Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

POPULATION: South Asia Unprepared For Demographic Bonus

Dev Raj

NEW DELHI, Sep 2 1998 (IPS) - If South Asia is to cash in on the ‘demographic bonus’ coming its way, it must create jobs and buck up on good governance, says a report released by the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) Wednesday.

According to the UNFPA’s ‘State of the World Population Report’ 1998, the region’s failure to invest in education and health and reduce unemployment would not only mean squandering the bonus but also lead to social unrest and instability.

So far, UNFPA India representative Wasim Zaman said at the local launch of the report here, “India has not taken the right steps in order to take advantage of the demographic bonus” that may allow economies to pick up growth due to coming changes in demographic profiles.

“Lots of people who could have done much better are going to be denied the opportunity because of inadequate planning,” he pointed out.

In South Asia, UNFPA estimates that demographic change and resulting increase in productive people aged 15 to 24 years of age could further boost its growth during the years 1990 to 2025.

It estimates the total contribution of demographic factors to reach between 0.55 and 1.25 percentage points in terms of economic growth rates.

The stimulus of what UNFPA calls the ‘workforce bulge’ holds true for all regions and affects them in the same way: change in the working-age population, rather than overall population growth, is what makes the difference.

Of course, the demographic bonus is a one-time occurrence and cannot be sustained once the size of the older population begins to increase dramatically.

Between 15 and 40 percent of the growth of per capita income in East Asia can actually be attributed to changes in demographic age structures over the last few decades, the report estimates.

The workforce bulge effect can propel growth anywhere. Its role in Europe between the late nineteenth century and the early twentieth century is currently being studied.

Now that it is South Asia’s turn, the big question is how prepared the region is to take advantage of a phenomenon which transformed East Asia in the past few decades, and will continue to sustain it despite its recent economic turbulence and uncertainty.

The 1998 Report on Human Development in South Asia, brought out by the Islamabad-based, Human Development Centre (HDC), presents precisely the kind of picture which UNFPA warns against.

The HDC report, which focused on education, showed that more than half of South Asia’s adult population is still illiterate and that in fact the region’s adult literacy rate is lower than elsewhere in the world.

Sri Lanka is the only exception in the region where education and literacy rates are concerned. Adult literacy rates have increased there from 77 percent to 90 percent in the last two decades — one of the highest in the developing world.

Across South Asia about 260 million people are not provided health facilities, 337 million have no access to safe drinking water and 828 million are without any sanitation facilities.

On the nutrition front, half of the world’s malnourished children or 84 million are to be found in just three countries — Bangladesh, Pakistan and India. An estimated 135 million children in the region are employed as labourers.

East and South-east Asia, which began with the same per capita income as South Asia in the sixties, present a picture of contrast today because of heavy investments in human capital.

In fact, UNFPA says the recovery of the Asian tiger economies will be helped by their past investment in education and health, through the resulting lower mortality and fertility rates.

Nor will they need to make any great future investments and the Asian tigers can actually fall back on their better educated workforce to revive their sagging economies, UNFPA predicts.

However, the ageing of some Asian populations will moderate economic growth in East and South-east Asia. During 1965-1990, GDP per capita growth in East Asia of an average 6.1 percent, between 0.9 and 1.5 percentage points, were the result of favourable demographic trends.

Demographic trends expected during the 1990 – 2025 period are likely to reduce growth rates in Hong Kong, South Korea and Singapore by 1.3 to 1.9 percentage points while growth in South- east Asia could fall by 0.2 to 0.6 percent, the UNFPA report says.

In contrast, demographic change could further boost South Asia’s growth in the same period, contributing significantly to economic growth.

Countries in East and South-east Asia that have completed the demographic transition and reached replacement levels of fertility will not be able to reap an economic bonus from a growing labour forces, but other changes can compensate.

For example, the migration of workers could increase the labour force and help ease the post-bulge decline. Similarly high levels of development could translate into productivity gains that bolster economies.

Growth could result from economic transition in response to new demands — in the service, information, financial and medical sectors — of older populations commanding more resources than in the past.

South Asian countries have a lot of catching up to do, but there are opportunities through focusing on basic education and an outward-looking trade strategy as their neighbours did so successfully, say both the HDC and the UNFPA reports.

The HDC report points out that many South Asian countries today have literacy rates that are much lower than those which the East and South-east Asian countries had achieved more than three decades ago when they began their economic transition.

Besides, the quality of education in South Asia leaves a lot to be desired. In a general knowledge test of class five students in 527 primary schools in Pakistan for instance, 57 percent believed that the sun revolved around the earth.

A survey in India revealed that less than half of fourth grade teachers could correctly answer 80 percent of the mathematics tests given to their own students.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags