Development & Aid, Europe, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

CHILDREN: European Child Protection Groups Demand State Action

Angeline Oyog

PARIS, Aug 25 1996 (IPS) - Child protection advocates are pressing governments and police authorities to step up the pursuit of child sex offenders and implement legislation criminalising the sexual exploitation of children.

“We expect governments and law enforcement agencies to examine their conscience and commit themselves to applying vigorously legislation against the sexual abuse of children,” said Pierre Compagnon, heading the End Child Prostitution in Asian Tourism (ECPAT) campaign at the International Catholic Bureau for Children.

According to Compagnon, governments and other national and international authorities can show that commitment by adopting and applying the programme of action to be taken up during this month’s World Congress against the Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children in Stockholm, Sweden.

Representatives of governments, U.N. agencies, non-governmental organisations and law enforcement agencies are expected at Stockholm from Tuesday to draw up strategies to combat criminals who victimise more than a million of the world’s children.

According to the U.N. Fund for Children, UNICEF, co-organiser of the Congress, the globalisation and the clandestine nature of child pornography have made the work of legislators and police forces particularly difficult.

The lack of complementarity among the laws of different countries has added to the complexities in the criminal pursuit of child sex offenders.

Compagnon expects the discussions in Stockholm to focus on laws of extra-territoriality that have been adopted by some countries in the North to allow these governments to try and to condemn their own nationals for crimes committed in other countries.

Although some developing countries have tightened up their legislation against child sexual abuse, some quarters believe that the foreign sex criminals should be tried in their own countries where they are likely to be meted more severe sentences, said Compagnon.

Some sex offenders have been caught and convicted in developing countries, said Compagnon, but because of the laxity or corruption of the local authorities, were released and found their way back to their countries as free men.

“A criminal can’t be judged twice for the same offense. So once back home, he’s free. We would thus prefer that the criminals be sent quickly home where they would be tried more strictly,” said Compagnon.

Moreover, some countries show “some reticence” in pursuing child sex offenders as local government or police authorities could be implicated in the trade and trafficking, said Compagnon.

In a recent issue of their newsletter, ECPAT in Thailand said that finally, German Karl-Heinz Nierenz went too far. Last March, he was given a cumulative prison sentence of up to 40 years and 4 months for various cases of sexual abuse against children.

Nierenz, said ECPAT, was a frequent visitor to Asia and a habitual child sex abuser. He was caught in the Philippines but upon his release, boasted of having given the police 2000 pesos (some 100 dollars) in order not to be bothered again. Then he re- surfaced in Thailand, caught again and expelled to Germany.

Just how much more strictly paedophiles would be punished or monitored could be asked. In Belgium, the citizens rained curses on their Justice ministry officials after learning that Mark Dutroux, accused for abduction, murder and trafficking of children, had been released for good behavior after three years of detention.

Germany, France, Australia, the United States, Belgium, New Zealand, Sweden, Norway, Denmark, Finland, Iceland and Switzerland have adopted laws of extra-territoriality. Ireland and Italy are expected to follow, and child protection advocates welcome the decision of Great Britain to introduce such laws as a high number of foreign “child sex tourists” are British nationals.

A consultative meeting in Bangkok earlier this year in which law enforcement officials, lawyers, child protection agencies from 17 countries, representatives of the European Union and Interpol, recommended that States accord primary emphasis to the prosecution of child sex criminals by the country where the crime took place.

But it also recommends that all states promulgate extra- territorial legislation providing for the prosecution of nationals who commit sexual crimes against children outside of state boundaries.

According to Compagnon, another problem that could be raised in Stockholm could be the definition of punishable crimes. “In France, for instance, the production and the commerce of pornographic materials involving children is prohibited, but not the possession.”

Groups in France hoping to make the possession of pornographic materials involving children a crime, said Compagnon, meet up with obstacles from other groups who decry the breach of personal liberties.

UNICEF concedes that for still a long time to come, numerous questions concerning the protection of civil liberties and the respect of privacy will continue to haunt legislators and jurists.

Ron Grady, international coordinator of the ECPAT campaign, said that the age of the Internet and rapid technological advances has brought the debate sharply into focus.

“At what moment was the crime committed? Who is the criminal: the one who made the pornographic material available on Internet or the one who spreads it? Or is he the one who downloads the material onto his own computer?”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags