Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

ISRAEL: Post-Election Reality Shadows Hebron Hope

Deborah Horan

JERUSALEM, Jun 4 1996 (IPS) - The frowns covering Palestinian faces in the West Bank town of Hebron in the aftermath of last week’s Israeli elections are darkened by reflection on a “what-if” question.

What if Benyamin Netanyahu of the rightwing Likud had not defeated incumbent Prime Minister Shimon Peres in last week’s elections?

In the scenario given by an outgoing Labor Minister, Yossi Beilin, if Peres had won, within 100 days the Israeli army would have redeployed its forces in Hebron. A compensation plan would have been set up for settlers. Then the government would have moved on to create a Palestinian state in all but 11 percent of the West Bank.

In the event, Peres’ loss to Netanyahu has called into question the whole future of the peace process that had taken the Palestinians several steps closer towards their dream of statehood, say analysts here. And it has put the troop withdrawals from Hebron on what could be long-term hold.

The first priority of the Likud government, which could be formed as early as June 17, will be to halt redeployment in Hebron — the only major West Bank town still under Israeli occupation — and possibly to renegotiate some of the details of the army’s move from the city, said a Likud spokesman.

The other two main Likud platform policies will be to support the expansion of Jewish settlements in the West Bank and Gaza and to work to prevent the creation of a Palestinian state, said the spokesman.

While Netanyahu pledged to continue negotiations with the Palestinians toward a final status agreement on the West Bank and Gaza, analysts here predict problems if the Likud carries out its election promises.

“There is a built in contradition between the peace process and major Likud platforms,” said Ehud Sprinzak, a political analysts at Hebrew University. “One is the issue of settlements. The other is that the Pals will never get independence.”

“This stance is in total contradiction to the Oslo agreements which specifically made it clear that at the end of the day Israel would pull out, that there would be no new settlements and that eventually the Palestinians will have control of the territory,” added Sprinzak.

The Oslo accords outlined a formula for Palestinian “self- rule” in the West Bank and Gaza, but the timetable outlined in the agreement left major issues for later negotiation and created a step-by-step process by which territory under Palestinian control would be increased — without specifying how much territory.

To date, only four percent of the West Bank and 80 percent of Gaza are under Palestinian control. In the West Bank another 30 percent of the land is under shared jurisdiction with Israel retaining “overall security” — meaning it can still arrest Palestinians or put villages under curfew there.

The rest of the West Bank — some 60 percent in which settlements and army installations are located — is completely under Israel’s control.

Three “further redeployments” of Israeli troops in the West Bank mentioned in the agreements are meant to put additional territory exclusively under Palestinian jurisdiction. But the wording of the agreement gives considerable leeway to negotiators as to how big those “redeployments” will be.

So far, Palestinians, other Arabs, and observers have reacted cautiously to Netanyahu’s victory, with Palestinians reiterating their commitment to the agreements and the expectation that Israel will also honor the accords.

They are waiting to see what the new Likud government does with regard to redeployment in Hebron, viewing the army’s withdrawal there as a “litmus test” on Likud’s sincerity to uphold agreements signed by the previous Labor government, say Palestinians.

While it is not making any formal commitment prior to taking office, a Likud spokesman alluded to a plan to “redefine” the army’s redeployment in Hebron — with Palestinian consent.

“Hebron is a special case,” said Likud spokesman Zalmon Shoval, who is slated to be Israel’s next ambassador to the United States.

“The new Israeli government will probably want to work out a formula which will ensure on the one hand the security of Jews in Hebron and Jewish rights in the city and at the same time, go ahead and transfer as much authority as possible in accordance with what the government signed.”

“If it will take some more time to work out an acceptable formula this is okay,” he added. “There can be changes.”

But while Likud’s platform contradicts many of the Palestinians’ expectations generated by the Oslo agreement and several issues already agreed upon, analysts say they expect Netanyahu to curb some of the hard-line rhetoric once he has to deal with the reality of governing.

“The biggest challenge (for Netanyahu) is the contradition between some of the issues he campaigned for and the reality that he’s going to face now that he is responsible for government because those things do not go together,” said Israeli analyst Mark Heller of the Jaffee Center for Strategic Studies.

“The impression that was conveyed that Hebron will not be included within the area of self-rule will not be tenable,” said Heller. “If you just took the party platform, then we would be heading for very serious trouble and some kind of explosion. But I would be very surprised if there wasn’t some kind of accomodation.”

But Heller also said he thinks a final agreement between the Palestinians and a Likud-led government is unlikely.

“It’s not dead yet, but there are serious challenges,” said Heller. “I would be very surprised if with the Likud, the Palestinians come to any mutual agreement.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags