Thursday, November 19, 2026
Danielle Knight
- Just two weeks until the US Presidential e lection and environmentalists remain divided over whether to support the Demo cratic or Green Party nomination, a factor that could give Texas Governor Ge orge W. Bush a chance to win.
While major US environmental organisations have endorsed Vice Preside nt Al Gore as their favoured presidential nominee, some environmentalists a re urging voters who care about the environment to cast their ballot for Ralph Nader, the Green Party candidate.
But environmental groups like Friends of the Earth and the Sierra Clu b that have endorsed Gore warn that a vote for Nader could tip the razor clo se race in favour of Bush, the Republican Party’s nominee, known for his poor re cord in protecting the environment.
“The Bush-Cheney ticket is a dangerous duo for the planet,” says Br ent Blackwelder, president of Friends of the Earth. “We need more than a head-in-the-sand approach to serious global environmental problems.”
While he says Nader, a well-known consumer advocate, is closest to hi s groups position on many environmental policy issues, particularly globalisat ion and genetically engineered food, since it is clear that Nader will not wi n the election, Friends of the Earth decided to support Gore.
“A grand canyon of difference separates” Bush and Gore, argues Blac kwelder. What worries Blackwelder the most is who Bush would most likely appoi nt to cabinet, judicial, and agency posts who deal with national and global environmental policy.
Judging by Bush’s past record, it does not seem likely that his appoi ntments would be partial to environmental protection, he warns. As Texas gove rnor, Bush appointed representatives of the oil, chemical, and real estate busin esses to run for the Texas pollution control agency.
Several seats on the Supreme Court are expected to open up within the next four years and environmentalists worry that if Bush is elected, while he w ill only be in office four to eight years, his appointments to the Court could harm the environment for decades.
“If the next President packs the court with people like Bush’s role model, Justice Scalia, then our clean air and clean water protections will s uffer profound damage,” says Robert Cox, president of the Sierra Club.
While the Sierra Clubs board of directors recently recogniszed Nad er as having a strong record fighting for the environment, they – like Friends of the Earth – are emphasising the urgency of defeating Bush and so have endorsed Gore.
In early October, the Sierra Club launched a 3 million dollar adverti sement and voter guide campaign in support of Gore, which includes 2 million dol lars for broadcast voter-guide advertisements and an additional 1 million doll ars for printed voter guides with side-by-side comparisons.
“As Vice President, Al Gore helped strengthen clean air health stand ards, sped clean up of Superfund toxic waste sites, reduced automobile tailpipe pollution, and protected America’s spectacular landscapes,” says Cox ..
In highlighting the differences between Gore and Bush, the voter guid es charge that even though Texas leads the United States in toxic industrial ai r pollution, Bush as governor of the large southern state, chose not to require outdated facilities to clean up their pollution. When Bush came into office n 1995, he cancelled the auto emissions testing programme in Houston, T exas.
Also at stake is development of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge i n the state of Alaska. Bush, with his strong ties to oil and gas companies, is intent upon opening this protected reserve to commercial oil production, whi le Gore wants the area to stay off limits to drilling because of its environm ental and ecological value.
Oil executives are eager to tap the riches beneath the frozen tundra – where there are anywhere from 5.6 billion to possibly 16 billion barrels of oil.
But it is also where 150,000 porcupine caribou gather each summer in massive herds and give birth to their young. It is also where millions of mig ratory birds and waterfowl – some as far away as China and Argentina – nest and feed in the summer time.
In general, Bush has stated that he supports increased logging, road building, and mining in wilderness areas. In contrast, the administration of President Bill Clinton and Gore have reduced logging on public lands by 80 percent from 1990 levels. The Forest Service is now taking public com ment on plans to keep millions of hectares of roadless national forests wild and undeveloped.
“If I am entrusted with the presidency, it will be a national priori ty to preserve roadless areas as they are, no ifs, ands or buts about it,” says Gore.
The future of the Kyoto Protocol, global agreement that requires industrialised nations to reduce their heat-trapping greenhouse gas emissions by an average of five percent by 2008-2012, is also at stake. Even though the US Senat e refuses to ratify the treaty, implementing the goals of the accord will be ma de much more difficult if Bush is elected, warn environmental organisations.
While Bush says he believes global warming is real, he opposes the Ky oto Protocol and energy efficiency regulations. Gore strongly supports th e agreement as well as energy conservation.
Despite the differences between Gore and Bush on environmental policy , some environmentalists say Gore is just as tied to polluting corporations as Bush and have decided to back the iconoclastic Green Party candidate Ralph Nader instead.
Saying they will “vote their hopes and not their fears,” a coalitio n of small grass-roots environmental organisations and activists from 25 states formed the ‘Environmentalists Against Gore and For Nader’ in July.
“Vice President Gore has sold out nature whenever oil, timber, and p olluters really put up a fight,” says Tim Hermach, an activist with the Orego n-based Native Forest Council, who helped found the coalition.
Activists are blasting Gore for breaking a promise he made during the 1992 campaign that he would deny a permit for a hazardous waste incinerato r in East Liverpool, Ohio, located near an elementary school.
Although the Environmental Protection Agency, under George Bush senio r, did approve the trial burn permit in 1993, it was the Clinton-Gore Admini stration that gave the approval for full commercial operation of the facility just months after it failed parts of a test burn.
“In the past seven years you have missed many opportunities to honou r your promise to protect the citizens of East Liverpool,” said Ralph Nader , in a letter to Al Gore sent in September.
Rainforest protection activists, co-ordinated by Amazon Watch and oth er groups have been protesting against Gore along each step of the campaign tra il for his connections to Occidental Petroleum. The California-based oil company is drilling for oil on land claimed by the U’wa indigenous tribe living in northeastern Colombia.
The U’wa are adamantly opposed to oil development on their land and h ave warned that if the oil project goes forward the area will become a centre of violent conflict between the military, paramilitaries, and guerrilla factions in the country’s three-decades-old civil war.
According to Gore’s 1998 Public Financial Disclosure Report, he owned between 250,000 and 500,000 in Occidental stock which had been inherited from his father, who died in 1998.
The Gore family and the Los Angeles-based company have been linked fo r generations. Gore’s father worked for Armand Hammer, the founder of O ccidental and funds from the company and its subsidiaries eventually formed the basis of the Gore family fortune
“It’s a time of reckoning for Al Gore, the supposed ‘environmental V ice President’,” says Lauren Sullivan, an activist with the Rainforest A ction Network.