Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT-US: Clinton Administration Fights Federal Ruling on Trade Panels

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Jan 14 2000 (IPS) - Environmentalists are blasting the administration of President Bill Clinton for fighting a recent federal court order that required it to include at least two representatives of the environmental activist community on two panels that advise it on international trade policy.

Environmental groups say the make-up of these advisory panels reflects how trade agreements – including policy made through the World Trade Organisation – have often been worked out in an undemocratic manner, behind closed doors and with no public participation.

Information shared between industry and the US Trade Representative (USTR) is not publicly released, except for brief summaries of subjects discussed. Meanwhile, the environmental consequences of trade agreements can be enormous, the groups argue.

But in the Jan 12 announcement by the USTR and the US Department of Commerce that they had filed an appeal the previous week, the agencies argue that the court’s November decision would “undermine” the advisory process.

“The court’s ruling, if permitted to stand, could undermine the framework that Congress established” for “channeling important negotiating advice to the administration from the manufacturing and services sectors,” said Commerce Secretary William Daley.

He said the two agencies would carry out the court’s orders pending the outcome of the appeal. An expedited appeal is expected to take up to six to nine months, while an ordinary appeal could take more than a year.

Before announcing the appeal, Daley and USTR Charlene Barshefsky told of a new government initiative to “enhance opportunities” for environmental, consumer and other non-governmental organisations to “provide their view to the administration on trade issues.”

“We welcome ideas from interested parties…on how we might improve our procedures for securing advice from across the broad spectrum of civil society,” said Daley.

The appeal stems from a lawsuit filed last year by environmental groups – including the Sierra Club and the International Forum on Globalisation – against the USTR and Department of Commerce, arguing that US law requires such advisory panels to be balanced and not comprise solely business and industry leaders.

In November, a US federal court judge, Barbara Rothstein, found that the administration was violating the Federal Advisory Council Act because the membership of the two committees did not provide a “fair balance of viewpoints,” as the law requires.

“The forest ISACs (Industry Sector Advisory Committees) offer advice on diverse and far-reaching issues that affect others, especially those who promote forest conservation,” wrote Rothstein in her opinion.

“The composition of the forest product ISACs thus violates (the law’s) requirement to be fairly balanced in terms of viewpoints to be represented,” asserted Rothstein, a veteran judge whose rulings almost always have been upheld on appeal.

Doug Norlen, a policy analyst with the Pacific Environment Resources Centre, one of the plaintiffs in the original case, called the government’s appeal and accompanying initiative a “blatant attempt at Orwellian spin.”

Despite Clinton’s pledge to include non-governmental organisations in the process of developing trade policies, “the USTR remains addicted to its secret meetings with industry fat cats, without the beginnings of a clue of what true public participation means,” says Norlen.

The appeal reflects the “continuing hypocrisy” in the administration’s trade policy, says Patty Goldman, an attorney at the Earthjustice Legal Defense Fund, who argued the cases before Rothstein’s court in Seattle, Washington.

“It calls for openness in the World Trade Organisation while maintaining secrecy and inside industry access to negotiators at home,” she says.

Joe Scott, conservation director of the lead plaintiff group, the Northwest Ecosystem Alliance, asked: “Which Clinton administration should we believe, the one that promises inclusion or the one that practices exclusion?”

Among the 15 members of the ISAC on wood and lumber products are chief executives of the American Forest and Paper Association, the International Paper Company, and the Hardwood Plywood Manufacturers Association.

Similarly, the paper-product ISAC includes representatives from the Georgia-Pacific Corporation and the American Forest and Paper Association.

In her opinion, Rothstein noted that the two panels provided advice on environmental policy matters ranging from global warming to the UN International Forum on Forests.

This past November and December, thousands of environmentalists poured into the port city of Seattle to protest the third annual ministerial meeting of the World Trade Organisation (WTO).

Just as they criticize the administration’s trade advisory panels, groups also criticize the international trade body’s proceedings and rulings as being surrounded in secrecy.

Even as it rules on domestic environmental policy, the WTO’s tribunals and hearings of the dispute resolution panels are closed to members of the press, the public, advocacy groups and even state attorney general representing their own laws that are being challenged by the trade body.

During the protests in Seattle, forest protection advocates warned that the USTR’s push at the conference to eliminate barriers to trade in paper and wood products would spur increased logging in environmental “hotspots” like Indonesia, Malaysia, and Chile.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags