Thursday, November 19, 2026
Tim Shorrock
- Congressional Democrats will shortly unveil trade legislation proposals designed to bridge the labour and environmental divide separating themselves from President George W. Bush and the Republicans. They risk alienating US anti- free trade activists and developing countries opposed to a ‘social clause’ in trade agreements.
The legislation will include labour and environmental provisions thus far opposed by Republicans, says Senator Max Baucus, chairman of the Senate Finance Committee.
“My goal is to get fast track with the widest possible support,” he says, referring to legislation that sets the rules for US negotiations on trade agreements.
Baucus is working on the proposals with leading Democrats in the House of Representatives, including Sander Levin, a Michigan Democrat who played a key role in last year’s passage of a bill granting China normal trade status.
Their efforts to strike a compromise with the Republicans are strongly opposed by labour unions, environmental groups, and economic nationalists that have lobbied against the free-trade agenda. These groups fear that, in order to gain Bush’s support and win favour with a majority in Congress, the proposals on both labour and the environment would be too loose to have significant effect.
“We’re trying to discourage Sen. Baucus from taking this approach,” said Gary Hubbard, a spokesman for the United Steelworkers of America, which led the labour fight against fast track in 1997. That bill, which was sought by the Clinton administration, never gained a majority and was pulled from consideration by the House leadership before it could come to a vote.
By drafting a broad proposal, the Democrats hope to force the Republican leadership in the House to end their opposition to including labour and environmental provisions in Trade Promotion Authority (TPA) legislation. “I think that’s at a dead-end,” said Levin.
Bush is eager to win negotiating authority so he can begin a new round of trade talks that will “ignite a new era of global economic growth,” as he told the World Bank last week. He has also been pushing free trade and the need for TPA at the Group of Eight (G-8) summit in Genoa, Italy.
In a speech here Friday, however, Baucus criticised the administration for not moving more quickly on fast-track.
“So far, this administration’s commitment has been far more rhetorical than real,” he said. “It has produced some vague principles, but made no serious legislative proposal. Despite promises of constructive compromise, the administration seems unwilling to actually engage in the hard negotiations required to make fast track a reality.”
To forge a “real bipartisan trade policy,” Baucus said the administration must begin negotiating with the Democrats in earnest by early September. “If they want fast track, the time for posturing is over.”
The legislation the Democrats hope to push will include provisions requiring countries entering trade agreements with the United States to provide “assurances” they will not lower their labour or environmental standards to gain a competitive advantage; allow countries to restrict trade in goods made by forced or child labour; and propose the creation of a multilateral agreement incorporating environmental issues in trade.
“We can’t write a trade agreement today without environmental issues, and the same goes for labour and labour market issues,” said Levin. “Whatever is relevant in domestic competition becomes relevant in global competition.”
Also under consideration for inclusion in the TPA is a provision, passed in the Senate Finance Committee Jul 19, that renews and strengthens a US Trade Adjustment Assistance programme that provides training funds to workers displaced by imports and shifts in the global economy.
Under the new legislation, the assistance could become available for an entire industry and benefits would be expanded to 78 weeks, from 52 weeks. The current programme expires in September.
Alan Tonelson, a trade analyst with the US Business and Industrial Council who opposes fast track, said the proposals to include worker retraining funds in TPA are coming from “moderates looking for a pass from labour.” The tactic isn’t likely to gain much support with the labour-environmental coalition fighting TPA, he said.
“There’s no substitute for a trade policy that supports manufacturing in this country,” he said. “The best form of job training is a job.”
Democrats may also add provisions to strengthen US powers to protect industries hurt by import surges under Section 201 of the 1974 Trade Act, as well as language that would expand Congress’ role in trade by removing limitations on how such free trade agreements are debated in the legislature.
Many developing countries oppose the inclusion of labour or environmental language in trade agreements.
Ruben Barbosa, Brazil’s ambassador to the United States, said his country would have a difficult time participating in negotiations for a Free Trade Agreement of the Americas if the United States insists on labour and environmental language.
“If TPA includes a reference to sanctions, as far as Brazil is concerned that would be a non-starter,” Barbosa told IPS.
Brazil and other steel exporters are also opposed to the US use of Section 201, which the Bush administration recently invoked in requesting the International Trade Commission to investigate whether a recent surge in steel imports has damaged the US domestic steel industry.
This week, the Senate Finance Committee passed a resolution endorsing Bush’s request to the ITC, underscoring the strong political support for helping steel producers overcome a global market glut caused in part by government-subsidised industries in Asia, Russia and elsewhere.
“Never before has both the president and the Congress requested an ITC investigation,” said Alan Wolff, a former deputy US Trade Representative who is now an attorney for three of the largest US steel producers. He said the Bush administration’s actions on steel “may be central to the compromise on TPA.”
Section 201 is the US version of the “safeguard” and “escape” mechanisms allowed under global trade rules when countries believe their domestic producers are being injured by imports. Countries affected by ITC decisions, however, can take their complaints to the World Trade Organisation.
Levin cautioned against any attempts to weaken the statute as part of a new trade initiative. “In a rapidly globalising world, there has to be room for a safeguard mechanism,” he said.