Monday, November 16, 2026
Jim Lobe
- Legislation designed to boost US trade and investment in sub-Saharan Africa and the Caribbean Basin has been revived in Washington after the Senate agreed Tuesday to limit debate on the measure and take a final vote later this week.
The action virtually assured final passage of the long-pending Africa Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), approved by the House of Representatives by a 234-163 margin last July.
The Senate move also gave the Caribbean Basin Initiative (CBI) a fighting chance to become law. This would allow Central American and Caribbean countries to enjoy most of the trade advantages obtained by Mexico under the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA).
While the pro-trade House Ways and Means Committee approved a far-reaching CBI bill earlier this year, it did not send it to the House floor because of stronger protectionist sentiment there. The House defeated a similar bill two years ago 182-234.
“Even though the Senate version is more protectionist than what was passed by the Ways and Means Committee, the CBI section will face an uphill struggle when the conference committee meets,” said one Congressional aide Tuesday.
The conference committee, which will begin work when the Senate approves the bill, is meant to reconcile different versions of the same legislation before a final version is sent to the president for his signature.
While the House version included only the AGOA, the Senate bill icontained three other components: the CBI; a five-year extension of the US Generalised System of Preferences (which permits the president to reduce tariffs on exports from most developing countries); and an aid and retraining package for workers who lose their jobs due to foreign competition.
The conference committee could approve only the AGOA and drop any or all of the other sections from the Senate bill.
If, on the other hand, the entire Senate package is approved by the House conferees, the result would be a major victory for the administration of President Bill Clinton which has failed to gain approval for any major piece of trade legislation for five years.
It also would give Clinton more credibility at the ministerial meeting of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) which is supposed to launch a new round of global trade negotiations in Seattle later this month.
“Let’s not go to Seattle empty-handed,” said Senate Finance Chairman William Roth, the prime sponsor of the Senate bill, just before Tuesday’s vote.
The Senate bill had been thought dead Friday when Democrats voted against ending a filibuster against it. Many of their votes, however, were designed to protest Majority Leader Trent Lott’s refusal to entertain amendments to the bill that were not related to trade.
On Monday, Lott and Minority Leader Tom Daschle worked out a deal under which amendments could be offered on another bill instead. With that hurdle out of the way, the Senate voted 73-24 Tuesday to limit debate on the trade measure to 30 hours, effectively ending the threat of a filibuster.
The 73-24 vote also was believed to roughly reflect how the upper house would vote on the final measure when the 30 hours expired.
Opposition to both the Africa and CBI portions of the legislation has been strongest among lawmakers from mostly southern states that have major textile interests. They argued that easing existing trade barriers to textile imports would deal another blow to a domestic industry which has suffered huge job losses over the last two decades through many US apparel companies moving offshore.
The bill also has been opposed by Democrats with strong links to labour unions, environmental organisations and some development groups. They have criticised the measures as a corporate scheme to export US jobs to cheap-labour countries and because the bill promotes an “inappropriate” development model for poor nations.
They particularly are upset that AGOA grants duty- and quota- free treatment to most African exports – provided that the countries of originmeet certain conditions.
To get AGOA’s full benefits, countries must be engaged in a process of liberalising their economies along lines approved by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF). They must provide guarantees for foreign investors, protect intellectual property rights, join the WTO, and take other measures designed to make them more attractive to US business.
Some critics, including church and labour groups, have charged that the bill would help US corporate investors more than ordinary Africans. Instead, they have backed legislation for more debt relief to African countries and amendments that would ensure provide more support to small and indigenous business and agriculture; but these measures lack majority support.
The CBI section of the bill would grant to Central American and Caribbean countries virtually the same trade preferences as Mexico received under NAFTA.
The major exception would be textiles and apparel. Under the Senate version of the bill, textiles and apparel from CBI countries could enter the United States duty- and quota-free only if they were assembled from US-made yarns or fabric, or if they were handmade. All other textile and apparel exports would continue to be subject to US trade restrictions.
Similar restrictions would apply to African textile and apparel exports under the Senate version, which also would imposes heavy penalties against any company which attempted to “transship” products from Asia or any other region through Africa in order to take advantage of AGOA preferences.
For some critics, the US content requirement on African textiles and apparel would be a major blow to using AGOA to boost the African textile industry, potentially a major employer in a region which where unemployment and under-employment are major problems.
While it still would be profitable for US textile manufacturers to ship their products to the Caribbean for assembly and to return them to the US market, the greater transport cost between the United States and Africa would make assembly operations far more expensive.