Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Mark Lynas
- To the security guard giving evidence at the trial, it was “verbal abuse”. But the imprisoned asylum seekers — waving makeshift banners and banging on the razor wire fence of Campsfield House Immigration Detention Centre near Oxford — were actually shouting “freedom”.
In Britain asylum seekers are only supposed to be deprived of their liberty if immigration officials have good reason to believe that they might abscond. But many are detained immediately and seemingly arbitrarily at the port of entry.
As a result, at any one time several hundred people are detained in British prisons and secure hostels — with no recourse to the legal system and possibly in contravention of the European Convention on Human Rights, which states that all detention decisions must be referred to a judge.
The trial in question illustrates the problems thrown up by an arbitrary policy of detaining asylum seekers. Nine West Africans accused of starting a riot last summer which left Campsfield House nearly in ruins.
Had they been found guilty, they could have spent up to ten years in jail; however the evidence given by the private security guards who run Campsfield was so contradictory that earlier this week the trial judge forced the prosecution to drop the charges.
To asylum rights campaigners, the collapse of the trial was vindicated their stance — that Britain is running an inhumane system. “The case is an illustration of how asylum seekers should not be put in prison and should not be treated like criminals,” said Suke Wolton of the Campsfield Nine Defence Campaign.
Claude Moraes from the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants was also critical of the policy. “This prosecution threw into sharp relief the whole issue of extra-judicial detention — which is both costly and possibly damaging to vulnerable asylum-seekers. The policy requires fundamental review, and our view is that detention powers are necessary but must not be routinely used.”
Nick Hardwick, director of the Refugee Council, which also works to protect the rights of refugees in Britain, echoed this point. “Our concern about the way in which detention is used in the UK is that it is an arbitrary process.
“So people are detained without ever going before a court, without ever being given written reasons. In addition there’s no date set for their release and they are sometimes detained in prisons.”
Hardwick adds that the whole system is in “complete chaos. There is a backlog of 70,000 cases waiting to be heard.”
In addition, many asylum-seekers arrive in Britain already traumatised through suffering torture and persecution in the countries from which they have fled. Yet when they arrive in Britain, many again find themselves leading an aimless existence under lock and key — apparently without any prospect of release.
Several of the nine defendants in the Campsfield trial suffered psychological problems as a result of the case. One — who cannot be named because he is a minor — was ruled unfit to stand trial at the beginning of the case because of his mental condition.
According to campaigners, he was “driven mad” because of harsh treatment before the case. He has attempted suicide on two occasions. A suicide attempt by another defendant was also reported to campaigners a month ago.
One of the defendants — the Nigerian Ogoni rights activist Sunny Ozidede — was picked up and badly tortured by Nigerian military police three times before finally managing to escape the Britain. He claims that he was picked out to be a scapegoat in the riot trial because he is West African.
Dr Evan Harris is a Liberal Democrat Member of Parliament — his constituency includes Campsfield House, and he considers those held there to be his constituents.
“I’ve always criticised detention in this country,” he says. “We detain far too many people for far too long in many cases without giving a written reason for their detention, without giving people an automatic right to a bail hearing and without judicial overview of the decision to detain.”
The British government’s own Chief Inspector of Prisons, David Ramsbotham, highlighted these same problems when he visited Campsfield House earlier this year.
In a strongly worded report he advised that: “Rigorous examination of the need for detention should take place within a few days (of detention)” and that “this country should move towards judicial oversight of immigration detention.”
To its credit, the British government has long since admitted that its system is chaotic and badly in need of reform and says it is coming up with a policy which is “firm, fair and fast”. Ministers are expected to announce proposed changes at the end of July.
Meanwhile Home Office Minister Mike O’Brien emphasises that only 1.5 percent of asylum-seekers are being detained, but said Thursday: “I don’t want to detain anyone but detention is a regrettable necessity.”
One area where the Home Office is in strong disagreement with asylum rights campaigners is on the issue of deterrence. Activists ask: Is Britain treating asylum-seekers badly in order to persuade those thinking of fleeing here to stay put?
“The vast bulk of people are detained to discourage people in other countries from applying for asylum,” says Nick Hardwick. “There’s no question of deterrence,” says a Home Office spokesperson. “We’re not trying to deter genuine asylum- seekers.”
In the meantime the remaining detainees at Campsfield House are stepping up their demand to be given access to the legal system or to be set free.
There is little doubt that as long as immigration detention remains a major plank of British policy, it will only be a matter of time before another major protest breaks out.