Thursday, November 19, 2026
Analysis - Jim Lobe
- It took a Chinese Communist to remind President Bill Clinton how politics is supposed to work in an advanced capitalist society.
Less than a week ago Chinese Premier Zhu Rongji left Washington a disappointed man, apparently defeated in his efforts to clinch a deal with the US President on the terms of Beijing’s membership in the World Trade Organisation (WTO).
Five days later Zhu was wrapping up his trip to the United States in a much better frame of mind.
His non-stop lobbying of US big business appears to have produced a new determination on Clinton’s part to strike an accord – and fast.
After feeling the heat generated by top business executives, many of whom met Zhu during the past several days, Clinton telephoned the Chinese premier at his New York hotel on Tuesday to ask him to resume negotiations by the end of this month.
The idea now is to clinch a deal as soon as possible and well before the next round of global negotiations are launched in Seattle in November.
Clinton’s phone call followed publication of a full-page advertisement in the Washington Post paid for by the Business Roundtable, an exclusive group comprised of the CEOs of the biggest 200 US corporations.
“Now is the Time to Bring China into the Global Trading System,” blared the advertisement.
It added that US trade negotiators, who laboured desperately to close a WTO deal before Clinton and Zhu held face-to-face talks at the White House last Thursday, had brought home “an unprecedented trade deal with China that will create jobs and opportunities for American farmers, manufacturers, workers, and service providers.”
“This agreement could be an enormous win for America …if it is concluded and implemented,” the advertisement asserted – the equivalent of a big business seal of approval aimed at Clinton and Congress, which could still veto an agreement.
“We’re optimistic,” Johanna Schneider, the Roundtable’s spokeswoman, told IPS Wednesday. “We’re very encouraged by the president’s conversation, and we’re hopeful that these talks are now back on track, because from what we’ve seen so far, it looks like this potential deal will make a historic breakthrough on trade.”
Indeed, it does. The concessions offered by Zhu, who is Beijing’s top economic policy maker, were substantially greater than most analysts here had predicted.
“My overall sense is that the Chinese conceded more than I thought would be politically possible,” said Nicholas Lardy, a senior analyst at the Brookings Institution.
“You have to remember that unemployment is at a 30-year high in China, corporate profits are falling off a cliff, and here is Zhu arguing that this is a moment to actually allow the foreigners to offer more domestic competition.”
In fact, the deal split the administration between Clinton’s top trade negotiators and national-security officials on the one hand and senior political aides on the other.
The latter argued that the current anti-China mood in Congress would not only make the package very difficult to pass, but likely also would split the Democratic Party on a key issue less than one year before the 2000 presidential campaign.
To help persuade Clinton, Zhu had come with a number of unilateral concessions designed to bolster political support in Congress for a deal.
Regardless of China’s entry into the WTO, he agreed to lift import bans on wheat from the US Pacific Northwest, on citrus fruit from the politically potent states of California, and on beef, pork, and poultry. He also agreed to double flights between China and take further measures to prevent computer-software piracy.
If China were accepted into the WTO, Zhu agreed to a number of other far-reaching steps, according to the administration, including easing curbs on foreign insurance companies and banks; permitting foreign companies to sell their products directly to consumers; and lifting the ban on foreign investment in telecommunications.
In addition, the Chinese offered to eliminate quotas on bulk commodities; reduce average industrial tariffs from about 25 percent to under ten percent; and permit foreign-owned movie theatres, hotels, and travel agencies.
On the eve of Zhu’s White House visit last week, Clinton appeared ready to sign a deal. “If China is willing to play by the global rules of trade,” he said, “it would be an inexplicable mistake for the United States to say no.”
At the same time, however, the Senate Majority Leader, Republican Trent Lott, announced that he opposed China’s entry into the WTO at this time. His declaration apparently helped persuade Clinton that a final deal was not politically viable.
At a joint news conference the following day, Zhu did not hide his disappointment, arguing that only the “political atmosphere” – not a “big gap” in negotiations positions – prevented a final accord.
Over the next several days, he would enlarge on that theme, especially with the hundreds of businessmen whom he met on his five-city tour of the United States.
He implied not only China’s offers would be taken off the table if he returned to China without at least the promise of a deal, but also that his own reform programme, which Washington strongly supports, may cease to be viable.
Business leaders got the message and launched their own campaign.
The Roundtable’s ad was one signal; as were harsh denunciations of the administration by pro-business lawmakers in the Senate Finance Committee Tuesday. “We cannot let perfection be the enemy of the good,” said Max Baucus of Montana, a Democrat, while Alaska Republican Frank Murkowski lambasted Clinton for “political cowardice.”
It was then that Clinton called Zhu, who reported the conversation, appropriately enough, to New York’s exclusive Economic Club in New York. He said he felt that a final deal was “99 percent” finished.
To most observers, however, that may be an exaggeration. Remaining sticking points which Washington wants resolved in its favour include easing curbs on foreign brokerage firms; more protections against dumping; and limits on Chinese textile shipments to the U.S. – a provision which Beijing strongly opposes.
Getting the package through Congress, where anti-China feeling has risen to a ten-year high, will not be easy.
Officials believe a coalition of lawmakers with strong ties to labour unions, human rights groups, defence hawks worried about alleged Chinese thefts of US military secrets, and textile industries could doom any effort to gain permanent “most-favoured- nation” status for China, a condition for WTO membership.
Still, the wishes of big business cannot be ignored. As the Business Roundtable ad said “The stakes are high – for Americans and for the rules-based trading system that has served us so well.”