Environment, Europe, Headlines

CZECH REPUBLIC: Disarmament Row Distracts From Environmental Issues

Josef Vesely

PRAGUE, Sep 18 1996 (IPS) - Environmental groups warn that the current focus on the weapons issue in the widespread debate over the Czech Republic’s draft law on nuclear policy distracts attention from other concerns, notably the much-criticised Temelin nuclear plant.

The draft ‘Law on the Peaceful Uses of Nuclear Energy and Atomic Radiation’ is designed to regulate use of nuclear energy, nuclear waste and assign liability in case of an accident — but the main focus of the discussion so far has been on the issue of weapons.

Petr Moravek, deputy head of the Social Democrats, largest opposition party in the parliament, says they will not support any law “which makes possible the expansion of nuclear weapons in Czech territory”. If the country joins NATO they will campaign for a Czech Republic free of nuclear weapons.

But environmentalists and anti-nuclear power groups say the whole discussion on the stationing of nuclear weapons sidelines the core issues raised by the draft law — on the exploitation and efficient use of nuclear energy.

“Of course we support the original version of the law with an absolute ban (on nuclear weapons),” said Daniel Vondrous of the environmental group Hnuti DUHA (Rainbow Movement), an independent civic and environmental group. “But we are concerned that the present discussion subverts the attention from all other problems that appear in the law.”

They claim the law has the aim of clearing the way to the completion of the controversial nuclear power plant in Temelin. Prime minister Vaclav Klaus himself concluded as much, saying that the new draft contains “an external, but an equally important local political aspect”.

The law contains clauses on the efficient use of nuclear energy, managing of nuclear waste, the protection of humans and the environment in case of radioactive leak as well as the measures that could and should be taken to solve the waste issue on a short- and long-term basis.

Such regulations do not exist in the country at present, and the government has come under pressure from international and other foreign institutions to bring them in. Western governments, including the United States, which are ready to grant the country the needed credits to complete Temelin, have demanded a law regulating the whole scope of nuclear energy.

The two 1,000 megawatt Soviet designed VVER-1000 type reactors at the Temelin plant is being retrofitted and completed by the U.S. power giant Westinghouse with funding from the U.S. Export-Import Bank, but is now expected to end up at least 10 percent over its initial 2.4 billion dollar budget.

The first reactor which should have started up in September 1996 but the government recently acknowledged that the plant will not be operational until well into 1997.

In a joint paper by Hnuti DUHA and four other green groups including the Czech branch of Greenpeace, the environmentalists argue that the law offers insufficient opportunities for the public to participate in the process of approval for new nuclear plants.

They also complain there are defects in the way the draft law seeks to deal with nuclear waste and damages to be paid in the case of an accident.

The first draft, submitted to parliament by Klaus’ former government early this year, gave a categorical ‘no’ to the manufacture and possession of nuclear weapons on Czech territory.

Critics claimed such a ban on the import, export and transport of nuclear weapons would pose a serious hurdle to the country’s wish to join the western military alliance, the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO), which does not want to exclude the theoretical possibility of stationing nuclear weapons in a future expanded Central And Eastern European membership region.

“One cannot be excited about the notion of having nuclear weapons in the country,” commented the daily Mlada Fronta Dnes, adding, “but if the (European) continent develops in such a bad way that it becomes vital to station nuclear weapons, then we would be happy if they can protect us.”

After general elections last May and June a new draft added a new paragraph allowing ‘exceptions’ to the prohibition clause. Exceptions are allowed, it said, when such stationing is obliging under international agreements which the country has signed.

The environmentalists claim it was the strategy of the government to include the clause on exceptions to the no-nuke clause as the officials expected such a clause, and not the other issues, to dominate the discussion.

But the government strategy might backfire in parliament.

Klaus’ government is dependent on the parliamentary opposition to get the draft law adopted. His centre right coalition possesses only 99 of the house’s 200 seats, and thus needs the support of at least part of the opposition.

The communists and the Republicans support the use of nuclear energy but could rally the representation needed to block the bill as they are against the stationing of nuclear weapons in the republic.

Another party, the Democratic Left, has decided to start a petition campaign with the aim of ensuring a constitutional clause that makes the Czech Republic nuclear weapons-free forever.

“The whole government and I are convinced that we have chosen a correct formulation which contains all that is necessary,” said Klaus, when he presented the new draft.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags