Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights

RIGHTS: Groups Warn Against Politicising World Court Judges

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Jul 1 2002 (IPS) - The selection of judges for the world’s first International Criminal Court (ICC) is in danger of being undermined by political horse-trading, warned a coalition of more than 1,000 non-governmental organisations (NGOs) Monday.

The proposed selection process could jeopardise the credibility, the moral authority and success of the court, said William Pace of the Coalition for the International Criminal Court (CICC).

“The whole selection process for judicial nominees in the past has been pretty scandalous,” he said, pointing out that in most instances decisions are taken behind closed doors, either by heads of state or justice ministers.

Pace said he feared that historical flaws might be repeated in the selection of judges for the ICC, which formally came into existence on Monday.

The UN Preparatory Commission for the ICC, consisting of representatives of all 189 U.N. member states, began a two-week meeting Monday to approve nomination and election procedures.

The Assembly of States Parties will approve all nominations and election procedures during its first meeting in September. A second meeting of state parties in January next year will elect the prosecutor and the 18 judges of the court.

The statute of the ICC, adopted in Rome in July 1998, has 139 signatories and 75 ratifications. Member states that have not ratified the court include the United States, China and India.

Pace said the judges who will serve in the ICC, the world’s only permanent court that will deal with genocide and war crimes, should be chosen from among persons who are not only of high moral character and integrity but also possess expertise in criminal law or other relevant fields of international law.

The court should also have regional and gender representation, and include judges who represent various legal systems, he added.

Other international judicial bodies, whose judges are mostly political appointees, include the International Court of Justice (ICJ), the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY), the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) and the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (ITLOS).

In past elections for judges, said Pace, countries often traded votes for posts in other U.N. bodies and international institutions. The competence of some of these judges has since been questioned, he added.

U.N. Special Rapporteur on the Independence of Judges and Lawyers, Param Cumaraswamy, also underlined the importance of appointing competent judges to the new body.

“The entire procedure must be based upon the principles of ability, impartiality and transparency – principles that form the basis of any selection procedure based on merit,” he said.

The Rome Statute provides a means of achieving this, by establishing an advisory committee on nominations, added Cumaraswamy.

As occurs in many national legal systems, he said, the committee would receive applications and screen the candidates using questionnaires and interviews.

“The importance that the international community has attributed to the establishment of the ICC, and the faith it has shown in its ability to contribute to the rule of law and international justice, underline the importance of the court’s legitimacy and the integrity of its composition,” Cumaraswamy added.

“It follows that the selection and appointment of the judges to the court must live up to the high expectations of this same community,” he said.

Caroline Baudot of the CICC said her coalition is fully supportive of a Swiss proposal to post the resumes of all candidates on the U.N. website. “This will ensure transparency,” she added.

Historically there have been “glaring disparities” in gender representation among elected posts at the international level, said the New York-based Women’s Caucus for Gender Justice, a member of the NGO coalition.

This includes the international criminal tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda, “where the women serving as judges have been very few in number,” it said.

The work of these tribunals has yielded jurisprudence that recognises rape and other sexual violence as forms of genocide and torture.

Part of the ICC’s mandate is the “fair representation of women and men” at all levels, said the caucus.

“Yet, there will still be the danger of inadequate gender representation on the court unless civil society plays an active role in monitoring the process,” it said.

Pace said it was disappointing that there was also no “major effort” to deal with the appointment of an ICC prosecutor, who he called the “single most important” person in the court.

According to the Rome Statute, the prosecutor will be elected separately from the 18 judges.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags