Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS-CANADA: Government Moves Gingerly on Indigenous Self-Rule

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Jul 4 2001 (IPS) - The federal government says it is working to overhaul the Indian Act and hand much of its authority over aboriginal affairs to First Nations, or indigenous communities. The intended beneficiaries remain to be convinced.

Robert Nault, Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development, says the government will consult the country’s 600 indigenous communities in coming months before tabling amendments to the Indian Act in Parliament in the autumn.

The amendments, says Nault, will be “aimed at returning power to the people.”

His assurances have received a cool reception from Native leaders across Canada, including those of the relatively wealthy Siksika Reserve, some 90 kilometres southeast of Calgary in Alberta province, where Nault chose to announce the latest proposals.

Siksika Chief Adrian Stimson says he can’t endorse the consultation process since it is planned to take only a few months. “For our future generations, we must ensure that this initiative does not water down our inherited or treaty rights in any way,” Stimson says.

“We do not agree to a federally imposed First Nations Act without full disclosure of what it entails,” he adds, noting that native leaders have not been shown the draft legislation.

Despite major administrative changes that have seen the strengthening of the power of Native local government, the 125- year-old Indian Act has not been amended in 50 years.

Native groups have often condemned the law; despising everything from its name to the veto power it gives Canada’s government over decisions made by Native governments. The Canadian government retains the power to fire Native chiefs and councilors, overturn Native land-use decisions, and set the rules governing membership in Native communities.

In June, the government angered Native leaders by placing an Ontario reserve in trusteeship, replacing the Native administration with a state-appointed agent. Government officials defended their action by citing the high rate of suicides on the reserve.

The powerful Assembly of First Nations, which has been working with the government on a task force to improve the quality of Native self-government, has not come out with a position on the proposed changes to the Indian Act. However, associations of Native chiefs in Ontario, Saskatchewan and Alberta are boycotting the consultations, saying the government is not giving their groups enough time to develop their own proposals.

“The minister has not heard the voice of the people he says he’s trying to consult,” says Mathew Coon Come, chief of the Assembly of First Nations. “I can’t imagine the minister going into our communities waving this document, saying ‘This will improve your deplorable living conditions’.”

The government’s proposed changes to the Indian Act fall far short of a recent Royal Commission recommendation for full self- government for Canada’s Native peoples but Nault says the government’s amendments are just part of a long-term process by which power will be devolved to Native governments.

One sticking point is that Nault has already said that the government does not plan to give up its powers over Native governments’ status and treaty rights. However, he says the new act will set rules for voting systems for First Nations, balance the interests of on- and off-reserve members and ensure that Native governments have the right tools to operate effectively and the money and expertise to make long-term social and economic plans.

The issue of voting rights and access to Native-run services has been particularly contentious, with several cases now making their way through the courts. Native governments are split on the issue of whether “non-reserve aboriginals”, many of whom live in cities far from reserves, should have the right to run for elected positions on Native councils and be entitled to services paid for with Native community funds.

The Supreme Court recently decided that Natives living off reserves are entitled to the same political rights and services as Natives living on reserves. Canadian Native leaders, however, are demanding the federal government give them the money to offer Native-run social services off reserves.

Nault says Native councils are ready to take on more of the responsibilities of self-government, but he has not yet increased funding for Native agencies.

All First Nations governments operate under the Indian Act but some have made land claims or administrative agreements that give them greater power over local government, law enforcement, health and welfare.

“The governance legislation is aimed at one thing – returning power to the people – and we are moving forward on other important programmes and initiatives. Our treaty relationship and self- government agreements remain priorities for us,” Nault asserts.

However, he says he does not want to negotiate more self- government agreements with Native communities until the Indian Act is amended to change the underlying framework of Native administration.

The minister acknowledges that legal challenges to the Indian Act are driving the legislative process.

“That’s really part and parcel of the urgency of this, that there are more court cases going forward on challenges to the Indian Act, that we’ll have the courts dismantling the Indian Act or changing it for us,” he says.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags