Thursday, November 19, 2026
Deborah Horan
- Israel began to set free some 1,100 jailed Palestinians in the first round of Oslo 2-inspired mass prisoner release Tuesday.
But thousands of others remained in their cells, untouched for now by the peace agreement that is set to extend Palestinian self- rule throughout the West Bank.
An estimated 4,200 Palestinians prisoners will remain in jail until just prior to Palestinian elections, tentatively set for sometime between January and April of next year, according to the terms agreed upon by Israel and the Palestinians.
It is then that another 1,000 or so are scheduled for release.
A third mass release should come some time after that, but the accord, signed late last month on the White House lawn, does not specify a date or the number to be released.
The piecemeal approach to prisoner release reflects Israel’s reluctance to give up all its cards before it gauges the success of the Oslo 2 accord, say analysts here. The Rabin government also does not want to appear to be capitulating to a Palestinian demand on such an explosive issue, many analysts say.
But Palestinians also put the delicate topic at the top of their list of grievances they say should be immediately addressed. With almost every Palestinian family having had someone in prison at sometime during the seven-year-uprising, the problem hits a national chord.
“We would like to see all prisoners released,” said Mohammad Wahiedi, spokesman for Palestinian negotiator and planning minister Nabil Shaath. “Prisoners is an emotional issue for Palestinians. They think that when peace comes, prisoners should be freed.”
Tuesday’s release, anticipated for two weeks, caused an outcry among both Israelis and Palestinians, albeit for different reasons. Right wing Israeli groups decried the left-leaning Labor- led government for releasing Palestinians with “blood on their hands” — those who had killed or wounded Jews or Palestinians.
Palestinians condemned Israel’s decision not to release four female prisoners who were convicted of murder or aiding murder as a violation of the accord, which states that Israel will release all women in the first round.
“It is clearly mentioned that female prisoners should be released,” said Khaled Batrawi, field work coordinator for Al- Haz, a Palestinian human rights organization in the West Bank. “This is clearly a violation.”
The decision not to release two of the women came from Israeli President Ezer Weizmann, who was under pressure from Israeli right wing groups, including a group called “Victims of Arab Terror” not to release prisoners who had killed or maimed. The other two did not receive commutation from Maj.-Gen. Ilan Biran, head of the West Bank military government.
Under Israeli law, only the president has the power to commute prison sentences handed down by Israeli courts, while only the head of the military government can grant early release to prisoners convicted in West Bank military courts.
“When we signed the agreement, it was not a secret that it is Israel who will decide to release prisoners,” said Environment Minister Yossi Beilin. “It’s was not a secret that [the president] has this right.”
“I can understand the Palestinian point of view, but it should be clear to the Palestinian side, that we cannot change our constitution,” said Beilin.
However, this reasoning did not satisfy Palestinians or an independent Israeli monitoring group called Peace Watch concurred in the assessment that failing to release the women constituted a violation of the agreement.
“If there is a peace agreement signed by [Israel] and afterwards ratified by the Knesset, then the reference in the agreement supercedes Israeli internal laws,” said Batrawi. “Israel should fulfill its obligations.”
Seven hundred of the 1,100 prisoners slated for release in this round were to be released Tuesday, according to army sources. By 6 p.m. some 350 had been released. The additional 400 are expected to be released over the next few days. Six hundred of those released are “criminal” prisoners, while the other 500 are political prisoners.
All but one of the 23 female prisoners opted to stay in prison in solidarity with the four who were not granted commutation. The one, 18-year-old Bashayer Abu Laban, said she left prison after being in solitary confinement, where she did not hear about the other women prisoners’ decision to remain in jail.
“It was only when I got outside that my family told me,” Abu Laban told the English-language daily Jerusalem Post from her West Bank home. “I felt terrible.”
Many of the remaining male prisoners have declared that they will go on a hunger strike to protest Israel refusal to release the four women, at the urging of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat.
Palestinians have said they will appeal to sponsors of the peace process, world leaders, and Pope John Paul II, to pressure Israel to agree to release the women, one of whom is an Israeli Arab citizen imprisoned for 12 years for killing a Jewish religious student in 1988.
Israeli Arab Ahmen Tibi, who is the political advisor to Arafat on Israeli affairs, has petitioned the Israeli High Court to rule that Israel’s agreement with the Palestinians supercedes the president’s right to refuse to commute prison sentences.
“I hope this will make Israel come down to the ground of reality and respect the agreement,” said Tibi.
This is not the first Oslo-related prisoner release. In May 1994, shortly after the Gaza Strip and Jericho areas came under Palestinian self-rule, Israel released 4,500 prisoners. Most of them returned to Gaza.
Some 500, from towns in the West Bank, went to Jericho, because the agreement required them to go to an area under Palestinian self-rule and lived in caravans donated by the Dutch government. Now that the self-rule area is expanding, they, and the new releases, will be allowed to go to their home towns.
However, while thousands have been released, thousands more have been arrested since self-rule came to Gaza and Jericho. The Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem estimates that move than 2,000 Palestinians, mainly from the Islamic rejectionist groups, Hamas and Islamic Jihad, but also from leftist opposition groups, like the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, have been arrested.
The simultaneous releases and arrests going on since Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization formally decided to seek a rapprochement has prompted several cynical cartoons in Palestinian newspapers, usually involving revolving doors.
The issue is equally explosive on the Israeli side, with public opinion against releasing Palestinians who have committed violent acts. Many say they are afraid that those released will not keep their pledges not to resort to violence.
Israel’s opposed to mass prisoner release point to last year’s kidnapping of a 19-year-old Israeli soldier by Hamas members, one of whom turned out to be a recently-released prisoner.