Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

PALESTINE: Anger Still Lingers Over Deaths In Custody

Deborah Horan

NABLUS, West Bank, Aug 21 1996 (IPS) - An elderly Palestinian recently summed up the popular feelings surrounding the recent death by torture of a young man at the hands of the Palestinian security forces.

“There should be a system of justice to punish those who are really involved,” he said. As people gathered around the old man to listen, his next sentence was telling: “But there isn’t,” he said. “We’re still far from being like other Arab countries.”

The death of Mahmoud Jumayal three weeks ago is still an open sore here in Nablus. While three members of the Palestinian Coastal Security force deemed responsible for his death were summarily tried and convicted two weeks ago, the family of Jumayal remains convinced that those convicted are not the ones ultimately responsible for their son’s death.

The Palestinian Legislative Council opened an investigation into the death, but sources here predict they will not be able to get to the truth. “The security forces would have to talk,” said Khalil Shkaki, director of the Centre for Palestine Research and Studies, a Nablus-based think tank. “And they are not going to.”

Pictures published in the local press showed Jumayal, 26, lying on a hospital bed in a cloth wrap with marks from cigarette burns and hot irons visible on his arms, legs, chest and stomach. Officially he died of a brain haemorrhage.

His murder sparked two days of violent demonstrations in Nablus and Tulkarem. But more than the death itself — already the seventh during interrogation since the Palestinian security forces arrived two years ago — the way it has been handled is sending a signal to Palestinians about how president Yasser Arafat plans to rule.

Since his arrival in Gaza, Arafat has spent his time moulding a constituency of loyalists that represent the various niches in Palestinian society, say Palestinian observers here. In Gaza, that meant crafting a balance between ‘insiders’, Palestinians living in Gaza, and ‘outsiders’, those who returned with Arafat from other Arab countries when the pact with Israel was signed.

In Nablus, traditionally the economic backbone of the West Bank with strong business and family ties to Jordan, it meant that Arafat had to court wealthy business class as well as the working class who ‘foot soldiers’ of the intifada, the revolt against Israeli occupation.

“Arafat wanted support from the big money class,” said Shkaki. “He also wanted to reward those who had sacrificed most fighting the intifada — but without giving them too much power.”

In the beginning, Arafat’s efforts proved effective. He succeeded in securing candidates for the January elections for the 88-member Legislative Council that evenly reflected the social forces vying for power. His Fatah list included ‘insiders’, ‘outsiders’, rich and poor, women and intifada fighters.

While all of this jockeying was taking place, Jumayal and two others were arrested, allegedly for being part of a gang that extorted money from local merchants and settled scores between rival clans during a period of lawlessness in the city that preceded Israel’s withdrawal.

The belief on the street was that the three were ‘enforcers’, acting on behalf of the mayor of Nablus, Ghassan Shaka’a — a claim he denies. A member of the Palestine Liberation Organisation and a long-time Arafat confidante, Shaka’a was on the official Fatah list of candidates for the council and is from one of the wealthiest families in Nablus.

But Palestinian sources say that the men who seized the three were grabbed by a rival group, known here as the ‘Tabouk gang’ — named after their leader, Ahmed Tabouk. Tabouk’s men had wanted to settle a score with Jumayal, and lobbied Arafat to have him and the two others arrested.

From the time he was arrested, Jumayal was held in a Jericho jail controlled by the Palestinian secret police. The other two were put in Nablus prisons where they are still being held.

Then three weeks ago, for reasons unknown, Jumayal was transferred to the Coastal Security prison in Nablus. The day after his transfer, someone spotted Jumayal in a hospital in Ramallah and told one of his brothers. The family found him listed under an assumed name. Three days later he died.

When council members conducting the investigation summoned the head of the Coastal Security, known as ‘Abu Zaki’, to answer questions, he refused. The Council lacks the power of subpoena. Council members have similarly been denied access to the three men convicted of torturing Jumayal to death.

Council members say they are coming under pressure from Arafat not to fan the flames. One Council member who initially called Jumayal’s death an ‘organised crime’ has since backed down. And the Council’s investigation committee has come under pressure to combine their committee with one set up by Arafat.

“Arafat wants loyalty,” explained Shkaki. “He is not interested in opening up any Pandora’s box that might hurt his loyalists.”

There is no evidence to prove Shaka’a’s involvement and for his part, he denies any involvement with Jumayal. Instead he says that he had warned both him and Tabouk to “stop terrorising local merchants” before Arafat’s arrival, although he does admit to having a “close relationship” with Abu Zaki.

As a Council member (he won a seat in the January elections), he would have to be stripped of his parliamentary immunity before an investigation of his alleged involvement could begin.

One Palestinian community leader, speaking on condition of anonymity, explained what he says most Palestinians think: “Those three became expendable. No one expects any of them to come out of prison alive.”

But the issue of individual guilt or innocence has become largely secondary to many Palestinians.

They want to see a real investigation and a Council with power to curb the excesses of the security forces. “This incident is alienating the public a great deal,” said Shkaki. “Arafat wants security and stability and the public is paying the price.”

Most of all, said Shkaki, Palestinians want to see the delicate balance of forces stay intact. But the view is growing here that the moneyed class and the ‘outsiders’ — Abu Zaki is an ‘outsider’ who returned to Gaza with Arafat — appear to be more important than the street veterans of the intifada.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags