Thursday, November 19, 2026
Andrei Ivanov
- The dismissal by presidential decree of Russian diamond industry chief official Yevgeny Bychkov is only the latest twist in Russia’s tortuous talks to ease the grip of South African trading giant De Beers on the sale of Russian diamonds.
Russia refuses to renew its old agreement with De Beers which expired at the end of 1995, which gave the CSO control over 95 percent of Russia’s uncut diamonds. Talks led by Bychkov, head of the State Committee for Precious Metals and Stones (Roskomdragmet), have rumbled on for over a year with no conclusion.
His dismissal on Wednesday came on the day of the scheduled opening of a third round of talks with De Beers. Bychkov’s place at the talks is being taken by Finance Minister Vladimir Panskov.
Speculation is rising within the industry that the Bychkov was fired to ease De Beers’ frustration and clear the way to a quick resolution to the negotiations; London sources say chaos reigns within the Russian industry and that Bychkov was clearly unable to bring this massive hard currency earner into line.
President Boris Yeltsin’s press office said Bychkov “lacked personal discipline in carrying out the president’s and government’s instructions”.
Aside from the inconclusive talks process, the industry is being rocked by corruption claims, bilateral deals, varying pricing scales and bitter rivalry between the different sectors of the industry, some of whom are challenging Roskomdragmet hard.
There were further corruption allegations relating to 88 million dollars of uncut diamonds supplied last year to the U.S. firm Golden Ardour. The uncut stones were sent to the firm’s cutting factory in San Francisco but the payement allegedly never reached Roskomdragmet.
Bychkov admits to making mistakes but points out that legal proceedings have been started against the U.S. firm. He denies any corruption and says his removal is purely political.
Panskov has been unable to deny outright that Bychkov’s dismissal was linked to the negotiations. “It’s difficult for me to talk about it,” he says. “It may simply be a coincidence.”
He said Russia is still taking a firm line with De Beers on its aim to build up the Russian diamond cutting sector. “We are insisting strongly that Russia should export not uncut diamonds but cut diamonds,” said Panskov. “If the gentlemen from De Beers don’t agree to our conditions we won’t continue the talks. That’s our position.”
Estimates by Roskomdragmet experts quoted by the daily Nezavisimaya Gazeta suggest that the expansion of the country’s diamond-cutting sector would create over 14,000 new jobs and provide add nearly 2.4 billion dollars to the federal budget.
One of Bychkov’s last acts as Chairman was to sign a memorandum of understanding with Botswana, intended to promote direct cooperation between diamond producers and traders and bypassing De Beers.
The two sides agreed to exchange information on a regular basis “for the purpose of harmonising methods of selling diamonds in order to ensure equitable sharing of the market”.
They also agreed to “explore the feasibility and viability of creating an appropriate forum to promote liaison and cooperation between all major producers of diamonds”.
But the new player in the Russian industry developments is the diamond company Almazy Rossii-Sakha (ARS) which has been in dispute with Roskomdragmet recently over the respective roles of the two organisations and national pricing policy.
ARS first vice president Lev Safonov says Bychkov’s departure will not affect the course of the talks with De Beers. Safonov says a special commission, chaired by prime minister Viktor Chernomyrdin, has worked out “a common Russian approach” and denies there is any difference of opinion among the commission members.
He supports the general principle that Russia should keep more uncut diamonds in the country to develop its own cutting and jewellery industry. ARS, based in the Yakut Republic in Siberia, has however made it clear that it intends to develop and expand its own role in the industry.
This is the main source of tension with Roskomdragmet. “ARS is against creating a structure which would monopolise the sale of rough diamonds,” says Safonov. “We are flatly against extractors being obliged to give its products to somebody else, which has been the practice over the past few decades.”
ARS is Russia’s biggest diamond producer and regularly holds fourth or fifth place in the world in the sale of rough diamonds. Admitting that the differences with Roskomdragmet, Safonov says some state officials want to deprive the company of the right to own its products.
He believes that the Russian Rosalmaz selling organisation should represent the state and work with the diamond stocks in the state depository. He wants a single pricing policy on the Russian market for rough diamonds and says the company will sell its products to Rosalmaz, but only at world prices.
Meanwhile ARS plans to set up a London subsidiary, Diamonds of Russia-Sakha UK, with an authorised capital of 10 million dollars. The company aims to attract a billion dollars in investment in the next five years, according to company vice president Semen Zelberg.
He says annual investment will mostly be channelled into mining. ARS spent around 109 billion roubles (24.2 million dollars) of its total profits on mining and around 485 billion roubles (107.7 million dollars) on compnay staff welfare provision last year.
Capital investments totalled about 800 billion (177.7 million dollars). Preliminary estimates for 1995 put ARS’s total revenue at 5,360 billion roubles (1.19 billion dollars), with sales profit totalling 3,300 billion roubles (733 million dollars).
The company hopes to process 100 million dollars worth of diamonds in 1996, says company managing director Sergey Ulin. “ARS has a stable raw materials base across Yakutia, with diamond stocks that will last until at least 2050.”
He explains that, while production targets had been the company’s priority in the past, the cost-effectiveness of individual diamond fields is now taking precedence.
“Relations between ARS and the De Beers corporation are not antagonistic,” he stresses, adding that there are numerous means of achieving a balance between supply and demand on the world diamond market and for regulating the market itself.
It seems that in the diamond industry power struggle ARS has won the first round.