Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

FINANCE: Corporations Are Merely Wrapping Themselves In UN Flag

Gumisai Mutume

WASHINGTON, Jul 21 2000 (IPS) - A global understanding between the United Nations and multinational corporations aimed at holding big business accountable has come under fire from international human rights and environmental groups.

Known as the Global Compact, the initiative was first announced last year and will be formally launched next week by UN secretary general Kofi Annan at a high level meeting at UN Headquarters in New York.

It calls on the corporate sector to commit to human rights, labour standards and environmental practices to help promote a fairer distribution of the benefits of globalization.

But, says Kenny Bruno, of US-based corporate watchdog the Transnational Resource and Action Centre (TRAC), Nike continues to move its sweatshops to union-busting countries.

“Shell is deeply involved in human rights and environmental violations around the world, and mining colossus Rio Tinto is involved in so many debacles…”

“To believe that by signing a voluntary code such as the Global Compact these companies will shape up is misguided.”

In a statement issued ahead of the launch of the operative phase of the Compact, Bruno says the initiative will most likely provide abusive corporations with a prestigious platform from which they can bolster their images.

The Compact was first announced at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland in January last year. Then, Annan challenged world business leaders to “embrace and enact” the principles enshrined in the UN Declaration of Human Rights and the 1992 Rio Declaration adopted at the UN Conference on Environment and Development.

More than 50 companies, such as Unilever, Glaxo Wellcome, Ericsson, Daimler Chrysler, Deutsche Bank and British American Tobacco have endorsed the Compact and say since last year they have adopted initiatives aimed at making them responsible corporate citizens.

But international human rights and environmental groups, such as the Kuala Lumpur-based Third World Network, Greenpeace International and the US-based Institute for Policy Studies, think otherwise.

They say Annan’s actions amount to asking repeat offenders to endorse a non-binding, vague statement of commitment to human rights.

This will have the effect of drawing attention away from the need for more substantial action to hold corporations accountable for their behaviour, the NGOs charge in a letter to Annan.

The letter which blasts the Compact was signed by, among others, the Asia Indigenous Women’s Network in the Philippines, Uruguay’s Third World Institute, Focus on the Global South, Thailand and the Food and Agriculture Campaigner of France.

The India-based International NGO Committee on Human Rights in Trade and Investment, Chile Sustainable, the Brazilian Institute of Economic and Social Analysis and the International South Group Network in Zimbabwe also put their signatures to it.

Annan’s office Thursday issued guidelines for UN-corporate collaboration to allow the companies to use the UN name and logo, a move condemned by the NGO groups as a free public relations ride for the corporations.

For instance, in Nigeria a company like Shell could work with the UN to fund a tree-planting programme in the Niger Delta – an area where it has extracted billions of dollars in profits and wreaked social and environmental havoc for decades, says TRAC Director Joshua Karliner.

“Under the new guidelines the programme might have the logos of Shell and the UN super-imposed, improving Shell’s public image, but doing little to alleviate the damage the company continues to cause there.”

In their memorandum to Annan, the NGOs raised two major concerns.

Firstly that the language of the Compact implies a universal consensus that open markets are the primary force for development. Secondly they expressed dismay that the Compact is purely voluntary and lacks provisions for monitoring and enforcement.

“We are well aware that many corporations would like nothing better than to wrap themselves in the flag of the United Nations in order to ‘bluewash’ their public image, while at the same time avoiding significant changes to their behaviour,” notes the letter.

A UN Sub-commission on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights is currently drafting a legal instrument on transnational corporations and human rights. The process, which is divorced from the Compact and seeks to establish a binding legal framework for business behaviour, may take years.

International Chamber of Commerce secretary general, Maria Livanos Cattaui, who has spearheaded the Compact on the part of business however believes that under current conditions companies “can and will do much by setting an example through good corporate practice.”

“However they cannot be expected to assume responsibilities that are properly the preserve of governments,” says Cattaui. “Therefore, business has a clear interest in stable and effective government that respects the rule of law and sees that it is applied.”

The Compact also comes at a time when there is a fierce debate over the benefits or harms of free trade and market liberalization promoted by the international financial institutions as the panacea to global poverty.

This is however disputed by a growing voice in civil society.

“All the relevant parties have to pull together if globalisation is to work for everyone,” says Annan’s special advisor, John Ruggie.

“Kofi Annan is hoping to succeed where others have failed.”

Ruggie says when Annan first proposed the compact last year, he warned of a backlash against globalization unless the process reflected the social values and common objectives of all segments of the world’s population.

“This was 10 months before Seattle,” says Ruggie, referring to the anti-globalization demonstrations, which disrupted the November meeting of the World Trade Organization, “and you’ll remember how prescient he turned out to be.”

The compact, however, appears to imply that globalization in its current form, can be made sustainable and equitable if it is accompanied by the implementation of standards for human rights, labour and the environment by multinationals.

“That the UN supports this ideology as official UN policy, has the effect of delegitimising the work and aspirations of those sectors that believe that an unregulated market is incompatible with equity and environmental sustainability,” notes the NGO letter.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags