Tuesday, November 17, 2026
David Rocks
- Slovaks are voting this weekend on NATO membership, but with their country apparently already excluded from the alliance, what’s really at stake is far more important: Slovakia’s future in Europe.
And even before the first ballots were cast Friday, it looked as if the country had once again managed to tarnish its image.
Although the referendum Friday and Saturday asked voters whether their country should join the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, many Western governments have indicated Slovakia will not be part of the first group of new members in the alliance.
After more than two years of instability, intrigues and political infighting — culminating this week in conflicts that have compromised the validity of the referendum — Slovakia has been dropped from nearly everybody’s short-list for early entry into the western defence alliance.
Many in the country, however, had hoped the referendum would send a clear message to Western European capitals that Slovaks want to continue integration into the European Union and other pan- European organisations.
“It will be a signal to all of Europe,” Slovak president Michal Kovac said in an interview with IPS. “Whether or not Slovakia is invited (to join the alliance, the referendum) has a great significance because these countries will realise that the citizens of Slovakia are interested in joining NATO.”
But whatever results are announced on Sunday, a strong signal has already been sent: Even if Slovaks vote in large numbers for membership in NATO, their country isn’t ready either for the alliance or other European institutions.
The vote is emblematic of much of life in Slovakia, where things are never quite what they appear to be. The referendum, for example, officially has four questions, but the ballots have only three.
The first question concerns NATO membership, while the next two ask whether nuclear weapons or foreign troops may be stationed in Slovakia if the country joins the alliance. The fourth question would change the Constitution to allow direct election of the president. Currently the president is chosen by a vote of parliament.
The validity of the final question was challenged by the ruling coalition, which maintained that the Constitution cannot be amended by a referendum.
The Constitutional Court ruled that the claim was unfounded, but that for procedural reasons the fourth question would have to be a non-binding recommendation to the parliament rather than an amendment.
The Central Referendum Commission then ordered ballots with all four questions to be issued, but the interior minister distributed ballots with only the three NATO questions. Opposition members and most other observers now say that the referendum is invalid and will only serve as a further black mark against Slovakia.
“The signal we are sending at the moment is quite the opposite of what we had hoped for,” sighed Frantisek Sebej, vice president of the opposition Democratic Party. “It’s a sign of political chaos and of absolute disrespect for the law and the Constitution.”
Such fight-to-the-finish politics have been Slovakia’s hallmark since Czechoslovakia split four years ago, and it is just that style that has soured the West’s opinion of the new country.
Although Slovakia has a free press, free speech and — until this weekend, at least — free elections, Prime minister Vladimir Meciar has sought an ever greater share of political power.
Meciar’s government has placed its partisans in control of public media and purged opponents from all levels of the state apparatus; it has passed a series of laws that could be used to hinder the activities of non-governmental organisations and limit academic freedom in universities; and opposition participation in oversight of the secret police has been virtually eliminated.
“We’ve been concerned about the concentration of power, and that Meciar appears to want to maintain that power at any cost,” said a European diplomat stationed in Bratislava. “And there really is concern about the rule of law in the country.”
Much of the Western discomfort stems from the turbulent relationship between Meciar and president Kovac. The two were once allies, and Kovac would never have been elected president without Meciar’s support. After his election, however, Kovac began to oppose his mentor, finally urging Meciar’s removal from office — which the parliament did in March, 1994.
Later that year, though, Meciar’s party won a plurality in new elections and he was named prime minister again. Since then, Meciar has called for his former protege to be unseated by whatever means possible, although his coalition lacks the three- fifths majority in parliament required to do so constitutionally.
The importance of the fourth referendum question this weekend is that the opposition fears a stalemate when Kovac’s term ends next spring. If no candidate is able to win the three-fifths parliamentary majority needed to be elected president — a near- certainty since neither the opposition nor the government has enough votes — most presidential powers would fall to Meciar.
“After the experience of recent years, we need a president who is independent of the parliament, the government,” said Miroslav Kusy, former rector of Comenius University and a specialist in human rights issues. “For Meciar, the main aim is pure political power.”
There are also serious questions about the rule of law in Slovakia. The highest-profile case involves the kidnapping two years ago of Michal Kovac Jr., the president’s son.
In August 1995, the younger Kovac was seized near his home in Bratislava, forced to drink several pints of whiskey, locked in the trunk of his car, driven across the border into neighbouring Austria and left in front of a police station.
An anonymous caller alerted Austrian police to Kovac Jr.’s whereabouts, and he was taken into custody due to an outstanding warrant seeking him for questioning in a fraud case in Germany.
Within days, two Slovak investigators reported evidence pointing to secret police involvement in the affair, but each was in turn taken off of the case. Since a third investigator was appointed the probe has languished for what police now call a lack of evidence.
Last year, a key witness in the case was killed in a car-bomb attack, a crime that police originally refused to investigate, saying that the car had exploded spontaneously.
“They fired two investigators who had indications and preliminary evidence showing that the kidnapping had a political background and that the Slovak secret service was involved,” Kovac said. “It’s more indirect evidence of unauthorised interference by government officials into an investigation that should have proceeded independently.”
Members of the governing coalition, meanwhile, say Slovakia is judged too harshly by the West. If the country were measured by the same yardstick as other countries in the region, they say, Slovakia would still be in the first group of candidates for NATO membership.
The country is a member of numerous international organisations, has participated in NATO-led Partnership for Peace military exercises, and has an economy that is among the region’s strongest.
And if the political scene appears more turbulent than in neighbouring countries, they say, that’s only because of Slovakia’s unique style and not due to any real lack of democratic institutions and ideals.
“I don’t say everything is perfect, but I think we are a normal country in transformation,” said Jozef Sestak, state secretary in Slovakia’s ministry of foreign affairs.
“If we have debates that are more visible outside, they are debates mainly among parliamentarians. That they fight against each other more strongly is a question of maturity of the political scene, of the political culture, but in substance this is a pluralistic democracy.”