Asia-Pacific, Environment, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT-PACIFIC ISLANDS: Climate Change To Hurt Economies – Big Time

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Nov 22 2000 (IPS) - Already among the world’s most vulnerable nations to the impact of climate change, the small-island states of the Pacific will suffer millions of dollars in damages each year caused by rising sea levels, beach and coral erosion, and more intense storms and droughts over the next century as global temperatures continue to warm, according to a new report released by the World Bank here Tuesday.

But given the uncertainty about the precise impact of climate change on the islands, the report urges local governments to avoid for now large- scale engineering projects, such as the construction of massive sea walls, to protect specific sites.

Instead, the islands should adopt a “no regrets” adaptation policy by taking measures that would be justified under any climate-change scenario, according to the report. Steps taken under such a precautionary policy would be mainly incremental in nature, such as better management of natural resources, especially along coastal areas; improved water collection and conservation measures; and the introduction of weather-resistant crops and farming practices.

But such efforts need to begin now, according to the Bank’s Senior Natural Resources Economist, Sofia Bettencourt who oversaw the study’s preparation.

“The sooner (they) can start preparing for climate change, the better,” she told IPS.

And even these relatively inexpensive measures will be too much for local economies, according to the report, entitled ‘Cities, Sea, and Storms’.

“It is urgent that the international community move rapidly to develop financing mechanisms to help countries on the receiving end of climate change fund ‘no regrets’ adaptation,” said Bettencourt, who also stressed that costs associated with climate change are already being incurred by the islands which can effectively do nothing to stop global warming itself.

The report was released as diplomats from the world’s nations intensified negotiations this week at The Hague on complying with the 1997 Kyoto Protocol which requires industrialised nations to reduce their emissions of greenhouse gases below their 1990 levels. Greenhouse gases, which result from the combustion of oil, gasoline, and a number of other chemicals, are believed by most scientists to be responsible for the warming of the Earth’s surface and the resulting changes in the global climate.

According to the most recent report by the UN-sponsored Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the Earth’s average surface temperature is likely to increase by between 1.5 and 6.1 degrees Centigrade over the next century unless greenhouse-gas emissions are cut back sharply.

This poses major risks for small-island states around the world. Not only must they cope with rising sea levels caused by the melting of polar ice and mountain glaciers, but most atmospheric scientists also agree that warming also increases the intensity, frequency, and violence of tropical storms.

“As the 21st century begins,” the report says, “the Pacific Island people confront a future that will differ drastically from the past.”

Many Pacific island nations, like the Maldives in the Indian Ocean, stand at the global-warming equivalent of “ground zero”. Not only are they especially exposed to storms, including typhoons and cyclones, but some of the more low-lying, populated islands reach only about three metres above sea level at their highest points.

With sea level expected to rise 11-21cms by 2025 and 50-130cms by the year 2100, many islands face serious dangers, particularly during storms. More than half of Tarawa atoll, home to almost half of Kiribati’s 80,000 people, could be completely inundated by a major storm surge under the worst-case scenario predicted for the year 2050.

But the impact of global warming is already a reality, according to the report, which notes that the damages incurred by major storms and extreme weather conditions associated with warming, such as drought, caused the islands more than 1 billion dollars in damages over the past decade.

Coastal eco-systems have been degraded, and people in coastal regions have left their homes, creating squatter settlements in more protected areas.

In addition to the potential damages caused by storms and the loss of infrastructure to coastal erosion and the sea-level rise, the islands face serious threats from prolonged droughts, the failure of subsistence crops and coastal fisheries, losses in coral reefs, and the spread of malaria and dengue fever.

The new study, which is consistent with the most recent IPCC report, stresses both the urgency of the islands’ taking far-reaching measures to adapt to these changes now and the necessity of taking a careful and incremental approach.

In the absence of adaptive measures, according to the report, low- lying islands, such as the Tarawa atoll, could face average annual damages associated with climate change of 6 to 8 million dollars by 2050, equivalent to as much as one-third of the atoll’s gross domestic product (GDP). Those costs could be considerably higher in years of extreme weather, such as cyclones, droughts, and large storm surges, according to the report.

Islands with greater elevation will also not be exempt, according to the report, which cites Viti Levu, the main island in Fiji with a population of about 800,000. If the island does not take adaptive measures, it is likely to suffer an annual average of 23 to 52 million dollars by 2050, equivalent to two to four percent of Fiji’s GDP, according to the report.

There are essentially three possible responses. One is to do nothing to adapt which, according to the report, is the “de facto present position of several Pacific Island countries”.

A second possibility is to “assume the worst and embark upon major investments in coastal protection – such as seawalls – and relocation of vulnerable infrastructure

“The first approach is unwise in light of increasing evidence of climate change,” the report argues. “The second is impractical and unaffordable.”

That leaves a third approach – “a strategy of precautionary adaptation,” – or a “no-regrets” policy” – designed to mitigate the impacts of climate change and avoid measures that could prove culturally, or environmentally disruptive or wasteful.

Thus, instead of building seawalls to protect coastal areas, it may make more sense to increase public awareness, ban the extraction of coral reefs and sand, preserve existing mangroves and plant new ones, according to the report.

To mitigate the impact of drought or storm surges on local water resources, rather than building desalination plants or importing water from abroad, local governments should immediately promote strong conservation measures, the imposition of strict penalties to prevent waste, reforestation, and the expansion of rainwater collection.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags