Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

VENEZUELA: Debate on Oil Privatization Goes On, and On…

Humberto Marquez

CARACAS, May 7 1996 (IPS) - The long-running debate on whether to privatize Venezuela’s oil industry shows no sign of coming to any quick conclusion.

Oil was nationalized here in 1976 but falling prices have proked an economic economic that has pushed 80 percent of the population below the poverty and a proposed austerity plan would impoverish them even more.

Constitutionally the state owns the subterranean soil of Venezuela and the oil industry has been a monopoly of state-run Venezuelan Petroleum (PDVSA) – until it began sharing some of its segments with private capital in 1991.

“I think that in any company like PDVSA, without the damage of controls, of national autonomy, it would be very healthy to have 15 percent (of shares) in the capital market”, said Luis Giusti, the group’s president, in the midst of the debate.

Giusti admitted, in a television interview, that this sale would imply modifying the nationalization law created by PDSVA 20 years ago. “But I think this is the way to go”, he added.

The government’s response came at once. “The oil deposits will not be sold, lent, or given away. We can only deal with the infrastructure that surround the deposits”, said Erwin Arrieta, Minister of Energy and representative of the only stock holder in PDVSA, the State.

The deposits “are an essential part of our nation’s net worth, which we inherited from our conquerors and was ratified by our Liberator (Simon Bolivar, who stressed the State’s ownership of subterranean land in an 1828 document)”, continued Arrieta.

“We are not planning to sell PDVSA. It has simply come up as an idea that is worth considering and debating as a long term option”, he declared after the press reported that Giusti was testing public opinion on the matter.

Former president Carlos Andres Perez (1974-1979, 1989-1993), who nationalized oil in 1976, told IPS that the privatization of PDVSA “is absurd, a proposal that can only be explained by the deterioration Venezuela is going through”.

Perez, a social-democrat, repeated his stance that “the privatization is totally inconvenient, since developing countries like Venezuela must have a basic industry like this one in the hands of the State”.

The debate, unthinkable a decade ago, is producing almost daily statements from all sectors that make up the public opinion, under the new economic conditions set up in Venezuela.

No one is arguing the principle inherited by the Spanish colony that the subterranean soil belongs to the Nation and not to individuals. The debate centers on whether private individuals can have a hold on the industry, on the infrastructure that permits the extraction, transformation and sale of oil, “black gold”, from this subterranean soil.

During more than 60 years (1914-1976) the exploitation of oil was done by transnational corporations, which gave rise to the industrial proletariat and to the modern political struggle whose major slogans were the agrarian reform and the nationalization of the oil industry.

After the Arab-Israeli war of 1973 produced an oil price boom, the State had enough money to take charge of the industry and realize a dream that until that point had only been used as a political campaign issue.

The nationalization law closed the door on the possibility for PDVSA to associate with private companies. This however was opened in 1983 with the “internationalization” of PDVSA (with its purchase of refineries abroad) and later in 1991 with minor joint-ventures in Venezuela.

PDVSA is, according to specialized journals, the world’s second oil company, after Saudi Arabia’s Aramco, with sales of over 26 billion dollars in 1995, twice the national budget and equivalent to the foreign debt.

The firm controls more proven crude (65 billion barrels) and gas reserves than any North American or European rival (it is the U.S.’ main provider). It is extending its activities in Latin America and it’s getting a foothold in the carbon, petrochemical and new fuels industries.

PDVSA generates 70 percent of Venezuela’s 18 billion dollar export income and more than a third of the national income, although this figure has dropped from its historic level of over 65 percent.

But as PDVSA grows, its owner -the State- is getting poorer: real salaries have dropped steadily in Venezuela since 1978, extreme poverty levels increased from less than 15 percent to over 30 percent, and general poverty has risen from less than 50 percent to over 80 percent of the population.

“It’s like starving in a bakery shop”, said Luis Machado, former Minister for the Development of Intelligence (1979-1984). “We are dying of poverty atop a carpet of 600 billion dollars”, seconded writer Arturo Uslar Pietri.

The debate heated up when, after two years of an erratic economic policy based on controls, president Rafael Caldera adopted in April a severe tightening program whose aim is to reduce inflation (85 percent yearly rate) balancing the federal budget.

It is the second austerity measure in seven years, and for Venezuelans that means that gasoline prices have gone up five- fold, the currency has gone down 70 percent, and interest rates, taxes and consumer prices have steadily risen in the past couple of months.

Independent economists, like Gustavo Garcia, have demanded that tightening policies be accompanied by an “aggressive privatization process of businesses, including the sale of PDVSA, to diminish public spending, and drastically increase the federal budget”.

Miguel Rodriguez, former Minister of Planning under Perez and organizer of the austerity measures of 1989, proposed “selling 15 or 20 percent of PDVSA’s stock and privatizing other State assets until enough resources are collected to face the debt problems”.

The foreign debt – around 27 billion dollars – consumes 40 percent of the State budget, which also has liabilities of a few billion dollars in terms of severance pay to 1,300,000 workers.

Banker Oscar Garcia said that with the privatization of only one state company, without excluding PDVSA, it would be possible to overcome the difficulties that arise with the austerity measures. Caracas’ Chamber of Commerce proposed to sell one PDVSA’s three operators to resolve the problem.

The Pro-Venezuela Association, an organization of businessmen of nationalist slant, rejected the sale of PDVSA.

In the political front, the two traditional parties, the social-democrat Accion Democratica (AD) and the social-Christian Copei, rejected, together with leftists and populists, any possibility of selling PDVSA.

However, former presidential candidates of both parties, Eduardo Fernandez (1988) and Oswaldo Alvarez (1993) of AD and Claudio Fermin (1993) of Copei, supported selling shares of PDVSA.

Former guerrilla and socialist presidential candidate Teodoro Petkoff (1983 and 1988), since March Minister of Planning under the Caldera Administration, rejected the sale because “the State should not give up its main instrument in economic policies.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags