Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

TURKEY-HUMAN RIGHTS: Conscientious Objector On Hunger Strike

Nadire Mater

ISTANBUL, Nov 5 1996 (IPS) - Nationwide opposition to compulsory military service and the use of army courts to try conscientious objectors in Turkey has found a focus in the case of Osman Murat Ulke, in the third week of a hunger strike in Ankara’s Mamak military jail.

Now one of Turkey’s best known conscientious objectors, Ulke Tuesday marked the 19th day of his hunger strike in Mamak, where he awaits trial on the charge of ‘alienating the public from the military’ — more than a year after he publicly declared his conscientious objection to military service before a military court.

“We are launching a two pronged drive,” says Yavuz Atan of the Izmir War Resisters’ Association (ISKD), a group coordinating a national protest against the draft in Turkey. Turkey is presently locked in a savage counter-insurgency war with Kurdish guerrillas in the country’s disputed south east.

“On one front we are fighting against compulsory military service, on another to abolish the military judiciary,” he says. “The campaign is aimed at forcing the Turkish government to adjust its legislation to bring it into line with the terms of international agreements already signed by Ankara.”

Nicknamed ‘Ossi’ by his companions, Ulke was arrested on the direct orders of the army chief of staff’s military prosecutor. From the western city of Izmir, Ulke publicly refused his military call-up in September 1995.

ISKD officials attribute the delay in prosecution to the army’s reluctance to see conscientious objection become a public issue. The conflict in the south east and major political changes in Turkey has already focused critical attention on the role of the military and the way it operates.

Ulke, who is scheduled to appear before a military court on Nov. 19, began his strike in protest at being ordered to wear military jail uniform while in detention.

Atan says the use of the separate military judicial system to try civilians breaks international agreements. “Turkey should abandon the practice of trying civilians in military courts and suspend laws allowing civilians to be punished by them,” he told IPS, warning that further clampdowns on conscientious objectors could trigger an national campaign of ‘civil disobedience’.

The deeply unpopular conflict in the south east has led to widespread desertion and evasion of national service — ISKD officials claim that there could be as many as 250,000 Turkish citizens on the run from military duty.

“The government could arrest at some of this huge mass of deserters but they are afraid of provoking mass disturbance,” he believes. He said that he and other objectors remain living at home, at officially registered residences. “But they do not call.”

Atan concedes the complexity of the issue in Turkey, where the military tradition of national service runs deep as an expression both of patriotism and manhood. Even he makes a distinction between deserters fleeing the south east battles out of fear and what he says is his group’s principled stand against an iniquitous system.

“We are not concealing our intentions. We publicly declare that we refuse military service. A simple deserter deserts from fear of death at the war front, while concealing this fact to prevent clash with popular values, based on identification of military spirit with manhood.”

The Istanbul branch chairman of the War Resisters Movement, Arif Hikmet Iyidogan was jailed for six months in 1995 alongside branch officials Gokhan Demirkiran and Mehmet Sefa Fersal, jailed for shorter terms. The Istanbul group was banned.

Ulke, who had not yet been called up, was also charged alongside the others but acquitted. However when asked if he would refuse service if asked, he said yes, whereupon the judge immediately ordered him to report for duty. Ulke refused and publicly burnt his draft orders.

Ulke’s lawyer Suna Coskun says his health is worsening and the war resisters have formed a solidarity committee to raise public support for his cause. The campaign has already gained support from the human rights group Amnesty International, which has put him on their ‘urgent action’ list.

All over Europe states are reconsidering the value of national service as even army commanders campaign for professionally trained and paid volunteer forces — a prerequisite for many east European states seeking to join Turkey in the NATO western alliance.

The British and U.S. model of a ‘professional’ army has many champions among the international military, which since the end of the Cold War has made extensive efforts to cooperate and exchange experience. Joint peacekeeping operations, notably in Bosnia- Hercegovina, have boosted the idea.

Several countries, notably Russia and Greece, have been singled out by international human rights monitors for their treatment of conscientious objectors.

In October the European Parliament criticised Greece in its annual human rights report as the only European Union member that does not offer community service as an alternative, and which routinely sends conscientious objectors to jail. Some 400 Greeks, mostly Jehovah’s Witnesses, are serving four-year prison terms for draft evasion.

And although Russian president Boris Yeltsin has signed a decree aiming to phase out conscription by the year 2000, conscientious objectors are still put on trial. In October draftee Alexander Seryogin was given a two year suspended sentence after he requested alternative civilian service when called up in the spring.

The Russian parliament is currently considering a new law to allow just such alternatives. Some former communist countries like Romania already allow two years community service for young men who do not wish to serve a year in the armed forces.

Change is under way even in countries like France, Germany and Holland, where across-the-board military service for all has long been seen as a way of ‘democratising’ the armed forces.

France decided in May it would phase out conscription from 1997, replacing it with voluntary service open to both sexes, part of President Jacques Chirac’s plan to shift to a professional army by 2002 based around rapid-deployment military task forces. Holland ended its annual draft after 187 years last August.

In Germany the number of conscripts refusing military service has increased rapidly. In 1995 a record 160,000 young Germans chose civilian service, compared with 128,000 in 1994. Bonn says it will stick by the tradition. In Germany young draftees on community service are seen as a vital, and cheap, community work force.

Turks hope that the debate on the advantages and disadvantages of military service will get an airing soon. “It’s wonderful,” says Istanbul waiter Mehmet Tas, commenting on the Ulke case. “if I were him I would also not go for military service.”

Tas finished his service five years ago. “I wasted two years in a barracks, my cousin has got sick during the fighting the mountains and later died. But he never received any aid from the state.

“If this war (against the Kurds) is so necessary, why is it that the sons of the rich and privileged are not fighting?” he asks.

“Only the poor like us sent there to fight. I am with ‘Ossi’, but unfortunately not many young men are in a position to follow his example.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags