Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

KUWAIT-HUMAN RIGHTS: Progress Praised, But More Needed – Amnesty

Senthil Ratnasabapthy

VIENNA, Feb 21 1996 (IPS) - Kuwait has instituted a number of political and human rights reforms and been praised for it by human rights NGO Amnesty International, but the group has also rapped the oil rich country for failing to investigate past misdeeds.

In a new report titled ‘Kuwait – Five Years of Impunity’, the London based watchdog says that despite a number of positive rights developments since 1992, government authorities still have to address the human rights violations that occurred during the post Gulf War martial law period in 1991.

Martial law was imposed in February 1991 following Iraq’s defeat by a U.S. led military coalition and its subsequent withdrawal from Kuwait, which it occupied in August 1990. It was imposed initially for a three month period, but was extended until late June the same year.

The 19-page report is accompanied by a ten-point recommendation list which includes a call for a thorough and independent investigation into violations reported immediately after the withdrawal of Iraqi forces.

Reforms began in earnest in October 1992, when polls were held for the 50-seat national assembly, which had been dissolved by the Kuwaiti emir six years earlier.

A parliamentary Committee for the Defence of Human Rights (CDHR) was also created with the power to investigate complaints from the public and to make non-binding recommendations to the authorities.

Besides setting up human rights sections in the ministries of foreign affairs and justice and setting up a permanent working group in the interior ministry to go into complaints made by the CDHR, Amnesty International also cites reports that the committee’s work also improved conditions in some prisons.

The government also acceded, or took steps to implement, a number of international rights instruments such as the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide last year and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.

These recent positive developments, however, sit on top of the human rights violations that occurred during the martial law period following Iraq’s withdrawal. Most, if not all, of the violations reported occurred in connection with the end of the occupation.

“Although the human rights situation has now improved considerably, the fundamental rights, usually of foreign nationals and stateless persons continue to be violated,” the report said.

Amnesty says that during the martial law period, Kuwaiti government forces and armed civilians, “often acting with the knowledge or acquiescence of government officials,” carried out a campaign of arbitrary arrests, torture and extrajudicial executions of persons suspected of collaboration with Iraqi forces.

Close to 1,000 people were arbitrarily arrested during this period and at least 70 have ‘disappeared’ — those who were detained but of whom no information is available. Most of the victims were non-Kuwaitis, including Iraqis, Palestinians, Jordanians and members of the Bidun community (stateless Arabs), the report said.

The Martial Law Court tried 164 cases of alleged collaborators before it was dissolved with the end of martial law. The estimated 450 cases awaiting trial were transferred to its successor, the State Security Court which was itself abolished in August 1995.

However Amnesty says that the process fails to tackle the issue of the violations following Iraqi withdrawal and that flaws in the trial process.

Kuwait’s ambassador to Belgium has told the local Amnesty section that his government has tried two Kuwaiti officials for such violations, but Amnesty questions the seriousness of the intent behind of these indictments.

“Given the hundreds of reports of violations during the Martial Law period, including torture, the failure to publish a single report of any investigations of these reports of violations and the figure of two convictions suggest that the Kuwaiti authorities are not taking their obligations… seriously.”

Similarly, an Amnesty report to the Kuwaiti officials in late 1991 documenting 11 persons who reportedly died in custody after torture remains unanswered, it added.

Although the violations occurred during the 1991 martial law period, Amnesty has also expressed concern about a number of actions by the government to curb rights since then.

One of the areas of concern regards the media and non- governmental organisations (NGOs). Censorship was lifted in 1992, but Amnesty notes reports that since then several journalists have been arrested and detained briefly, and some fined, in connection with offences such as criticising government policies or officials.

In 1993 the Kuwaiti Council of Ministers also issued a decree curtailing the activities of NGOs. It also ordered the closedown of ‘unlicensed’ NGOs, including the Kuwaiti Association to Defend War Victims, the country’s leading rights group, and the Hostages and Missing Committee.

Of particular concern to the international human rights group was the reintroduction of the death penalty in 1993 and its extension of its scope last year to include drug related crime.

At least six persons have since been hanged and several more are on death row. Capital punishment, which Amnesty strongly opposes as both an abuse of rights and an ineffective means of halting crime, was applied in cases of ‘crimes’ committed during Iraq’s occupation and for rape and murder.

The human rights group’s ten point recommendations to the Kuwaiti government calls for, among others, immediate and thorough investigations into all cases of extrajudicial killings, disappearances and torture and the retrial of all those convicted under the Martial Law Court and the State Security Court.

The group also called for the commuting of death sentences and that all detainees given full access to lawyers.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags