Active Citizens, Civil Society, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines

UZBEKISTAN: Would-Be ‘Tiger’ Burns Bright In Central Asian Forests

Sergei Strokan

MOSCOW, Mar 18 1996 (IPS) - While Russia is hastily trying to reassert its influence in the five former Soviet Central Asian republics, one — Uzbekistan — has begun an ambitious effort to establish itself as the key political and economic power in the region.

These ambitions have set Moscow teeth grinding, especially since the failure of Russian foreign minister Yevgeni Primakov’s trip to Uzbek capital of Tashkent — the only state which Primakov has needed to visit twice since his appointment in January.

Yet all his attempts to draw Tashkent closer to Moscow and the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) have been rebuffed by Uzbek strongman president Islam Karimov. Tashkent has further added insult to injury by claiming that draft bilateral agreements presented by Primakov were “poorly drafted”.

Another point of contention is Uzbekistan’s tinkering with the crisis in neighbouring Tajikistan. While the Kremlin tries to keep the pro-Moscow government of Imomali Rakhmonov in power, feeding him cash and arms for his war against armed Tajik rebels, Tashkent urges compromise with the militants.

Recent clashes in the Tavil-Dara district have pointed up Rakhmonov’s apparent inability to crush the opposition after years of fighting, and Tashkent sees its case gaining strength.

“Karimov would like to see a Tajik leadership loyal first to Uzbekistan and his interests,” said Sanobar Shermatova, a Central Asia expert with the weekly Moscow News. “Russian troops patrol the Tajik-Afghan border, fighting incursions by Afghan mujahadin supporters of the Tajik opposition. And the mujahadin are run by (rebel warlord) ‘General Dustum’ — an ethnic Uzbek”.

In March Uzbekistan began an unprecedented PR campaign, taking a host of academics and journalists on a VIP tour of the republic.

Uzbekistan, once the poorest of the former Soviet republics, lived on Moscow’s largesse for years, but is now going all out to prove that it is a thriving democratic state, as opposed to what it calls ‘chaotic’ Russia. But in recent months its new controls on the Erk and Birlik democratic opposition and the persecution of the emerging free press has drawn fire from human rights groups.

Helsinki Watch human rights group Moscow representative Rachel Denber says the group is planning a report confirming “widespread human rights abuse” in Uzbekistan. The charges are stoutly denied.

“We are a market democracy with national traits. When we talk about our course — some call it ‘the Uzbek model’ — we first mean that we are reforming, but not at any price, like our neighbours,” Karimov told a visiting journalist. “Our results in the last three to four years confirm the correctness of our choice.”

“Tashkent’s deaf ear to Moscow stems from Karimov’s confidence that the republic can survive without Russia,” said Sergei Solodovnik, leading research fellow at the Moscow International Relations Institute.

“Karimov is inspired by the Tiger economies of south-east Asia like Singapore. For him the Eastern model of an authoritarian ‘controlled democracy’ proves you do not need political freedoms as a prerequisite of economic growth”.

Historically, Uzbekistan has been run by regional family clans. Tight state control of economic and political life coupled with a refusal to overturn secure patriarchies in favour of destabilising ‘Western liberalism’ has — claim Uzbek officials — made the country a secure home for foreign investment.

Per capita foreign investment is already three times higher than in Russia. Most of it goes towards industrial diversification in an attempt to lessen dependence upon cotton exports. Cotton fibre accounted for 57.8 percent of exports in 1995.

Latest projects include a 500-million dollar car plant to be built by the South Korean industrial giant Daewoo in the town of Asaka and a tobacco factory in Samarkand financed by British- American Tobacco.

According to Karimov, in three years the republic will become self-sufficient in energy thanks to developing its natural gas deposits. Uzbek gas and electricity is already exported to neighbouring states, including areas of Afghanistan controlled by General Dustum. Gas exports made up 14 percent of 1995 exports.

Just a few years ago, Uzbekistan had to spend half of its cotton export revenues to buy fuel and electricity. Unconfirmed reports say the country has also become the fifth largest world exporter of uranium.

Yet this month Uzbekistan posted a foreign trade surplus of 216.2 million dollars for 1995, up 135.8 million dollars on the previous year, the Interfax news agency reported. Uzbekistan’s Forecasting and Statistics Committees said trade with non-CIS nations rose from 41.5 percent of the 1994 total to 56.5 percent in 1995.

Overall volume of foreign trade increased 13.2 percent to 622.06 million dollars in 1995. Importantly, Uzbekistan exported more primary commodities such as cotton and energy and imported less food, energy while importing more capital goods.

Last year exports rose 15.6 percent to 419.1 million dollars and imports rose 10.9 percent to 202.9 million — including a 240 percent increase in imports of plant and machinery for the newly booming Uzbek light industrial sector.

It is this new economic power that has allowed Uzbekistan, which has borders with all Central Asian states, to play its own game in the region.

Karimov’s regime has several times cut off its gas and electricity exports to Kirgizstan and Tajikistan, to further its new-found regional ambitions.

Tashkent also wields influence through a sizeable Uzbek diaspora at work in these countries. Its position of strength is further reinforced by a 70,000-strong and well equipped army, which has sealed the border with Tajikistan, effectively preventing a spill- over of the unrest there.

Uzbekistan is now planning to challenge the increasingly amorphous CIS by creating a Central Asian alliance linking it with Kazakhstan and Kirgizstan, echoing the original CIS concept of a ‘common home’ for the former Soviet nations by propounding a ‘common home of Central Asia’.

On his initiative an Interstate Council consisting of Uzbek, Kazakh and Kirgiz representatives has been formed with Tashkent trying to get it internationally recognised.

“Next, we should expect Tashkent to try to move in as the main arbiter in the Tajik conflict,” said Ruslan Budrin, a RIA-Novosti news agency Asian expert. “We can also expect Karimov put forward an initiative on international control over the situation in Afghanistan.

“Since Russia’s supply routes to the Kabul government of Burhanuddin Rabbani go through or over Uzbek territory, Tashkent has ways and means to minimize Moscow’s influence in Afghanistan too”.

Another manifestation of Tashkent’s independence from Moscow could be a closer cooperation with Washington and institutions like the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) and the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD).

“Ideally Uzbekistan would like to be seen by Washington as ‘The Ukraine of Central Asia’, said Solodovnik, “to be supported as a counterbalance to Russia on its Eastern flank.”

But to achieve this Islam Karimov would have to change his attitude to human rights issues. An OSCE team led by Audrey Glover, director of the OSCE Bureau for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights, this month visited Uzbekistan to look into the country’s human rights record.

“For a lot of prospective investors reports of legal discrimination from a country can still nullify investment guarantees,” noted the Moscow daily Nezavisimaya Gazeta.

According to government statistics, companies from more than 70 countries have equity investments in Uzbekistan, with the biggest investors being Turkey (106 ventures), the United States (104) and Russia (99). Uzbekistan has registered a total of 1,818 joint ventures and foreign companies, of which only half are so far in operation.

But Karimov still has some more work to do on his international public relations. “Washington has demonstrated its discontent with the situation in Uzbekistan in this regard,” added the Nezavisimaya Gazeta dryly, “by so far refusing to invite Karimov for a state visit.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags