Thursday, November 19, 2026
Jim Lobe
- Republican senators urged U.S. President Bill Clinton Thursday to prevent the recently-approved treaty creating an International Criminal Court (ICC) from ever taking effect.
The lawmakers depicted the Court as a major threat to America’s sovreignty and said Washington should penalise other nations that ratifed the treaty. The vote to approve the treaty, after weeks of negotiations in Rome ended last Friday, was 120-7 but it must be ratified by 60 nations before it can take effect.
“This Court truly is a monster, and it is a monster that must be slain,” declared Republican Sen. Rod Grams, who chaired the first Congressional hearing to review the ICC treaty. “The United States must aggressively oppose this Court each step of the way because the treaty establishing (it) is not just bad, it is dangerous.”
U.S. administration officials, meanwhile, re-asserted their opposition to the treaty as written but said Washington would continue working with other countries to amend the treaty to meet U.S. demands.
“We are going to try to correct the flaws before we conclude that they will not be corrected and we need to move into a different mode, such as serious opposition,” State Department spokesman James Rubin told reporters.
Human-rights activists, who lobbied hard for years for the kind of international court envisaged by the new treaty, were not reassured.
Asked if he thought the Clinton administration would pressure other countries not to ratify the treaty, Jerry Fowler, who attended the Rome talks as legislative counsel for the New York- based Lawyers Committee for Human Rights (LCHR), shook his head and said, “I really don’t know. (The administration) played a lot of hardball in Rome, and they can play hardball now.”
“Up to now, there’s been no real disagreement between the administration and Congressional Republicans on the ICC,” said Richard Dicker, who headed the lobbying efforts by Human Rights Watch in Rome. “The real fault line lies between the United States and 120 countries, including America’s closest friends and allies, who voted for the treaty.”
The United States was one of the seven countries, several of which Washington calls “rogue states,” to vote against the ICC treaty July 17. Virtually all of Washington’s traditional European and East Asian allies voted for the treaty, while China, Iraq, Israel, Libya, Qatar and Yemen were the other nations voting against.
With no trace of irony, one witness called to testify to the Foreign Relations Committee Thursday cited the range of dissenters as evidence of the unacceptability of the treaty itself. “The extremity of (ICC supporters’) demands may be judged by the results they achieved, for it takes a rare talent indeed to drive the United States and Israel onto the same ground as China and Libya,” said Washington lawyer Lee Casey.
The witness list itself helped illustrate the temper of the Republican-controlled Senate, two-thirds of which, under the U.S. constitution, must vote to ratify treaties. Of the five witnesses who testified, only one supported the treaty, while several Republican senators offered lengthy statements attacking it.
“The United States must fight this treaty,” declared Committee Chairman Jesse Helms in a written statement. “We must be aggressively opposed to this Court.”
Helms and others objected in particular to the inclusion of “aggression,” along with genocide, crimes against humanity, and war crimes, as one of the “core crimes” over which the ICC would have jurisdiction.
“I think I can anticipate what will constitute a crime of ‘aggression’ in the eyes of this Court: It will be a crime of aggression when the United States of America takes any military action to defend its national interests, unless the U.S. first seeks and receives the permission of the United Nations, Helms said.
Republicans also rejected the treaty’s notion of “universal jurisdiction” by which the actions of a state which did not join the treaty could still be subject to the court’s jurisdiction. U.S. Ambassador David Scheffer, who led the American delegation in Rome, agreed that the treaty’s claim to universal jurisdiction, even in the absence of a UN Security Council resolution, could well threaten US defence and peacekeeping commitments abroad.
The U.S. delegatyion in Rome objected to the power of the Court’s prosecutor to initiate cases without the consent of the Security Council, in which Washington, one of the five permanent members, holds a veto.
But Michael Scharf, director of the Center for International Law and Policy at the New England School of Law in Boston, declared substantial headway had been made in Rome on almost all of the issues of concern. But Washington felt compelled to vote against the treaty because it did not get “what would amount to an iron-clad exemption for U.S. servicemen,” he said.
Helms said he would seek assurances from the administration that, if the ICC takes effect, Washington would not provide any financial or other assistance and would renegotiate all accords with foreign countries where U.S. forces were stationed to ensure their immunity from the Court’s reach.
Human rights activists feared that Republican lawmakers would go further by enacting legislation forbidding any US support for the ICC and conditioning certain kinds of bilateral aid for countries, or NATO membership, in the case of East European countries, on their non-adherence to the treaty.