Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

FINANCE: US, Europeans Play Cat-and-Mouse Over Spy Network

Gumisai Mutume

WASHINGTON, May 13 2001 (IPS) - A European parliamentary committee hit a brick wall this week in their efforts to question US officials about alleged economic spying.

The group was in Washington to investigate the existence of an electronic spying network codenamed Echelon. The United States denies the existence of such a network but Australia has admitted to being a partner in the effort, which reportedly also includes Britain, Canada and New Zealand. The network allegedly monitors global telephone, fax, and email communications.

The committee had been eager to test suspicions that intelligence gleaned this way is then passed on to US corporations to enable them to beat their European competitors to business contracts.

Carlos Coelho, who headed the European delegation, charged in a statement that the group’s meetings with the State and Commerce departments were cancelled at the last minute, and that US intelligence officials declined to meet the committee although arrangements to do so had been made in advance.

The Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) denied the accusation.

“There was never any commitment with the CIA to meet with them,” CIA spokesperson Anya Guilsher said. “The US intelligence community has basically said everything that it can say on this issue and would not want to go into it any further with a foreign committee.”

Officials at the US National Security Agency (NSA), however, confirmed that they had refused to meet the Europeans because they had nothing new to say on the matter.

“We believe that (NSA Director) General (Michael) Hayden’s testimony before the US intelligence oversight committees last year provides a synopsis of NSA’s position on the issues at hand,” the agency said in a statement.

Hayden told a Congressional intelligence committee last year that his organization collects information only for foreign intelligence purposes and provides it only to authorized government recipients.

“This means that NSA is not authorized to provide signals intelligence information to private US companies and we do not do so,” he told the hearing.

Last August, however, US Congresswoman Cynthia McKinney told Britain’s Oxford Union debating society that Echelon indeed monitors global communications.

McKinney acknowledged that EU fears about the use of Echelon for corporate espionage were founded and that information gathered by the network had been used “to defeat an Airbus bid to supply jumbo jets to Saudi Arabia in favour of a Boeing tender.”

“Boeing won the multi-billion-dollar contract thanks to stolen information supplied by Echelon,” she said.

On the strength of similar admissions and numerous investigations, the European parliament mandated a 36-member committee last year to verify the Echelon’s existence, determine whether Echelon contravenes privacy laws, and assess the risks to European industry. The committee’s Washington visit had been intended to gather information for that report.

As it happened, however, Coelho’s group packed their bags and left after meeting officials at the Justice Department and some members of Congress.

The committee’s expressed frustration notwithstanding, “the Europeans probably know more than enough already about Echelon,” said US author William Blum, who has written about the network. “And there is no question that the US is using it for commercial advantage, but the Europeans are doing it too.”

According to the Europeans, Echelon monitors the international telecommunications satellites used by telephone companies in most countries, regional communication satellites, and land-based and under-sea telecom systems.

The network is said to monitor traffic randomly and to zero in on conversations and messages containing keywords programmed into Echelon’s computers. Those conversations and messages are then recorded and forwarded to the countries doing the spying.

The United States and Britain have repeatedly denied the existence of such a programme despite admissions by another member of the group, Australia, that its Defence Signals Directorate forms part of the network.

During the 1970s, Congressional investigating committees found that US government agencies, including NSA, had conducted a number of improper intelligence activities directed against US citizens.

The NSA was required to report on the legal basis for Echelon and similar activities under a law enacted by President Bill Clinton. But the agency’s subsequent report gave few details about the system’s operations and legality.

In a series of studies released last year, the EU noted that unlike many electronic spy systems developed after the cold war, Echelon was designed primarily for non-military targets, including “governments, organizations and businesses in virtually every country.”

Because most economic information is now exchanged electronically, privacy protection is of increasing concern.

Almost every advanced nation practises intelligence involving the covert interception of foreign communications, experts say. Despite assertions that Echelon does not exist, it is widely believed to be the largest effort of this kind, followed by a programme run by Russia.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags