convince foreign governments to reschedule Algeria’s public debt worth a further 20 billion dollars.

In its rescheduling deal signed earlier this month, Algerian officials convinced banks in Europe, Japan, North American and the Arab countries that they be repay 1.1 billion dollars in the first 10 years and the remainder over the next decade.

Raymond Benhaim of the Centre for Studies in International Solidarity in Paris, charged that Western governments and international financial institutions bolster the authorities with debt rescheduling and other assistance.

Western leaders “always think that with more money one can gain time,” Benhaim said, adding that in Algeria, financial aid hardens government resolve to crush fundamentalists.

“If France doesn’t condition its aid and the International Monetary Fund’s aid on restarting dialogue, it’s going to get worse,” he warned. “They (the military regime) are going to force the Islamists into terrorist acts in France and elsewhere overseas.”

Indeed, the United States is warning its citizens in Algeria — believed to be less than 100 — to be on the alert against militant attacks.

Last week, the U.S. State Department issued an advisory warning its citizens in Algeria to “have substantial armed protection while traveling overland, on their work sites or in their accommodations”.

The U.S. advisory follows a little publicised move by the State Department earlier this month adding Algeria’s militant Armed Islamic Group, better known by its French acronym, GIA, to its list of international terrorist groups.

The GIA, perhaps the most extreme group, has claimed responsibility for most killings of foreigners.

Analysts say it began its campaign against the foreigners, particularly the French, in 1993 in a bid to damage the Algerian government’s external relations and give the international community the impression that the regime had lost control of the country.

The campaign, which has been condemned by the Islamic Salvation Front, has forced thousands of foreigners to leave. Most of those who have stayed are in the vital oil and gas industry or with embassies.

By singling out the GIA for its list, analysts say Washington has shown a high degree of sophistication in its policy towards Algeria. Though the United States has condemned the GIA to its terrorist list, it continues to maintain links with other groups which it knows are also violent.

Its main links are with FIS’ military wing, the Islamic Salvation Army (AIS), which is believed recently to have joined forces with the GIA.

Anwar Haddam, a senior FIS official, has been living in the United States for the last two years, and, unlike other Muslim militant leaders from Arab countries, remains a free man. This is inspite of statements by Haddam defending attacks against Algerian and foreign civilians.

“There is nothing odd about U.S. policy in Algeria,” says a Western diplomat in Cairo. “It is just trying to keep its options open.”

The Algerian government, which claims to be containing the militant campaign even though it has lost control of large swathes of the countryside, canceled a second round of elections at the end of 1992 which FIS was poised to win.

By adding the GIA to its terrorist list, the United States has pleased the Algerian government. But by leaving the FIS off, it has also angered it.

The United States is not competing with France for influence in Algeria but filling a leadership gap, said Benhaim.

France’s new government has not yet indicated whether it will change its policy of the past two years. Indeed, that policy was never uniform with one part of the government taking a hardline stance and the other seeking negotiations.

Charles Pasqua, former interior minister, made a show of deporting suspected FIS sympathisers and fostering ties with Algerian security forces. Alain Juppe, then foreign minister and now prime minister, favoured negotiations.

Pasqua was a hardliner who claimed there were no moderate Islamic fundamentalists with whom to negotiate and who was in favour of delivering arms to Algerian security forces, charged Farid Aissani, Paris representative of the Front of Socialist Forces (FFS), a major Algerian opposition party.

When contacted by IPS this week, foreign ministry officials did not respond to repeated requests for details of the new government’s policy.

Aissani said Juppe’s preference for negotiation is encouraging but “we’ll see if it is followed by concrete actions.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags