Thursday, November 19, 2026
- Canada’s reputation as a haven for refugees and immigrants is undeserved and out of date, say critics of Canadian refugee policy.
About 25,000 of the 212,000 people who immigrated to Canada last year were refugees. The government had a 30,000-person refugee quota, and a 240,000-person one for immigrants. Critics of the system say it has become so cumbersome that legitimate refugees either give up in frustration or are turned away.
Right-wing politicians here have tried to paint immigrants as a drain on welfare and health services, and as potential criminals. In October, they made political mileage on the arrests of more than 70 Honduran refugee claimants living in Vancouver, who are alleged to have been running a major cocaine importing and distribution network.
Most immigrants to Canada, however, are relatively affluent and skilled people who have fallen afoul of the governments of their home countries, say NGO workers who help refugees.
Critics of the Canadian system say it is unfair that Canada is the only country in the world that places a head tax on refugees and immigrants: about 1,000 U.S. dollars for adults and 65 U.S. dollars per child.
A panel set up by the government to make recommendations to reform the system wants immigrants to pay even more: the cost of English- or French-language education for refugees who don’t speak any of Canada’s two official languages.
Most criticism, however, is directed at the tribunals that decide whether people who claim protection are truly refugees. The quasi- judicial Immigration and Refugee Board has a backlog of 29,000 cases, the equivalent of more than one year’s tally of legal refugees.
And the board now faces embarrassing accusations of bias, levied by NGOs and by former members who have gone public with allegations that some board members are extremely narrow-minded.
In September, the Canadian Jewish Congress (CJC) demanded a full, independent inquiry of the Immigration and Refugee Board. Moshe Ronen, president of the CJC, said the board now operates under “a cloud of suspicion”. He said former and current board members had come forward to accuse other tribunal officers of being anti- Semitic, homophobic, and intolerant.
The some 200 board members are appointed by the government, without confirmation hearings by Canada’s parliament. There are no set qualifications for members of the board, who hold tribunal hearings in most of Canada’s major cities.
Their decisions can only be overturned by a superior court or by an order from Canada’s federal minister of immigration. While appeals of immigration board decisions are common, the board’s findings are rarely overturned.
Ministerial orders are even rarer, and are usually issued for high-profile cases or immigration matters that have security overtones, such as granting asylum to a former espionage agent.
“The allegations are serious enough to warrant a full investigation. If anyone thinks these allegations are just going to be swept under the rug, they’re mistaken,” Ronen said.
In September,the government hired a prominent lawyer to probe the allegations of bias. Deputy chair John Frecker is being investigated for saying “seig heil” and making a Nazi salute to a fellow board member, who then filed an official complaint.
One board member is being investigated for writing a decision to expel a refugee claimant while the man’s lawyer was presenting his case. Another is alleged to have said that she would never give permission for a homosexual to stay in Canada.
Critics have branded the Canadian refugee system corrupt and callous. Mary Jo Leddy, author of ‘At the Border Called Hope’, a book about Canada’s refugee system that was published last year, says the refugee board is so worried about keeping criminals out of Canada that they’re turning away legitimate refugees.
Leddy, who shelters refugees in her home and operates three other houses for refugees, says part of the problem is that many Canadian refugee lawyers do not care about their clients.
She says many such lawyers, who are paid by the governmental Legal Aid for indigents, bill for work they haven’t done, fall asleep in hearings, ask clients to sign blank forms, and are generally incompetent. Clients complain to the organizations that discipline lawyers, but by the time their protests are scheduled to be heard, the complainants have already been deported.
At the same time, Leddy says, some refugees are victimized by shady ‘immigration counselors’, who advertise their services in developing and war-torn countries. They promise approval of immigration and refugee applications and often suggest they have influence with the government.
Leddy says the regulations are so complex and are amended so often that Canadian NGOs can’t keep up with the changes. “It’s a Byzantine system that has very little regard for refugees as human beings,” she charges.
In 1992, Leddy and other NGO leaders risked jail by organizing an “underground railroad” for 23 refugees facing deportation to countries where they were likely to be executed or jailed. Since then, all but one of those refugees, along with their families, have been given permission to stay in Canada.
Leddy says the system is so cumbersome and unfair that it’s dehumanizing the public servants who are forced to work in it. “You can’t sugar-coat it anymore,” she says.
Some recent cases have become focal points for critics of the system:
* In September, a Chilean family took shelter in a church basement in Saint John, New Brunswick, after their request for refugee status on compassionate grounds was denied. Marcela Roma, her spouse Elias Hurtado, and their two children, were on the run from Roma’s former husband, a Chilean police officer who threatened to kill the family.
* Mohamad Sharif Karimzada, an refugee who had served in the foreign ministry of a previous Afghan regime, was ordered to leave Canada in August, despite a plea for mercy from former U.S. president Jimmy Carter. The federal government said Karimzada could not stay in Canada because he had been an official of a repressive regime. He is appealing to the courts.
* Immigration system critics say the government has singled out groups such as gypsies and Kurdish refugees for unfair treatment. Both groups are required to get special visas before entering Canada, and gypsies say they have been refused access to Canadian immigration offices in Eastern Europe.
The system does give shelter to some refugees. In August, four Filipino sailors from a Taiwanese ship were given refugee status after they testified that they had seen their Taiwanese officers throw a Romanian stowaway overboard while their ship steamed 200 kilometers from the North African coast.
The sailors, crewmen on the container ship Maersk Dubai, had to fight for two years to stay in Canada.
And, in September, a former Honduran judge who had made a ruling against a multinational fruit company and then had to flee her country to save her life, was allowed to stay in Canada after a hearing by the Immigration and Refugee Board. During the Sep. 8 hearing, members of the Vancouver panel had tears in their eyes as Reyna Arguenta told how thugs hired by the fruit company terrorized her in her home and coerced the Honduran government into firing her.
Later, she said, the government filed false charges against her. Arguenta eventually made her way through the United States to the Canadian border, which she crossed on foot in a wilderness area in the Rocky Mountains.