Thursday, November 19, 2026
Dilip Hiro
- The word in Tel Aviv has it that newly elected Israeli premier Binyamin Netanyahu plans a surprise strike when he meets U.S. president Bill Clinton in Washington Tuesday — by trying to unveil a plan for a peace accord with Lebanon.
The Israeli leader is keen to find a way to deflect pressure from Clinton to resume peace talks with the Palestinians and Syria along the lines pursued by his predecessor, Shimon Peres.
A ‘Lebanon First’ policy, as touted by Israeli media citing prime ministerial sources last week, would also give Netanyahu the chance to be seen taking the initiative, something he likes.
He is clear on what he does not want to talk about. He is resisting pressure from the U.S. to reopen top-level talks with the Palestinian Authority and to get on with a long-delayed withdrawal from Hebron, the last West Bank town under Israeli occupation.
The Palestinians have complained about lack of communication with the new government and Netanyahu has said he would meet with Arafat only “if deemed necessary to Israel’s security”.
As for Hebron, troubled home to 450 Jewish settlers and 94,000 Palestinians, Netanyahu told Israeli Army Radio before leaving for the U.S. on Monday that he did not intend to raise that question in Washington either.
“I believe hasty moves in Hebron or anywhere else can lead to violence and a deterioration of security that will hurt both the peace process and the Palestinians,” he said.
On what he will speak about he has no official comment — a Monday statement from Netanyahu’s office noted only that he “did not intend to leak to the press issues he would bring up with the American president”.
But few expect him to be anything less than combative with Clinton. His usual strategy, echoing the Roman poet Ovid’s view that maybe ‘the best defence is always a good attack’, served Netanyahu well in his recent prime ministerial contest.
During the election campaign, 46 year-old Netanyahu confidently predicted that his rival, 72 year-old Peres, would uproot the Jewish settlements in the West Bank and Gaza, divide Jerusalem, and allow hundreds of thousands of Palestinians to return home, thus endangering Israel’s ‘demographic security’.
He thus put Peres on the defensive, who found himself having to conduct the electoral debate within the framework defined by Netanyahu.
This time around, Netanyahu is treating Clinton as a virtual rival. A deep chasm exists between the policy guidelines of the new Netanyahu government, and the positions that Washington has taken on the Middle East peace process launched with an international conference in Madrid, Spain, in October 1991.
Allowing for the diversion of the Oslo peace accords between Israel and the Palestinians, and a peace treaty between Israel and Jordan signed in 1994, the regional peace process has now settled down into two tracks: the Palestinian track and the Syrian- Lebanese track.
On both these fronts, the Netanyahu cabinet has laid down a hard line position.
On the Palestinian front, the new official Israeli positions are first, to strengthen and develop Jewish settlements in the West Bank and Gaza, and ensure that they retain their ‘affinity’ with Israel. Secondly they wish to maintain the Israeli military’s power to ‘go anywhere to ensure the security of Jews’ — presumably including the territories controlled by the Palestinian Authority.
Thirdly they oppose the formation of a Palestinian state. Four, oppose the return of Palestinian refugees to ‘any part of the Eretz Israel (the ‘biblical Land of Israel’) west of the Jordan River’. Five, thwart any attempt to undermine the unity of Jerusalem and prevent any action which is counter to exclusive Israeli sovereignty over the holy city in its totality.
On the Syrian front, Netanyahu’s policy is simple: retain Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights. Since Syrian president Hafez Assad is committed to recovering all of the occupied Golan Heights, this track of the peace process should be considered closed.
In that case there can be no progress on the Israeli-Lebanese front either. Article Five of the Syrian-Lebanese Treaty of Brotherhood, Cooperation and Coordination, signed in May 1991, requires the contracting parties to coordinate their ‘Arab and international policies’.
The two neighbours have been doing so ever since. The latest example was their absence from the summit of 27 countries on ‘terrorism’ at the Egyptian port of Sharm al-Shaikh in March.
As such, everybody involved in the Middle East peace process has understood, and accepted, the reality that only after Israel has worked out a peace accord with Syria will the stage be set for serious peace talks between it and Lebanon.
Nevertheless Netanyahu still hopes he can change this by initiating his ‘Lebanon First’ policy.
He could do so by implementing the United Nations Security Council Resolution 425, passed during the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in March 1978. It requires Israel to ‘withdraw forthwith its forces from all Lebanese territory’ — unilaterally.
If Netanyahu decides to vacate the Lebanese strip along the Israeli-Lebanese border unconditionally, there is nothing to stop him. But that would mean overruling his generals, a move — given the floating presence of super-hardliner Ariel Sharon in his cabinet since Sunday — would appear unthinkable.
He has faint hopes of persuading Washington to take a tougher line on Syria. Netanyahu is bringing with him “new information” linking Syria to ‘terrorism’, Israeli Channel Two reported Sunday.
Netanyahu has criticised Damascus for giving refuge to such groups and for supporting Hizbollah guerrillas fighting Israel in south Lebanon.
Nevertheless it is hard to see any ‘Lebanon First’ plan as no more than an attempt to divert Clinton’s attention away the fact that he is opting out of the basic principle underlying the Madrid peace process, defined by United Nations Security Council Resolution 242 of November 1967 — that Israel should vacate the Arab lands it occupied in the June 1967 War in exchange for peace treaties with its Arab neighbours.
— IPS analyst Dilip Hiro is the author of Dictionary of the Middle East, published by Macmillan, London, and St Martin’s Press, New York.