Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Sergei Strokan
- Even setting Chechnya aside, Russia’s human rights record was unimproved in 1996 despite its accension to the Concil of Europe and the end of war in the breakawy republic according to Human Rights Watch/Helsinki annual report.
“The Russian Federation’s human rights practices did not improve in 1996, despite heightening expectations, stemming from its admission into the Council of Europe and from President Boris Yeltsin’s re-election campaign promises, the report stated.
It lambasted the national leadership, and, in particular capital Moscow authorities for human rights abuses and for stirring xenophobia.”Added together, not even the end of the war in Chechnya with all death and destruction it involved could brighten the state’s general record.
“If you set Chechnya aside, human rights stayed on the same level and in some cases worsened,” Alexander Petrov, Moscow representative of the US-based Human Rights Watch/Helsinki told journalists.
Much of the report dwelt on the first six months of the year, during which the war in Checvhnya raged on. It chronicles an all familiar catalogue of beatings, killings and rape, some of which it claimed were sanctioned by the federal authorities.
The release of the report coincided with Russia’s national holiday, Constitution Day, Dec. 12, which honour the three year- old Russian constitution. But while Russians welcomed the day-off, IPS survey, conducted on the streets of Moscow, revealed few of the citizens are familiar or aware of either the rights the document guarantees them or the demands it makes of them.
Sergei Yablokov, 28, a scruffy-looking man loitering on Zagorodny prospect, a suburban Moscow street, was taken aback when asked if he was familiar with Article 58 of the Constitution, which says that citizens are required “to preserve nature” and treat the environment with “respect”.
“I am required to do this? Well, then, so be it,” he said, spitting on the street and flicking his cigatette butt into the gutter.
The Russian constitution was adopted in a 1993 referendum, which political opposition, including Communist Party leader Gennady Zyuganov had labelled as “grand falsifcation”, accusing Kremlin of padding 9 million votes. Ordinary Russians regard it as a rambling list of rights, many of which are de-facto ignored today.
“When would I have had time to read that?” said Svetlana Gromova, who was rushing into Pushkinskaya metro station. “Two holidays – Thursday and Friday are not bad, but isn’t it just a bunch of damned laws anyway?”.
Among the guarantees to be found in the 137 articles of the Constitution are the right to free medical care and housing, as well as a right to trial by jury, a presumption of innnocence, a right to consult a lawyer withing 24 hours of arrest and to refuse to answer questions that may be self-incriminating.
The Constitution also guarantees immunity from illegal searches, the freedom of movement and promises an alternative to military service. However, few amnog the citizenry and far from all in authority are familiar with the list.
“Ironically, the most versed in the constution are hard-core organized criminals and mobsters – in short, people who often deal with the police and they are well-protected because of it,” Boris Volzhkin, Research Fellow with the Institute for Improving the Work of Prosecutors and Police Investigations told IPS.
Across Moscow at a local office of OVIR, the Soviet-era office of residence permit registration, a spokesman snorted at the idea of Article 27, which guarantees citizens freedom “to freely move about and chose one’s place of dwelling”, as well as “to leave and enter Russia unhindered”.
“As if the governmnet cannot tell you where to live or not to live – please”, said Valery Sergeyev, annoyed spokesman for the North-West District OVIR. “Of course, it is the government’s right.”In the USSR the system of residence permits, the notorious “propiska”, kept a far tighter hold on movements within the country’s borders.
But while in some parts of Russia it has been abolished, Moscow and St. Petersburg authorities still require residency permits – a rulethat is often ignored but nevertheles available for police to enforce selectively.
Human Rights Watch/Helsinki’s report paid close attention to now unconstitutional sysem of “propiska” registration that is still in practice in major Russian cities. According to human rights activists, “propiska” not only restricts freedom of movement but is also used by the police for unlawful detention, raids and deportation.
Moscow Mayor Yuri Luzhkov was singled out for attacks on this score, due to decrees ordering police to clean up the city, with most of those “cleaned” out being from the North Caucaus.
Activists also focused on the plight of Russia’s millions of refugees, who have fled the hot spots of the former Soviet Union — such as Chechnya, Tajikistan, and the Transcaucaus — and now are effectively without any rights whatsoever.
The new constitution guarantees a trial by jury, but this is also seldom observed, according to Larisa Bogoraz, an expert on Russian judicial reform with Human Rights Watch/Helsinki. Bogoraz said Soviet courtroooms were built without seating or other accomodations for a jury, and that money for running the country’s courts – much less renvating them – was short.
“Courtrooms can’t just be revamped to accomodate jurors at this time. I doubt we will see the application of this article for many years to come,” she said. As a result, Bogoraz said, almost all criminal trials that have been held since 1993 didn’t have jurors present and could conceivably be struck down as unconstitutional, resulting in a massive cleaning of prisons.
“And not necessarily all those who would be freed are innocent”, she said. One right that all ctizens are aware of, however, is the right to vote.
“People have had plenty of practice voting lately, and that is certainly a provision of the new constitution people are taking advantage of”, says Andrei Piontkovsky of the Center for Strategic Studies in Moscow.
“This means people are becoming acclimated to the idea that they can have some effect on the workings of government. Perhaps, somewhere along the way they will read the consitution, too”.
According to Piontkovsky, the root cause of the lack of radical improvements probably lies in the fact that human rights issues come rather far down on the list of concerns for Russian voters, more than half of whom live a hand-to-mouth existence.
Another aspect emphasized by Human Rights Watch activists is international community’s reluctance to pressure the Russian governmnet into trying harder.
Helsinki Watch berated the European Union for admitting Russia to the Council of Europe, an organization based on respect for human rights, even as the war in Chevchnya was still underway. A special place in the report was set aside for criticism of Russia’s failure to impose a moratorium on the death penalty, despite commitments made when joining the Council.
Russia’s newly adopted criminal code, which is to become active Jan.1, lists seven capital offenses, while there is been no slowing of execution rates.
“By joining the Council of Europe, Russia has said that it wants to sign on to the values held as universal in Europe. There is every reason to help and cajole the authorities to realize that desire, regardless of how incvonvenient some of those values may be,” Andrei Bystritsky, Social problems Editor with “Itogi” newsmagazine told IPS.