Thursday, November 19, 2026
Jim Lobe
- One month after Pope John Paul II’s historic visit to Cuba, U.S. policy towards the Caribbean island is moving back into the political spotlight.
For the first time since the introduction of the “Helms- Burton” law, designed to starve Cuba of foreign investment and codify a 35-year-old trade embargo, U.S. efforts to isolate Havana until President Fidel Castro leaves office have come under sustained attck.
“The Pope has shown that it’s possible to go to Cuba and shake Fidel’s hand,… and still do some good,” according to Richard Nuccio, who handled relations between the U.S. administration and the Cuban-American community here from 1993 until the Helms-Burton legislation took effect.
At a forum on America’s Cuba policy, sponsored by the influential Brookings Institution, Nuccio observed that U.S. President Bill Clinton recently complained to aides about parts of the Helms-Burton law. It limited his ability to respond to positive developments in Cuba, such as the release after the pope’s visit of at least 60 political prisoners.
The growing debate over Washington’s policy toward Cuba includes the issue of humanitarian assistance, particularly a bill currently pending in Congress that, if passed, would authorise the sale of food, medicine, and medical equipment to Cuba.
The bill is backed by a range of organisations – from the Roman Catholic Church and other mainstream church groups to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce – and has garnered the support of about 25 percent of Congress. Sponsors include both Republicans and Democrats.
Momentum for action became so strong after the pope’s visit that Sen. Jesse Helms, and the fervently anti-Castro Cuban- American National Foundation (CANF), put forward another bill which, while maintaining the embargo, would permit Clinton to donate food and medical supplies to Cuba via the Catholic Church and American Red Cross.
Although Castro has strongly denounced that initiative as an affront to Cuba’s dignity, the fact that Helms and the CANF felt compelled to offer it marked a major change in the debate here, according to Geoffrey Thale, an analyst at the Washington Office on Latin America (WOLA), a human rights group.
It also provoked a rare split between the CANF and other exile hardliners in Congress, particularly Ileana Ros-Lehtinen and Lincoln Diaz-Balart of Miami. After initially attacking the Helms- CANF bill as a potential first step toward ending the embargo, the two lawmakers later eased their opposition.
The split, according to Nuccio, suggests not only uncertainty among hardliners about how to react to the pope’s repeated calls for an end to the U.S. embargo, but also a “struggle to show who is more “duro” (uncompromising) within the Cuban-American community after the death in December of CANF founder and strongman Jorge Mas Canosa.
Jockeying between hardliners obscures larger changes in the Cuban- American community, according to Nuccio and others. “I think there’s been a tremendous shift in terms of attitude,” says Maria de los Angeles Torres, who teaches political science at De Paul University and has written a book on Cuban exile politics.
“People see Cuba after the pope’s visit as a much broader place than just one person, Fidel Castro, ” she says. “The dominant paradigm has been how best to overthrow him, but the pope’s visit has brought forth another framework: how we can start helping our brothers and sisters on the island.”
She agrees with Nuccio that many second generation Cuban- Americans, particularly Catholics in their 30’s and 40’s, may now be more inclined to challenge the polarised politics of their parents. “The pope’s visit legitimised those voices in the community that have not been in the forefront,” according to Torres.
More than 1,000 Cuban-Americans made the journey to Cuba during the pope’s visit, many for the first time, and observers see them as having a major impact within their community.
“For the people who went for the first time, it transformed them,” says Silvia Wilhelm, director of the Miami-based Cuban Committee for Democracy, who also took the trip. “My sense is that they were deeply touched by the words of the pope, and they feel a responsibility to find a way for reconciliation. I don’t know a single person who doesn’t feel that way.”
She views especially significant, a column published in the Miami Herald by a leading Cuban-American business leader, Carlos Saladrigas, after the papal tour. He told the exile community to undertake “new initiatives” toward Cuba “based on reconciliation, fraternal love, and justice” if it wants to play any constructive role in the island’s future.
The debate is not confined to the Cuban-American community. The fact that the Brookings Institution, the granddaddy of Washington thinktanks, has held two major seminars on Cuba since the pope’s visit is one indication that the issue is warming up. And more Republicans are questioning current policy.
A joint resolution introduced in the House by right-wing California Republican Elton Gallegly earlier this month urged Clinton “to build upon the (pope’s) visit and to support the pope’s message to the Cuban people.” Gallegly, the new chairman of the House’s western hemisphere subcommittee, will hold hearings on Cuba policy for early next month.
At the Brookings forum this week, Roger Fontaine, who directed Latin American affairs for the National Security Council under Ronald Reagan, argued that the Helms-Burton law undermines the chances for a peaceful democratic transition in Cuba. He favours ending the embargo.
The U.S. Catholic Conference, meanwhile, has endorsed the Dodd bill, and also is pressing the administration to lift “the onerous and meaningless ban on direct flights to Cuba.” “When you see cardinals, bishops and priests walking the halls of Congress, they can make a difference,” said veteran Democratic lawmaker Joe Moakley.
For its part, the administration is still holding its counsel. Last week, Secretary of State Madeleine Albright said she wanted to work with both Helms and Dodd on a humanitarian bill but declined to indicate which she preferred. And Washington has yet to offer a substantive reaction to the prisoners’ release.
Nuccio, who now teaches at Harvard University, thinks the current ferment offers a chance for Clinton to reclaim Cuba policy from the strictures of Helms-Burton.
He says the president should deliver a high-level statement on Cuba and convene a blue-ribbon commission to make recommendations for a truly bipartisan policy on Cuba, which is currently lacking – “Presidents lead by speaking.”