Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Jorge Pina
- Italy’s Parliament will debate a controversial new law to make the justice system more agile, but which could also let those responsible for political corruption off the hook.
The nation’s justice system has ground to a virtual halt with cases taking an average of four and a half years to resolve, but the critics say the aim of the centre-left government is really to give a helping hand to the 5,000 people on trial for “Tangentopolis’.’
“Tangentopolis” (the city of bribes) was the name given to a well-established system of political corruption discovered by the immense “Clean Hands” investigation in 1992, under the control of then Public Prosecutor Antonio Di Pietro.
This investigation destroyed the ruling class which had dominated Italian government since the second world war, leading directly to immense ructions in the Christian Democratic and Socialist parties – the two groups who had practically taken turns in government during this long period.
Meanwhile, the government swears the aim is not to help the corrupt to slip off the hook even though they could take advantage of the move if it becomes law.
But the progress of the parliamentary debate is expected to be slow – at least a year – and full of potholes, even though the Council of Ministers gave it the initial go ahead last weekend.
In speech at the opening of this year’s sessions in the Supreme Court last Friday, the leader of this body, Ferdinando Zucconi Galli Fonseca said sentences passed in 1996 only covered 0.03 percent of the cases pending.
The new initiative plans to cut the judicial process by allowign for agreement on the sentence between the judges and the accused, who will receive a shorter sentence for taking this option.
Under this system, if the accused accepts to forgo the long processes, overcoming the most difficult terrain of the law, they could benefit from large discounts whereby a 12-year sentence could be reduced to barely two and a half.
The project will be applied to a wide spread of crimes, and not only those related to “Tangentopolis,” like corruption and extortion, but also robbery, usuary, burglary, money laundering, the revealing of State secrets and perjury.
The crimes not covered include, murder, terrorist attempts, mafia association, kidnapping, drug trafficking and sexual violence.
According to the initiative, the accused will not even have to confess to the crimes, as it will be sufficient for the judge to consider the conditions are right to agree a sentence on the basis of proof in the possession of the public prosecutor.
If, on the contrary, the judge considers these elements are insufficient, the accused may decide to confess in order to provide the decisive element in the sentence.
The agreement will assure a reduction of at least a third of the sentence to the accused, but as the bill plans four possible reductions – whereby a 12 year sentence could be reduced to two and a half.
The shortened process will be applied to all crimes, including those deserving a life sentence. If the accused requests this of the judge, and if the petition is accepted, the maximum sentence becomes reduced to 30 years.
Gerardo D’Ambrosio, coordinator of the “Clean Hands” operation, said he did not approve of the initiative because it will “help the corrupt people of Tangentopolis.”
He said the bill appear to be a specially made to measure suit for these criminals, as it does not even require a confession as the basis for a shorter sentence.
The initiative will provide the defendents with a free lightening of the sentence, ranging from a third of the sentence to a complete pardon.
D’Ambrosio also criticised the reduction of the sentences as “an offence to public interest” as it “generates discrimination between those who have the money to do it and the poor devil who cannot get the discount.”
For instance, he said, someone who robbed millions of dollars and put them in foreign bank accounts will get a reduced sentence after spending a little of this money – something which “appears to have been tailor made for those charged under Tangentopolis.
President of the Association of Penal Lawyers, Gaetano Pecorella, also lodged his opposition to the project as, he said, “it defines a type of penal justice where the quest for truth by proof will no longer exist.”
Up until now, he added, confession has formed the basic criteria for all trials.
Meanwhile, head of government, Romano Prodi, said the project established indispensible measures to avoid greater risks, like an amnesty or the simple cancellation of the crimes.
The initiative is one “of the most important challenges of my government,” said Prodi.
The “father” of the project, Justice Minister Giovanni Maria Flick, siad the norm under discussion is not aimed at Tangentopolis, but at justice as a whole.
Flick declared himself open to introducing changes in the project in Parliament, but warned the government was not about to make this into a debate on a supposed wiping of the slate for Tangentopolis.