Thursday, November 19, 2026
Johanna Son
- Recovery plans in recession-hit Asia, many of them prescribed by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), must put as much premium on shielding social sectors from damage as it does on stabilising markets and currencies, says World Health Organisation (WHO) chief Gro Harlem Brundtland.
In an interview Tuesday, Brundtland explained that recovery schemes often focus too much on the larger economy and financial and stock markets, and not enough on “social and economic issues that relate to living standards and people’s lives”.
“There is a danger if we get into a slippery slope on health and fall back on achieved results (over the past few decades),” Brundtland told IPS.
In the long run, this would hurt not just social sectors or individual people, but the capability of entire economies, she pointed out.
Brundtland, who became WHO director general in May, says this is why “we need to tell the IMF” about how crucial it is to protect the health and education sectors from cuts under traditional austerity programmes underway in countries like Thailand, Indonesia and South Korea.
This is a message that organisations like WHO should be discussing with the Fund, she said.
In fact, WHO is working with the Manila-based Asian Development Bank “to try to safeguard health” in some of the troubled economies, added Brundtland, who was in Manila until Tuesday for a regional meeting of WHO’s Western Pacific region.
In contrast “the IMF is a little different because there is no running relationship between the IMF and WHO”,” she pointed out. “The IMF is more distant to the general development dialogue between partners. That is an issue which needs to be addressed and which we need to discuss with the IMF.”
Across East Asia, “there are real risks if accessibility to basic and key services are reduced, because you can get setbacks in health statistics, which means more people with untimely and premature disease and children with disabilities and so on,” Brundtland said.
“If we don’t have good basic primary health care, especially for pregnant mothers and children, it will certainly create setbacks and this should be avoided at all costs,” added the WHO chief, a former prime minister of Norway.
More than a year into a regional slump, economies from South Korea down to Indonesia are reflecting steep social costs borne often by women and children, and the already marginalised poor.
As economies contract and unemployment soars, people’s incomes are slashed so deeply that many are unable to keep children in school or to afford basic medicines whose prices have soared with massive currency collapses.
This month, the United Nations office in Indonesia said that two of three Indonesians are likely to be living in poverty in 1999. That is a far cry from the 11 percent poverty incidence figure in Indonesia as of 1996, a percentage that used to be as high as 70 percent some three decades ago.
Reports say malnutrition is climbing as Indonesians have a hard time buying rice, vegetables and other basic foods. Some worry that infant mortality, which has been cut by two-thirds in the last quarter of a century, could rise by 30 percent.
Pregnant women often have a hard time affording health care, and childhood diseases may well come back as common vaccinations become prohibitive for ordinary citizens.
In South Korea, the government has had to help feed children whose families are unable to support them, while more and more Thai children are having to turn to work to survive.
In short, Asia’s recession threatens to slow, or even reverse, major gains made during the region’s boom decades in poverty reduction and improvement in health areas such as maternal and infant mortality.
“If things go wrong and we don’t have safety nets in the health sector, people and families suffer directly, so that is the kind of social costs which you can’t see but which you know is there,” Brundtland said.
But while multilateral institutions like the IMF need to be sensitised more to the need to continue to hold the fort in investment in health and education even in hard times, Brundtland says governments also need to review their own budget priorities.
For instance, she said: “Maybe too much (money) is going to defense. I expect that you can pool some resources going into the military field and use them for social reasons, health and education”.
But while everyone agrees that social sectors should as much as possible be spared the pain of austerity, Asian governments find themselves in a spot — trying to attend to the growing ranks of the poor, holding down social unrest and trying to woo international confidence back.
Often, these cash and investment-short economies have little choice but to depend on inflows from bail-out schemes that require strict austerity measures to meet macroeconomic targets.
Asked how they can put their foot down and insist on safety nets for the poor, Brundtland replied: “It’s a very difficult question, a very difficult balancing act and so I don’t think there are any clear-cut and simple answers to this.”
“But it’s important to work together to really try to analyse what options are among the best,” she said.
“We have to take seriously these social consequences, otherwise they will not be helpful in the long term for the economic ability of countries,” Brundtland explained. “On the other hand, you have to address seriously the financial crisis.”
“This is a challenge to any political leader to try to strike the right balance — and for those who advise and help them — also to help find that balance,” Brundtland added.