Africa, Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

TRADE-US: House Clears Africa Trade Bill

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Jul 16 1999 (IPS) - President Bill Clinton and US multinational companies racked up a victory in the House of Representatives Friday with the passing of a new trade bill designed to boost US commerce and investment in sub-Saharan Africa.

The lower house of Congress voted 234 to 163 in favour of the bill, despite opposition from labour unions, some non-governmental organisations (NGOs) active on African issues and textile interests – fearful of Asian exporters to trans-shipping goods to the United States via Africa.

As passed by the House, the bill – the Africa Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) – would grant duty-and-quota free treatment to most African products. This would apply particularly to textiles and apparel and the bill also offers various incentives, including hundreds of millions of dollars in loans and credits, to US companies investing in Africa.

To obtain maximum benefits from the Act, however, African countries would be required to liberalise their economies by opening them wider to foreign competition and investment. They also must comply with policy prescriptions by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank.

Governments which abused the human rights of their citizens would be ineligible to benefit from the programme.

The bill still must be considered by the Senate where textile interests are stronger than in the House. Last year, the bill died in the Senate after it was approved in the House by a 233-186 vote.

Last month, the Senate Finance Committee approved its version of the bill which, unlike the more liberal House version, would permit duty- and quota-free access to the US market for African apparel exports only if they were made from US yarns or fabrics.

House sponsors of the bill have objected that such a requirement would defeat one of its primary aims – to promote the growth in Africa of labour-intensive industries, such as textiles and apparel assembly. The higher costs involved in shipping the yarn or fabric to Africa would outweigh any other competitive advantage, such as cheaper labour, that African might enjoy, they said.

Despite AGOA’s cloudy prospects in the Senate, the administration – which had made the bill a legislative priority since before Clinton’s unprecedented trip to Africa in March, 1998 – welcomed the House approval.

“This was not only an important test of support for the administration’s Africa policy,” said one official after the vote. “It was also the first important piece of trade legislation to reach the floor of either house this year.”

More than two-thirds of House Republicans voted in favour of AGOA, while Democrats split right down the middle, 98-99. Most members of the Congressional Black Caucus, who have voted in recent years to oppose trade-liberalising measures, also voted for the bill, as they did last year.

Africa actually accounts for a tiny amount of US trade and investment, and what little does exist is concentrated in just a few countries: primarily oil exporters Nigeria, Angola, and Gabon, and South Africa.

In 1998, US imports from the region – almost all of it in the form of basic commodities, especially oil, came to 13.1 billion dollars, or just one percent of all US imports. Exports – mainly machinery, transport equipment, and wheat – stood at 6.7 billion dollars, or about one percent of all exports.

Similarly, US direct investment in Africa in 1997 came to about 3.3 percent of total US direct investment abroad, or 3.8 billion dollars, most of it in the petroleum industries of Nigeria and Angola.

The purpose of the bill passed Friday was to boost all of those numbers and percentages by doubling the number of African exports which can enter the US market duty- and quota-free, and authorising almost a billion dollars in credits, loans, and guarantees that US export agencies can use to promote trade and investment in Africa.

The House Democratic Whip, David Bonior, argued that, in the absence of explicit protections for workers, the bill’s impact would be to reduce their wages, as occurred in Mexico after the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) took effect in 1994.

“This repeats the mistakes that we made in Mexico,” he said.

But the bill’s sponsors strongly denied these charges. “American workers are not protected by an impoverished Africa,” said Earl Pomeroy, a Colorado Republican.

Passage of the bill also ended debate on the ‘HOPE for Africa Act’, a bill sponsored by Rep. Jesse Jackson Jr. and more than 70 of his Democratic colleagues.

Backed AGOA’s NGO and union opponents, it included forgiving all of Africa’s bilateral debt with the United States, providing more aid to the region, and tying trade and investment incentives to countries’ adherence to labour rights and environmental protection.

Jackson tried Friday to amend AGOA to require all the 350 million dollars provided by the bill to the Overseas Private Investment Corporation (OPIC) to be spent on projects, such as basic health services, water and sanitation, schools, rural electrification, and accessible transportation, which are designed to meet the basic needs of most Africans.

The amendment, however, was defeated on a voice vote.

The other major controversy was over the bill’s effect on the faltering US textile industry, particularly if Chinese companies tried to take advantage of the bill by trans-shipping their goods through Africa.

“This will be a national holiday in China if we pass this bill,” said Lindsay Graham, a Republican from South Carolina.

The bill’s sponsors, however, insisted that AGOA’s anti- transshipping provisions were strong enough to prevent such practices. “We have the mechanisms to stop that,” said Amo Houghton, a New York Republican.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags