Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT-TRADE: US Environmentalists Take Aim at Americas Trade Agreement

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Feb 9 2000 (IPS) - Environmental groups, having shown their strength in protests against the World Trade Organisation (WTO), are now taking aim at proposals for a Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA).

First presented at the Summit of the Americas in Miami, Florida in 1994, the FTAA seeks to economically integrate the hemisphere’s 34 nations.

Even though negotiations on the FTAA are years away from being finalised, advocacy organisations have already dubbed the free trade initiative as the “little WTO” or the “bigger and meaner NAFTA,” referring to the North American Free Trade Agreement.

Environmental groups, emboldened by massive protests at the WTO’s Third Ministerial Conference in Seattle, Washington last year, say they are closely watching the ongoing FTAA negotiations to ensure they are not carried out in an undemocratic manner, behind closed doors with no public participation.

They fear the FTAA will resemble the WTO, whose proceedings and rulings, they say, are surrounded by secrecy.

Organisations point out that the international trade body’s tribunals and hearings are closed to members of the press, the public, advocacy groups and even state attorney generals representing their own laws being challenged by the trade body.

Yet these decisions have enormous consequences for the environment, they say.

“Ongoing negotiations for a Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) will be one of the first tests of whether governments have learned the lessons of Seattle,” say groups in a formal response being sent this week to the Federal Register’s request for comments on the FTAA.

About 10 US organisations signed the response, including the Center for International Environmental Law, Friends of the Earth, the Sierra Club, and Defenders of Wildlife.

If the Clinton administration and future administrations fail to use the FTAA negotiating process as an opportunity to re-direct US trade policy so that it is conducted in an open, transparent manner, the organisations say they would likely oppose the FTAA, if and when it is brought before the US Congress for ratification.

“We expect the US government to push for significant changes to both the negotiating process and the substantive trade rules being negotiated,” they say.

Increased participation in the domestic trade policymaking process will help rebuild public confidence and improve the quality of trade policies in areas including the environment, say groups.

Last month, some of these same organisations criticised the Clinton administration for appealing a recent federal court order that required it to include at least two representatives of the environmental activist community on two panels that advise it on international trade policy.

Environmental groups say the make-up of these industry- dominated advisory panels reflects how trade agreements – including the WTO and FTAA – are made.

The two panels’ advice to the US Trade Representative (USTR) on trade in paper and wood products, for example, played a role in the agency’s push at the recent WTO ministerial conference to eliminate barriers to trade in such products.

Forest protection advocates warn this would spur increased logging in ecologically vulnerable “hotspots” like Indonesia, Malaysia and Chile.

“The US government should break down the walls of secrecy and privileged corporate access that skew our government’s trade agenda in an anti-governmental direction,” say groups.

Last November, President Clinton signed an executive order requiring environmental assessments of all new trade agreements before they are enacted into law.

Groups are demanding that the administration make good on this promise and conduct an environmental assessment of the FTAA, a process which they say must include non-governmental organisations.

“Our organisations are eager to work with the US government to make an environmental assessment of the FTAA a thorough and useful exercise that will serve as a precedent for successful implementation of the new executive order,” they say.

Environmental groups say the United States must ensure that the Committee on Government Representation on Civil Society of the FTAA has public, on-the-record meetings with citizen groups and negotiators.

They say that otherwise, the committee at best will resemble the WTO’s Committee on Trade and Environment, which groups criticised for being a “nice forum for discussion with no meaningful participation in the making of trade policy.”

The group’s statement also called for the FTAA to work toward the reduction of environmentally harmful subsidies.

Such government subsidies fuel destructive logging operations and contribute to deforestation worldwide, they argue. Subsidies for commercial fishing fleets should also be halted, they say, since they lead to over-fishing the world’s already depleted fish stocks.

Groups are urging the USTR not to use the NAFTA model, which includes rules on investment, as a template for the FTAA.

Under NAFTA, corporations can sue for compensation if environmental laws reduce their property values.

US companies already were using NAFTA rules to sue countries, say environmentalists, who warned that this practice could spread to other countries as the WTO and FTAA talks progress.

For example, when Canada moved to protect its citizens’ health from a potentially harmful US fuel additive, the chemical’s manufacturer, Ethyl Corp., sued on the grounds that this would obstruct free trade. Last year, the US company succeeded in overturning Canadian law.

Metalclad, another U.S. firm, complained to NAFTA that it had been prevented from opening a waste disposal plant because of environmental zoning laws in the Mexican state of San Luis Potosi.

The FTAA could include similar financial compensation for investors who claim environmental laws have financially harmed the corporations in which they own stock, warn groups.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags