Thursday, November 19, 2026
Gustavo Gonzalez
- Environmentalists in Chile criticised the government’s energy policy as “irresponsible” Wednesday, while warning that the giant Ralco dam would trigger an environmental disaster – besides violating laws protecting indigenous rights.
Activists submitted a proposal for a sustainable energy policy in the midst of the ongoing conflict over the construction of the Ralco hydroelectric dam on the upper stretch of the Bio-bio river, some 500 kms south of Santiago.
The mega-project has been on hold for the past two weeks, due to the staunch refusal of seven indigenous Pehuenche families to leave their land, which will be flooded when the reservoir is filled in.
The Action Group for the Bio-bio (GABB), the Sustainable Chile Programme and the Institute of Political Ecology (IEP) accused the centre-left coalition government of President Eduardo Frei and Endesa, the Chilean company involved in the project, of distorting the debate surrounding Ralco.
The government and Endesa point out that the seven families are a small minority compared to 84 other indigenous families who agreed to swap their ancestral lands for property offered by Endesa.
Chilean authorities and Endesa maintain that if the dam – slated to produce 570 megawatts a year – is not built, the country will find itself short of electricity by the year 2002.
“To say that only seven families of Pehuenches, backed by ‘eco- terrorists’, are against 14 million Chileans who are going to have to ‘turn their lights off’ is an intelligent propaganda maneuvre by the government and Endesa,” said Sara Larrain, the president of the Sustainable Chile Programme.
But that accusation is false, she maintained, because studies have demonstrated that it is possible to obtain the same amount of electricity – or even more – through rational use plans and the “recovery” of energy.
GABB’s Juan Pablo Orrego noted that the chairwoman of the National Energy Commission, Maria Eugenia Gonzalez, initially said Ralco was not the best solution for Chile, while the National Environment Commission (CONAMA) rejected Endesa’s environmental impact study.
The environmentalists argue that in its eagerness to give the Endesa project the green light, the Frei administration made changes in the institutions governing the environment – removing officials opposed to Ralco, for example – and that it now planned to violate laws on indigenous rights.
The proposal presented by the Sustainable Chile Programme is based on a study by the University of Chile’s Energy Research Programme, which analyses the possibility of diversifying the country’s energy sources and using them more efficiently.
Larrain underlined that while Chile’s annual average Gross Domestic Product growth stood at seven percent, its energy consumption was growing by 10 percent a year – figures she said clearly revealed inefficient use of energy as the two indexes were in line in most countries.
The proposal for a sustainable energy policy is designed to correct that imbalance and promote the adequate generation of electricity from natural gas to be imported from Argentina, the development of unconventional sources, energy saving and efficient consumption habits.
The Frei administration was favouring a company, Endesa, whose bottom line was profits, which meant it was interested in constantly growing demand rather than the rational use of energy, she warned.
Chile’s Endesa is part of the Enersis consortium, which entered into association last year with Spain’s Endesa, in a financial operation tarnished by charges that the Chilean executives – currently facing a lawsuit brought by the state – lined their pockets with illegally obtained money.
IEP president Manuel Baquedano pointed out that Pablo Rodriguez, a former leader of the extreme right, was serving as defence lawyer for the former Enersis executives at the same time he defended Endesa in the litigation with the seven Pehuenche families.
According to Chile’s Law on Indigenous Development, Baquedano stressed, the seven Pehuenche families could not be forced to trade their lands to Endesa. He added that a majority of the other 84 families were tricked into agreeing to the land swap.
Orrego cited a specific case, publicised by a TV report, of an elderly Pehuenche woman who was forced by Endesa’s lawyers to sign her land over in exchange for cash and the offer of medical assistance.
Larrain noted that in accordance with the Law on Indigenous Development, it was the government’s duty to keep pressure from being applied against the Pehuenches, and to make sure the land swap contracts were drafted in the indigenous community’s language, which was not done.
Meanwhile, the Ralco dam could cause an environmental disaster, Orrego warned. But, he added, in the conflict with the Pehuenche families, the question of the project’s potential environmental impact has tended to fade into the background.
Ralco, combined with the Pangue dam which has already been built by Endesa, would cause the destruction of some 70 kms of the 400-km long Bio-bio river, Chile’s largest river, which runs from the Andes mountains to the Pacific ocean. In other words, said Orrego, it would destroy half of the upper stretch of the river, which is home to a unique ecosystem with endemic species of flora and fauna, many of which are endangered.
The 14-km Pangue reservoir and the 35-km Ralco reservoir would flood around 4,000 hectares of land and turn a continuously flowing river system into a lake, he explained.
That would alter not only the river’s biodiversity, Orrego added, but would disrupt the chain of organic food sediment that makes the Gulf of Arauco, in the Pacific, one of the world’s richest fishing grounds.