Economy & Trade, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

ARGENTINA-ECONOMY: Profits Up for Privatized Industries

Marcela Valente

BUENOS AIRES, Feb 19 1997 (IPS) - Argentina’s former public companies, privatised during the past five years, were now reaping the highest earnings of all the nation’s business concerns, according to a new study.

Furthermore, the conglomerates that took control of the old state- run industries are earning hefty profits despite any decline in the gross national product (GNP) – as occurred in 1995.

“Argentina’s Business Elite” – a study conducted by economist Daniel Azpiazu – found that of Argentina’s largest 200 companies, which collectively sell 75 billion dollars worth of goods and services, 66 were involved with the privatization process.

Another startling figure was that the 50 most profitable businesses — not including YPF Petroleum which, is the wealthiest firm but is considered a “mixed” company — account for 60 percent of all profits generated.

If YPF’s earnings were included, then the percentage of total profits attributable to this small group of companies would be 80 percent.

Azpiazu told IPS that “Argentina’s privatization process has accelerated and deepened the ongoing process of economic concentration”.

The auction of publicly-held companies required that any bidding company be able to demonstrate a very high minimum level of net worth, an entrance requirement that only very large national conglomerates could meet. In many cases, these “national” companies were local associates of foreign companies.

In exchange for purchasing these formerly public companies, the State transferred to the private sector captive markets, a guaranteed profit base, the power to set prices and fees at their own discretion, and even regulatory capability.

Azpiazu warned that “we now have a situation in which the Government of Argentina is increasingly weakened in its relationship with private economic groups.”

During Carlos Menem’s first term (1990 – 1995), almost all public industries passed into private hands, or into the managerial domain of public companies based in other countries. Water, telephone services, gas, electricity, toll roads and coastal shipping were all converted into private monopolies.

The new map of Argentina’s business sector showed that during this period, the contribution to sales made by state companies fell from 33.6 percent of total national sales to 2.7 percent. Simultaneously, the commercial and service sectors of the economy increased their percentage of total national income relative to the industrial sector.

This phenomenon corresponded to the protection and privilege enjoyed by public service companies relative to those companies that must submit themselves to the price and quality competition of the external marketplace. Most of these latter businesses focus their activity on factories which produce industrial goods.

Offsetting these profitable changes in the Argentine marketplace, howeverm, is a worryng growth in unemployment. Between 1990 and 1995, unemployment rose from 6.4 percent to 18.6 percent. In 1996 the rate backed off slightly to 17.4 percent, although official estimates of employment trends indicates any further decline in unemployment will be very slow.

It may seem paradoxical but privatization and economic “opening” have contributed to greater concentration of wealth and further consolidation by monopolies. “The same companies that produce goods and services for the internal Argentine market are those that import the most; above all in the food and drink sector,” Azpiazu noted.

By way of example, Azpiazu’s study revealed that 90 percent of imported dairy products are ordered by local producers. This concentration hurts the consumer, but it also brings about an additional consequence – the increasingly unequal distribution of wealth.

According to the National Institute of Statistics and the Census, the last six years have seen the gap between Argentina’s rich and poor widen by 50 percent, a redistribution of wealth that aligns Argentina with other South American countries, whereas traditionally Argentina stood out as a country with relatively equal income distribution.

Statistics reveal that, even when one takes into account price stability – finally secured in 1991 following two earlier bursts of hyperinflation – along with the growth of the Argentine economy at an annual rate of seven percent, the distribution of wealth is increasingly unequal.

Azpiazu pointed out that the inequitable division of income becomes more acute with the concentration of capital. “If the gross national product falls at the same time big business increases its share of earnings, it is only because some social sector is getting a smaller slice of the pie.”

As an example, the economist highlights 1995 as the year when Argentina suffered the effects of the Mexican financial crisis, impacting Argentina’s gross national product with a decline of 4 percent. Nevertheless, in 1995, the 200 largest Argentine companies increased their billing by 11 percent over 1994.

If one looks at cumulative Argentine profits for 1995 – the year in which Argentina experienced its most recent recession – the 200 largest companies earned 30 percent more than they had the previous year.

The so-called “tequila effect” also revealed the ongoing process of wealth concentration in the financial sector. The total number of banking companies in Argentina went from 205 to 108, a process of concentration in which the largest financial concerns survived. These surviving few can now take over the marketplace with less competition.

Even in the countryside, the concentration of wealth is seen in the replacement of traditional landholding families with large business conglomerates, a process that has been accompanied by an unprecedented phenomenon: foreign investment.

Italian citizen Luciano Bennetton, and Hungarian George Soros, are now Argentina’s two largest landholders and economists agree that the difference between national and transnational economic activity is less and less important considering the noxious effects of capital concentration whatever flag is being flown.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags