Thursday, November 19, 2026
Bijoy Basant Patro
- Fifty years after Indian independence, the government is still only at the stage of promising to make education a fundamental right of children.
Prime Minister Inder Kumar Gujral, in an address to the nation on its 50th Independence anniversary last week, said his government has presented a bill to amend the Constitution in Parliament.
“Unless and untill our future generations go to school, society cannot make further progress,” he said. “My government has already acceded the right to education as a fundamental right … and we have presented the amendment bill in Parliament.”
India is the world’s most illiterate nation, with a third of its 960 million people not able to read or write. One third of the population is under 14. An estimated 110 million children of these children, between six and 14 years, do not go to school.
“Our country will have a bright future only when every child below 14 years will go to school every morning wearing a colourful uniform,” the prime minister said in the speech that was broadcast countrywide on TV and radio.
But educationists are sceptical about the government’s commitment to putting all children in school. India’s ruling coalition government had promised to increase government spending for education to 6 percent when it came to power in June 1996.
While education’s share has risen by 245 million in this year’s budget, the bulk of the 940 million dollars that has been set aside are foreign funds tied to specific projects.
“For universalising education, the state has to devote more funds,” says Professor Arjun Dev, joint director of the government’s National Council For Education Research and Training in New Delhi.
“Non-universalisation of education is not because of any constitutional shortcoming,” he asserts. “I would like to know what programme the government has in mind.”
Prime Minister Gujral said his government would open more schools and raise the standard of education. But in 50 years, India has been able to only double the number of primary schools across the country. Only one in seven primary schools has a teacher in every class: 61 out of a 100 primary schools have two teachers and 29 out of 100 have a single teacher.
According to NCERT’s Dev, “A 1984 country-wide survey showed there were 30,000 habitations without a primary school within a kilometre. Now less than a third of India’s villages have a primary school.”
As a result, just 25 percent of children, mostly boys, under 14 are going to school. Less than 15 percent of girls in the same age group are allowed to go to school in a society that considers women less than human.
India embarked on an ambitious “Education for All” programme in 1993, after the World Conference on Education in Jomtien, Thailand, in 1990. But the campaign never really took off, because the funds were not forthcoming.
Two years ago, the then prime minister, P.V. Narasimha Rao of the Congress party, launched a mid-day school meal scheme to increase school enrollment, attendance and reduce the drop-out rates at school. An alarming 55 percent of children drop out, either because of economic reasons or because the system of education has failed to satisfy aspirations.
In 1995, a substantial share of the education budget went to pay for the meal scheme, which was widely seen as a politically motivated programme with an eye on the forthcoming general elections.
However, teachers complain the mid-day meal scheme is an additional burden, and even diverts energy from education. “Teachers supervise the cooking. In some schools they have to cook the meals themselves,” said Prem Arya, a primary school teacher in the neighbouring state of Haryana.
Meanwhile, educationists believe programmes like the mid-day meal scheme are just sops, and not enough if India is to achieve its goal of universalising education early in the new millennium.
They point out that the government was meant to universalise secondary education within 10 years of the country’s independence. But successive governments not only failed to keep that promise, but have diluted it.
“The Constitution talked of eight years of “elementary” education,” says Dr Krishna Kumar, one of the country’s best known educationists who teaches in Delhi University. “But the
(present) government talks of five year “primary” education.”
Writing in ‘The Times of India’ daily recently, he says, “No one is discussing elementary education these days, for no one believes that it can be universalised in the forseeable future.”
In his opinion the majority of middle class parents are disillusioned with state schools. And the bulk of farmers and the urban poor see no prospect of education becoming relevant for their children or the teacher showing warmth towards them.
“Bias against village life is so central to modern education and its curriculum that one cannot imagine how the high drop-out rate of rural children can decline without drastic alternations in perspective,” adds Kumar.
With there being no signs of such drastic change, education for all will remain just a catchy slogan.